Land use not litter quality is a stronger driver of decomposition in hyperdiverse tropical forest

Sabine Both (Corresponding Author), Dafydd Elias, Ully H Kritzler, Nick J. Ostle, David Johnson

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

4 Citations (Scopus)
5 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

In hyperdiverse tropical forests, the key drivers of litter decomposition are poorly understood despite its crucial role in facilitating nutrient availability for plants and microbes. Selective logging is a pressing land use with potential for considerable impacts on plant–soil interactions, litter decomposition, and nutrient cycling. Here, in Borneo's tropical rainforests, we test the hypothesis that decomposition is driven by litter quality and that there is a significant “home-field advantage,” that is positive interaction between local litter quality and land use. We determined mass loss of leaf litter, collected from selectively logged and old-growth forest, in a fully factorial experimental design, using meshes that either allowed or precluded access by mesofauna. We measured leaf litter chemical composition before and after the experiment. Key soil chemical and biological properties and microclimatic conditions were measured as land-use descriptors. We found that despite substantial differences in litter quality, the main driver of decomposition was land-use type. Whilst inclusion of mesofauna accelerated decomposition, their effect was independent of land use and litter quality. Decomposition of all litters was slower in selectively logged forest than in old-growth forest. However, there was significantly greater loss of nutrients from litter, especially phosphorus, in selectively logged forest. The analyses of several covariates detected minor microclimatic differences between land-use types but no alterations in soil chemical properties or free-living microbial composition. These results demonstrate that selective logging can significantly reduce litter decomposition in tropical rainforest with no evidence of a home-field advantage. We show that loss of key limiting nutrients from litter (P & N) is greater in selectively logged forest. Overall, the findings hint at subtle differences in microclimate overriding litter quality that result in reduced decomposition rates in selectively logged forests and potentially affect biogeochemical nutrient cycling in the long term.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)9307-9318
Number of pages12
JournalEcology and Evolution
Volume7
Issue number22
Early online date4 Oct 2017
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Nov 2017

Fingerprint

tropical forests
tropical forest
litter
land use
decomposition
degradation
old-growth forests
tropical rain forests
soil chemical properties
plant litter
selective logging
logging
biogeochemical cycles
old-growth forest
nutrient cycling
leaf litter
rainforest
soil biological properties
nutrients
pressing

Keywords

  • Borneo
  • leaf litter chemistry
  • litterbags
  • old-growth forest
  • phospholipid fatty acids
  • Sabah
  • selectively logged forest

Cite this

Land use not litter quality is a stronger driver of decomposition in hyperdiverse tropical forest. / Both, Sabine (Corresponding Author); Elias, Dafydd; Kritzler, Ully H; Ostle, Nick J.; Johnson, David.

In: Ecology and Evolution, Vol. 7, No. 22, 11.2017, p. 9307-9318.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Both, Sabine ; Elias, Dafydd ; Kritzler, Ully H ; Ostle, Nick J. ; Johnson, David. / Land use not litter quality is a stronger driver of decomposition in hyperdiverse tropical forest. In: Ecology and Evolution. 2017 ; Vol. 7, No. 22. pp. 9307-9318.
@article{ca76231d84b241279a88b3d385f435da,
title = "Land use not litter quality is a stronger driver of decomposition in hyperdiverse tropical forest",
abstract = "In hyperdiverse tropical forests, the key drivers of litter decomposition are poorly understood despite its crucial role in facilitating nutrient availability for plants and microbes. Selective logging is a pressing land use with potential for considerable impacts on plant–soil interactions, litter decomposition, and nutrient cycling. Here, in Borneo's tropical rainforests, we test the hypothesis that decomposition is driven by litter quality and that there is a significant “home-field advantage,” that is positive interaction between local litter quality and land use. We determined mass loss of leaf litter, collected from selectively logged and old-growth forest, in a fully factorial experimental design, using meshes that either allowed or precluded access by mesofauna. We measured leaf litter chemical composition before and after the experiment. Key soil chemical and biological properties and microclimatic conditions were measured as land-use descriptors. We found that despite substantial differences in litter quality, the main driver of decomposition was land-use type. Whilst inclusion of mesofauna accelerated decomposition, their effect was independent of land use and litter quality. Decomposition of all litters was slower in selectively logged forest than in old-growth forest. However, there was significantly greater loss of nutrients from litter, especially phosphorus, in selectively logged forest. The analyses of several covariates detected minor microclimatic differences between land-use types but no alterations in soil chemical properties or free-living microbial composition. These results demonstrate that selective logging can significantly reduce litter decomposition in tropical rainforest with no evidence of a home-field advantage. We show that loss of key limiting nutrients from litter (P & N) is greater in selectively logged forest. Overall, the findings hint at subtle differences in microclimate overriding litter quality that result in reduced decomposition rates in selectively logged forests and potentially affect biogeochemical nutrient cycling in the long term.",
keywords = "Borneo, leaf litter chemistry, litterbags, old-growth forest , phospholipid fatty acids, Sabah, selectively logged forest",
author = "Sabine Both and Dafydd Elias and Kritzler, {Ully H} and Ostle, {Nick J.} and David Johnson",
note = "Funded by Natural Environment Research Council. Grant Number: NE/K016253/1",
year = "2017",
month = "11",
doi = "10.1002/ece3.3460",
language = "English",
volume = "7",
pages = "9307--9318",
journal = "Ecology and Evolution",
issn = "2045-7758",
publisher = "Wiley",
number = "22",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Land use not litter quality is a stronger driver of decomposition in hyperdiverse tropical forest

AU - Both, Sabine

AU - Elias, Dafydd

AU - Kritzler, Ully H

AU - Ostle, Nick J.

AU - Johnson, David

N1 - Funded by Natural Environment Research Council. Grant Number: NE/K016253/1

PY - 2017/11

Y1 - 2017/11

N2 - In hyperdiverse tropical forests, the key drivers of litter decomposition are poorly understood despite its crucial role in facilitating nutrient availability for plants and microbes. Selective logging is a pressing land use with potential for considerable impacts on plant–soil interactions, litter decomposition, and nutrient cycling. Here, in Borneo's tropical rainforests, we test the hypothesis that decomposition is driven by litter quality and that there is a significant “home-field advantage,” that is positive interaction between local litter quality and land use. We determined mass loss of leaf litter, collected from selectively logged and old-growth forest, in a fully factorial experimental design, using meshes that either allowed or precluded access by mesofauna. We measured leaf litter chemical composition before and after the experiment. Key soil chemical and biological properties and microclimatic conditions were measured as land-use descriptors. We found that despite substantial differences in litter quality, the main driver of decomposition was land-use type. Whilst inclusion of mesofauna accelerated decomposition, their effect was independent of land use and litter quality. Decomposition of all litters was slower in selectively logged forest than in old-growth forest. However, there was significantly greater loss of nutrients from litter, especially phosphorus, in selectively logged forest. The analyses of several covariates detected minor microclimatic differences between land-use types but no alterations in soil chemical properties or free-living microbial composition. These results demonstrate that selective logging can significantly reduce litter decomposition in tropical rainforest with no evidence of a home-field advantage. We show that loss of key limiting nutrients from litter (P & N) is greater in selectively logged forest. Overall, the findings hint at subtle differences in microclimate overriding litter quality that result in reduced decomposition rates in selectively logged forests and potentially affect biogeochemical nutrient cycling in the long term.

AB - In hyperdiverse tropical forests, the key drivers of litter decomposition are poorly understood despite its crucial role in facilitating nutrient availability for plants and microbes. Selective logging is a pressing land use with potential for considerable impacts on plant–soil interactions, litter decomposition, and nutrient cycling. Here, in Borneo's tropical rainforests, we test the hypothesis that decomposition is driven by litter quality and that there is a significant “home-field advantage,” that is positive interaction between local litter quality and land use. We determined mass loss of leaf litter, collected from selectively logged and old-growth forest, in a fully factorial experimental design, using meshes that either allowed or precluded access by mesofauna. We measured leaf litter chemical composition before and after the experiment. Key soil chemical and biological properties and microclimatic conditions were measured as land-use descriptors. We found that despite substantial differences in litter quality, the main driver of decomposition was land-use type. Whilst inclusion of mesofauna accelerated decomposition, their effect was independent of land use and litter quality. Decomposition of all litters was slower in selectively logged forest than in old-growth forest. However, there was significantly greater loss of nutrients from litter, especially phosphorus, in selectively logged forest. The analyses of several covariates detected minor microclimatic differences between land-use types but no alterations in soil chemical properties or free-living microbial composition. These results demonstrate that selective logging can significantly reduce litter decomposition in tropical rainforest with no evidence of a home-field advantage. We show that loss of key limiting nutrients from litter (P & N) is greater in selectively logged forest. Overall, the findings hint at subtle differences in microclimate overriding litter quality that result in reduced decomposition rates in selectively logged forests and potentially affect biogeochemical nutrient cycling in the long term.

KW - Borneo

KW - leaf litter chemistry

KW - litterbags

KW - old-growth forest

KW - phospholipid fatty acids

KW - Sabah

KW - selectively logged forest

U2 - 10.1002/ece3.3460

DO - 10.1002/ece3.3460

M3 - Article

VL - 7

SP - 9307

EP - 9318

JO - Ecology and Evolution

JF - Ecology and Evolution

SN - 2045-7758

IS - 22

ER -