Living and Dying with a Disability in Debtor Society

Why Context Matters in Assisted Suicide Debates

Brian Brock (Corresponding Author)

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Economic rationalities are a central component of the malignant social positioning of people with all sorts of disability and mental health issues today. This paper traces the role of economic rationality in positioning some lives today as not really worth living. This widespread willingness of the general populace in western liberal democracies to map their political relations in economic terms is historically novel in the west, and is one of the more noteworthy marks the transition points into, and out of, Christendom. The paper examines the impact of the rise of the cultural settlement called Christendom for social outsiders, suggesting that they provide illuminating contrasts with some of the characteristic practices and moral assumptions of our contemporary western liberal democracies. The conclusion of the paper is that a society without a working account of mercy and forgiveness will find it difficult conceptually to explicate practices associated with valuing human lives which are considered non-contributors within accounts of political life grounded in economic rationalities.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)331-351
Number of pages21
JournalJournal of Disability & Religion
Volume22
Issue number3
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2018

Fingerprint

Assisted Suicide
assisted suicide
dying
disability
Economics
rationality
Democracy
economics
Forgiveness
democracy
political relations
Mental Health
mental health
Society
Economic Rationality
Suicide
Dying
Liberal Democracy
Positioning
Christendom

Keywords

  • value of life
  • disability
  • euthanasia
  • Christian theology
  • eugenics

Cite this

@article{ccd3af6b76af4ac1ac260017be17c406,
title = "Living and Dying with a Disability in Debtor Society: Why Context Matters in Assisted Suicide Debates",
abstract = "Economic rationalities are a central component of the malignant social positioning of people with all sorts of disability and mental health issues today. This paper traces the role of economic rationality in positioning some lives today as not really worth living. This widespread willingness of the general populace in western liberal democracies to map their political relations in economic terms is historically novel in the west, and is one of the more noteworthy marks the transition points into, and out of, Christendom. The paper examines the impact of the rise of the cultural settlement called Christendom for social outsiders, suggesting that they provide illuminating contrasts with some of the characteristic practices and moral assumptions of our contemporary western liberal democracies. The conclusion of the paper is that a society without a working account of mercy and forgiveness will find it difficult conceptually to explicate practices associated with valuing human lives which are considered non-contributors within accounts of political life grounded in economic rationalities.",
keywords = "value of life, disability, euthanasia, Christian theology, eugenics",
author = "Brian Brock",
year = "2018",
doi = "10.1080/23312521.2018.1540386",
language = "English",
volume = "22",
pages = "331--351",
journal = "Journal of Disability & Religion",
issn = "2331-2521",
publisher = "Taylor and Francis Ltd.",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Living and Dying with a Disability in Debtor Society

T2 - Why Context Matters in Assisted Suicide Debates

AU - Brock, Brian

PY - 2018

Y1 - 2018

N2 - Economic rationalities are a central component of the malignant social positioning of people with all sorts of disability and mental health issues today. This paper traces the role of economic rationality in positioning some lives today as not really worth living. This widespread willingness of the general populace in western liberal democracies to map their political relations in economic terms is historically novel in the west, and is one of the more noteworthy marks the transition points into, and out of, Christendom. The paper examines the impact of the rise of the cultural settlement called Christendom for social outsiders, suggesting that they provide illuminating contrasts with some of the characteristic practices and moral assumptions of our contemporary western liberal democracies. The conclusion of the paper is that a society without a working account of mercy and forgiveness will find it difficult conceptually to explicate practices associated with valuing human lives which are considered non-contributors within accounts of political life grounded in economic rationalities.

AB - Economic rationalities are a central component of the malignant social positioning of people with all sorts of disability and mental health issues today. This paper traces the role of economic rationality in positioning some lives today as not really worth living. This widespread willingness of the general populace in western liberal democracies to map their political relations in economic terms is historically novel in the west, and is one of the more noteworthy marks the transition points into, and out of, Christendom. The paper examines the impact of the rise of the cultural settlement called Christendom for social outsiders, suggesting that they provide illuminating contrasts with some of the characteristic practices and moral assumptions of our contemporary western liberal democracies. The conclusion of the paper is that a society without a working account of mercy and forgiveness will find it difficult conceptually to explicate practices associated with valuing human lives which are considered non-contributors within accounts of political life grounded in economic rationalities.

KW - value of life

KW - disability

KW - euthanasia

KW - Christian theology

KW - eugenics

U2 - 10.1080/23312521.2018.1540386

DO - 10.1080/23312521.2018.1540386

M3 - Article

VL - 22

SP - 331

EP - 351

JO - Journal of Disability & Religion

JF - Journal of Disability & Religion

SN - 2331-2521

IS - 3

ER -