Managing a moral identity in debt advice conversations

Nicole Andelic* (Corresponding Author), Clifford Stevenson, Aidan Feeney

*Corresponding author for this work

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Previous research has found that stigma can be a barrier to service-use but there has been little work examining actual service encounters involving members of stigmatised groups. One such group are those with problematic or unmanageable debts. Providing advice to members of this group is likely to be particularly difficult due to the stigma associated with being in debt. Using conversation analysis and discursive psychology, this study examines twelve telephone advice conversations between debt advisors and individuals in debt. Both clients and advisors oriented to the negative moral implications of indebtedness and typically worked collaboratively to manage these issues. Clients often claimed a moral disposition as a way to disclaim any unwanted associations with debt, but could find it difficult to reconcile this with an insolvency agreement. Moreover, the institutional requirements of the interaction could disrupt the collaborative management of stigma and advisors could manage the subsequent resistance from clients in either client-centred or institution-centred ways. The findings suggest that the products offered by debt advice agencies, as well as the manner in which they are offered to clients, can either help or hinder debtors negotiate the stigma-related barriers to service-engagement.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)630-648
Number of pages19
JournalBritish Journal of Social Psychology
Volume58
Issue number3
Early online date5 Dec 2018
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Jul 2019

Fingerprint

Telephone
Psychology
Research

Keywords

  • advice-giving
  • conversation analysis
  • discursive psychology
  • institutional talk
  • personal debt
  • service-use
  • stigma

Cite this

Managing a moral identity in debt advice conversations. / Andelic, Nicole (Corresponding Author); Stevenson, Clifford; Feeney, Aidan.

In: British Journal of Social Psychology, Vol. 58, No. 3, 07.2019, p. 630-648.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Andelic, Nicole ; Stevenson, Clifford ; Feeney, Aidan. / Managing a moral identity in debt advice conversations. In: British Journal of Social Psychology. 2019 ; Vol. 58, No. 3. pp. 630-648.
@article{95be2cc840d14ac185a51d71ac736d87,
title = "Managing a moral identity in debt advice conversations",
abstract = "Previous research has found that stigma can be a barrier to service-use but there has been little work examining actual service encounters involving members of stigmatised groups. One such group are those with problematic or unmanageable debts. Providing advice to members of this group is likely to be particularly difficult due to the stigma associated with being in debt. Using conversation analysis and discursive psychology, this study examines twelve telephone advice conversations between debt advisors and individuals in debt. Both clients and advisors oriented to the negative moral implications of indebtedness and typically worked collaboratively to manage these issues. Clients often claimed a moral disposition as a way to disclaim any unwanted associations with debt, but could find it difficult to reconcile this with an insolvency agreement. Moreover, the institutional requirements of the interaction could disrupt the collaborative management of stigma and advisors could manage the subsequent resistance from clients in either client-centred or institution-centred ways. The findings suggest that the products offered by debt advice agencies, as well as the manner in which they are offered to clients, can either help or hinder debtors negotiate the stigma-related barriers to service-engagement.",
keywords = "advice-giving, conversation analysis, discursive psychology, institutional talk, personal debt, service-use, stigma",
author = "Nicole Andelic and Clifford Stevenson and Aidan Feeney",
note = "The study was jointly funded by the Economic and Social Research Council [ES/S010882/1], the Business Alliance at Queen's University Belfast and Aperture IVA, the company whose clients participated in the research.",
year = "2019",
month = "7",
doi = "10.1111/bjso.12303",
language = "English",
volume = "58",
pages = "630--648",
journal = "British Journal of Social Psychology",
issn = "0144-6665",
publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Managing a moral identity in debt advice conversations

AU - Andelic, Nicole

AU - Stevenson, Clifford

AU - Feeney, Aidan

N1 - The study was jointly funded by the Economic and Social Research Council [ES/S010882/1], the Business Alliance at Queen's University Belfast and Aperture IVA, the company whose clients participated in the research.

PY - 2019/7

Y1 - 2019/7

N2 - Previous research has found that stigma can be a barrier to service-use but there has been little work examining actual service encounters involving members of stigmatised groups. One such group are those with problematic or unmanageable debts. Providing advice to members of this group is likely to be particularly difficult due to the stigma associated with being in debt. Using conversation analysis and discursive psychology, this study examines twelve telephone advice conversations between debt advisors and individuals in debt. Both clients and advisors oriented to the negative moral implications of indebtedness and typically worked collaboratively to manage these issues. Clients often claimed a moral disposition as a way to disclaim any unwanted associations with debt, but could find it difficult to reconcile this with an insolvency agreement. Moreover, the institutional requirements of the interaction could disrupt the collaborative management of stigma and advisors could manage the subsequent resistance from clients in either client-centred or institution-centred ways. The findings suggest that the products offered by debt advice agencies, as well as the manner in which they are offered to clients, can either help or hinder debtors negotiate the stigma-related barriers to service-engagement.

AB - Previous research has found that stigma can be a barrier to service-use but there has been little work examining actual service encounters involving members of stigmatised groups. One such group are those with problematic or unmanageable debts. Providing advice to members of this group is likely to be particularly difficult due to the stigma associated with being in debt. Using conversation analysis and discursive psychology, this study examines twelve telephone advice conversations between debt advisors and individuals in debt. Both clients and advisors oriented to the negative moral implications of indebtedness and typically worked collaboratively to manage these issues. Clients often claimed a moral disposition as a way to disclaim any unwanted associations with debt, but could find it difficult to reconcile this with an insolvency agreement. Moreover, the institutional requirements of the interaction could disrupt the collaborative management of stigma and advisors could manage the subsequent resistance from clients in either client-centred or institution-centred ways. The findings suggest that the products offered by debt advice agencies, as well as the manner in which they are offered to clients, can either help or hinder debtors negotiate the stigma-related barriers to service-engagement.

KW - advice-giving

KW - conversation analysis

KW - discursive psychology

KW - institutional talk

KW - personal debt

KW - service-use

KW - stigma

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85069965114&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1111/bjso.12303

DO - 10.1111/bjso.12303

M3 - Article

VL - 58

SP - 630

EP - 648

JO - British Journal of Social Psychology

JF - British Journal of Social Psychology

SN - 0144-6665

IS - 3

ER -