"It's making contacts": notions of social capital and implications for widening access to medical education

S. Nicholson, J. A. Cleland

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

14 Citations (Scopus)
6 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

In the UK widening access (WA) activities and policies aim to increase the representation from lower socio-economic groups into Higher Education. Whilst linked to a political rhetoric of inclusive education such initiatives have however failed to significantly increase the number of such students entering medicine. This is compounded by a discourse that portrays WA applicants and students as lacking the essential skills or attributes to be successful in medical education. Much of the research in this area to date has been weak and it is critical to better understand how WA applicants and students negotiate medical admissions and education to inform change. To address this gap we amalgamated a larger dataset from three qualitative studies of student experiences of WA to medicine (48 participants in total). Inductively analysing the findings using social capital as a theoretical lens we created and clustered codes into categories, informed by the concepts of "weak ties" and "bridging and linking capital", terms used by previous workers in this field, to better understand student journeys in medical education. Successful applicants from lower socio-economic groups recognise and mobilise weak ties to create linking capital. However once in medical school these students seem less aware of the need for, or how to create, capital effectively. We argue WA activities should support increasing the social capital of under-represented applicants and students, and future selection policy needs to take into account the varying social capital of students, so as to not overtly disadvantage some social groups.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)477-490
Number of pages14
JournalAdvances in Health Sciences Education
Volume22
Issue number2
Early online date14 Nov 2016
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - May 2017

Fingerprint

social capital
contact
applicant
education
student
medicine
economics
medical student
rhetoric
Group
worker
discourse
school
experience

Keywords

  • lower socio-economic groups
  • meritocracy
  • social capital
  • undergraduate medical education
  • under-representation
  • weak ties, bridging and linking capital
  • widening access

Cite this

"It's making contacts" : notions of social capital and implications for widening access to medical education. / Nicholson, S.; Cleland, J. A.

In: Advances in Health Sciences Education, Vol. 22, No. 2, 05.2017, p. 477-490.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{738d0f0517fa4d09bfa3acc8ef74e699,
title = "{"}It's making contacts{"}: notions of social capital and implications for widening access to medical education",
abstract = "In the UK widening access (WA) activities and policies aim to increase the representation from lower socio-economic groups into Higher Education. Whilst linked to a political rhetoric of inclusive education such initiatives have however failed to significantly increase the number of such students entering medicine. This is compounded by a discourse that portrays WA applicants and students as lacking the essential skills or attributes to be successful in medical education. Much of the research in this area to date has been weak and it is critical to better understand how WA applicants and students negotiate medical admissions and education to inform change. To address this gap we amalgamated a larger dataset from three qualitative studies of student experiences of WA to medicine (48 participants in total). Inductively analysing the findings using social capital as a theoretical lens we created and clustered codes into categories, informed by the concepts of {"}weak ties{"} and {"}bridging and linking capital{"}, terms used by previous workers in this field, to better understand student journeys in medical education. Successful applicants from lower socio-economic groups recognise and mobilise weak ties to create linking capital. However once in medical school these students seem less aware of the need for, or how to create, capital effectively. We argue WA activities should support increasing the social capital of under-represented applicants and students, and future selection policy needs to take into account the varying social capital of students, so as to not overtly disadvantage some social groups.",
keywords = "lower socio-economic groups, meritocracy, social capital, undergraduate medical education, under-representation, weak ties, bridging and linking capital, widening access",
author = "S. Nicholson and Cleland, {J. A.}",
note = "Acknowledgements Our thanks to the Medical Schools Council (MSC) of the UK for funding Study A; REACH Scotland for funding Study B; and Queen Mary University of London, and to the medical school applicants and students who gave their time to be interviewed. Our thanks also to Dr Sean Zhou and Dr Sally Curtis, and Manjul Medhi, for their help with data collection for studies A and B respectively. Our thanks also to Dr Lara Varpio, Uniformed Services University of the USA, for her advice and guidance on collating data sets and her comments on the draft manuscript.",
year = "2017",
month = "5",
doi = "10.1007/s10459-016-9735-0",
language = "English",
volume = "22",
pages = "477--490",
journal = "Advances in Health Sciences Education",
issn = "1382-4996",
publisher = "Springer Netherlands",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - "It's making contacts"

T2 - notions of social capital and implications for widening access to medical education

AU - Nicholson, S.

AU - Cleland, J. A.

N1 - Acknowledgements Our thanks to the Medical Schools Council (MSC) of the UK for funding Study A; REACH Scotland for funding Study B; and Queen Mary University of London, and to the medical school applicants and students who gave their time to be interviewed. Our thanks also to Dr Sean Zhou and Dr Sally Curtis, and Manjul Medhi, for their help with data collection for studies A and B respectively. Our thanks also to Dr Lara Varpio, Uniformed Services University of the USA, for her advice and guidance on collating data sets and her comments on the draft manuscript.

PY - 2017/5

Y1 - 2017/5

N2 - In the UK widening access (WA) activities and policies aim to increase the representation from lower socio-economic groups into Higher Education. Whilst linked to a political rhetoric of inclusive education such initiatives have however failed to significantly increase the number of such students entering medicine. This is compounded by a discourse that portrays WA applicants and students as lacking the essential skills or attributes to be successful in medical education. Much of the research in this area to date has been weak and it is critical to better understand how WA applicants and students negotiate medical admissions and education to inform change. To address this gap we amalgamated a larger dataset from three qualitative studies of student experiences of WA to medicine (48 participants in total). Inductively analysing the findings using social capital as a theoretical lens we created and clustered codes into categories, informed by the concepts of "weak ties" and "bridging and linking capital", terms used by previous workers in this field, to better understand student journeys in medical education. Successful applicants from lower socio-economic groups recognise and mobilise weak ties to create linking capital. However once in medical school these students seem less aware of the need for, or how to create, capital effectively. We argue WA activities should support increasing the social capital of under-represented applicants and students, and future selection policy needs to take into account the varying social capital of students, so as to not overtly disadvantage some social groups.

AB - In the UK widening access (WA) activities and policies aim to increase the representation from lower socio-economic groups into Higher Education. Whilst linked to a political rhetoric of inclusive education such initiatives have however failed to significantly increase the number of such students entering medicine. This is compounded by a discourse that portrays WA applicants and students as lacking the essential skills or attributes to be successful in medical education. Much of the research in this area to date has been weak and it is critical to better understand how WA applicants and students negotiate medical admissions and education to inform change. To address this gap we amalgamated a larger dataset from three qualitative studies of student experiences of WA to medicine (48 participants in total). Inductively analysing the findings using social capital as a theoretical lens we created and clustered codes into categories, informed by the concepts of "weak ties" and "bridging and linking capital", terms used by previous workers in this field, to better understand student journeys in medical education. Successful applicants from lower socio-economic groups recognise and mobilise weak ties to create linking capital. However once in medical school these students seem less aware of the need for, or how to create, capital effectively. We argue WA activities should support increasing the social capital of under-represented applicants and students, and future selection policy needs to take into account the varying social capital of students, so as to not overtly disadvantage some social groups.

KW - lower socio-economic groups

KW - meritocracy

KW - social capital

KW - undergraduate medical education

KW - under-representation

KW - weak ties, bridging and linking capital

KW - widening access

U2 - 10.1007/s10459-016-9735-0

DO - 10.1007/s10459-016-9735-0

M3 - Article

C2 - 27844179

VL - 22

SP - 477

EP - 490

JO - Advances in Health Sciences Education

JF - Advances in Health Sciences Education

SN - 1382-4996

IS - 2

ER -