Is there ageism in oncology?

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    10 Citations (Scopus)

    Abstract

    Objective: To use routine data to explore age-related decision making in the hospital management of colorectal cancer. Design: Retrospective analysis of linked Scottish cancer registry and hospital discharge data for colorectal cancer Setting: All Scottish general hospitals. Participants: All patients on the Scottish colorectal cancer registry 1992-6 (n=15,299). Main Results: Histological verification was used to indicate the "gold standard" of investigation. Definitive surgery and chemotherapy were used as indicators of treatment received. After adjusting for demographic factors, tumour sub-site, co-morbidity and route of first admission, increasing age was associated with markedly decreased rates of histological verification, surgery and chemotherapy. It is still not possible to be sure whether there is ageism in the management of older patients with colorectal cancer However the rate of histological verification fell markedly with increasing age, making it questionable whether decisions to treat were based on best clinical practice at the time. Differences observed between this study and clinical trial data may represent the margin of ageism between everyday clinical practice and controlled conditions. Conclusions : The value of this analysis lies in the fact that the data come from routine clinical practice rather than special studies. The improved content of Scottish cancer register and the ability to link it to hospital care provides a useful baseline for monitoring adherence to clinical guidelines.

    Original languageEnglish
    Pages (from-to)17-20
    Number of pages3
    JournalScottish Medical Journal
    Volume48
    Issue number1
    Publication statusPublished - 2003

    Keywords

    • ageism
    • colorectal cancer
    • cancer registration
    • data linkage
    • clinical guidelines
    • COLORECTAL-CARCINOMA
    • CANCER
    • MORTALITY

    Cite this

    Is there ageism in oncology? / Austin, D.; Russell, Elizabeth M.

    In: Scottish Medical Journal, Vol. 48, No. 1, 2003, p. 17-20.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    Austin, D & Russell, EM 2003, 'Is there ageism in oncology?', Scottish Medical Journal, vol. 48, no. 1, pp. 17-20.
    Austin, D. ; Russell, Elizabeth M. / Is there ageism in oncology?. In: Scottish Medical Journal. 2003 ; Vol. 48, No. 1. pp. 17-20.
    @article{c172f50480a24d9c9873bad14baf28e1,
    title = "Is there ageism in oncology?",
    abstract = "Objective: To use routine data to explore age-related decision making in the hospital management of colorectal cancer. Design: Retrospective analysis of linked Scottish cancer registry and hospital discharge data for colorectal cancer Setting: All Scottish general hospitals. Participants: All patients on the Scottish colorectal cancer registry 1992-6 (n=15,299). Main Results: Histological verification was used to indicate the {"}gold standard{"} of investigation. Definitive surgery and chemotherapy were used as indicators of treatment received. After adjusting for demographic factors, tumour sub-site, co-morbidity and route of first admission, increasing age was associated with markedly decreased rates of histological verification, surgery and chemotherapy. It is still not possible to be sure whether there is ageism in the management of older patients with colorectal cancer However the rate of histological verification fell markedly with increasing age, making it questionable whether decisions to treat were based on best clinical practice at the time. Differences observed between this study and clinical trial data may represent the margin of ageism between everyday clinical practice and controlled conditions. Conclusions : The value of this analysis lies in the fact that the data come from routine clinical practice rather than special studies. The improved content of Scottish cancer register and the ability to link it to hospital care provides a useful baseline for monitoring adherence to clinical guidelines.",
    keywords = "ageism, colorectal cancer, cancer registration, data linkage, clinical guidelines, COLORECTAL-CARCINOMA, CANCER, MORTALITY",
    author = "D. Austin and Russell, {Elizabeth M}",
    year = "2003",
    language = "English",
    volume = "48",
    pages = "17--20",
    journal = "Scottish Medical Journal",
    issn = "0036-9330",
    publisher = "SAGE PUBLICATIONS LTD",
    number = "1",

    }

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Is there ageism in oncology?

    AU - Austin, D.

    AU - Russell, Elizabeth M

    PY - 2003

    Y1 - 2003

    N2 - Objective: To use routine data to explore age-related decision making in the hospital management of colorectal cancer. Design: Retrospective analysis of linked Scottish cancer registry and hospital discharge data for colorectal cancer Setting: All Scottish general hospitals. Participants: All patients on the Scottish colorectal cancer registry 1992-6 (n=15,299). Main Results: Histological verification was used to indicate the "gold standard" of investigation. Definitive surgery and chemotherapy were used as indicators of treatment received. After adjusting for demographic factors, tumour sub-site, co-morbidity and route of first admission, increasing age was associated with markedly decreased rates of histological verification, surgery and chemotherapy. It is still not possible to be sure whether there is ageism in the management of older patients with colorectal cancer However the rate of histological verification fell markedly with increasing age, making it questionable whether decisions to treat were based on best clinical practice at the time. Differences observed between this study and clinical trial data may represent the margin of ageism between everyday clinical practice and controlled conditions. Conclusions : The value of this analysis lies in the fact that the data come from routine clinical practice rather than special studies. The improved content of Scottish cancer register and the ability to link it to hospital care provides a useful baseline for monitoring adherence to clinical guidelines.

    AB - Objective: To use routine data to explore age-related decision making in the hospital management of colorectal cancer. Design: Retrospective analysis of linked Scottish cancer registry and hospital discharge data for colorectal cancer Setting: All Scottish general hospitals. Participants: All patients on the Scottish colorectal cancer registry 1992-6 (n=15,299). Main Results: Histological verification was used to indicate the "gold standard" of investigation. Definitive surgery and chemotherapy were used as indicators of treatment received. After adjusting for demographic factors, tumour sub-site, co-morbidity and route of first admission, increasing age was associated with markedly decreased rates of histological verification, surgery and chemotherapy. It is still not possible to be sure whether there is ageism in the management of older patients with colorectal cancer However the rate of histological verification fell markedly with increasing age, making it questionable whether decisions to treat were based on best clinical practice at the time. Differences observed between this study and clinical trial data may represent the margin of ageism between everyday clinical practice and controlled conditions. Conclusions : The value of this analysis lies in the fact that the data come from routine clinical practice rather than special studies. The improved content of Scottish cancer register and the ability to link it to hospital care provides a useful baseline for monitoring adherence to clinical guidelines.

    KW - ageism

    KW - colorectal cancer

    KW - cancer registration

    KW - data linkage

    KW - clinical guidelines

    KW - COLORECTAL-CARCINOMA

    KW - CANCER

    KW - MORTALITY

    M3 - Article

    VL - 48

    SP - 17

    EP - 20

    JO - Scottish Medical Journal

    JF - Scottish Medical Journal

    SN - 0036-9330

    IS - 1

    ER -