Meta-analyses of whale-watching impact studies: differences and similarities in disturbance responses among species

Valeria Senigaglia, Fredrik Oscar Christiansen, L. Bejder, D Gendron, D J Lundquist, D Noren, A Schaffar, J Smith, R Williams, David Lusseau

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

Abstract

Whale-watching activities are known to induce behavioural changes that are compatible with anti-predatory responses. However anti-predatory responses can vary depending on the species, population and/or site-specific environmental features. This variability makes it challenging to evaluate whale-watching disturbance and multiple metrics should therefore be used for any impact study. In this study we used meta-analyses to assess the consistency of anti-predatory responses among several studies on whale-watching disturbance. Changes in swimming speed, activity budget, inter-breath intervals, and deviation and directness index were used as proxies to measure whale-watching disturbance. We also assessed if these changes were due to extrinsic factors (the presence of whale watching regulations), intrinsic factors (species and animal body size) or environmental factors (habitat type). Our results showed that changes in the activity budget and directness and deviation index were the most consistently reliable metrics in capturing cetacean responses to whale-watching disturbance. Animals were more likely to travel and less likely to rest and forage (Q7=81.2, p< 0.0001, k=8; Q5=23.2, p=0.0003, k= 7; Q7=49.5, p< 0.0001, k=8) as a consequence of whale-watching presence. Body size also had an effect on resting activity with smaller animals being less likely to rest in the presence of boats (Q1=4.1, p=0.04, k=7). Our results showed a generalized tendency of cetaceans to increase their path sinuosity (deviation index) and decrease path linearity (directness index) in response to whale-watching disturbance (Q= 24.6, p= < 0.0001, τ2=0.09, k=5; Q= 8.94; p= 0.03, τ2=0.05, k=5). Path linearity and predictability also increased in corridor type habitats (SMD=1.55; p=0.004, k=5). We found that cetaceans overall showed similar anti-predatory responses to whale-watching activities. These behavioural changes reflect greater direct energy expenditure and fewer opportunities for energy recovery respectively and may cause long-term consequences to population fitness. We conclude with highlighting the validity of a meta-analytical approach in studying anthropogenic disturbances.
Original languageEnglish
Publication statusPublished - Dec 2013
EventThe 20th Biennial Conference on the Biology of Marine Mammals - The University of Otago, Dunedin, New Zealand
Duration: 9 Dec 201313 Dec 2013

Conference

ConferenceThe 20th Biennial Conference on the Biology of Marine Mammals
CountryNew Zealand
CityDunedin
Period9/12/1313/12/13

Fingerprint

Whales
Meta-Analysis
Body Size
Budgets
Ecosystem
Intrinsic Factor
Ships
Proxy
Health Expenditures
Energy Metabolism
Population

Cite this

Senigaglia, V., Christiansen, F. O., Bejder, L., Gendron, D., Lundquist, D. J., Noren, D., ... Lusseau, D. (2013). Meta-analyses of whale-watching impact studies: differences and similarities in disturbance responses among species. Paper presented at The 20th Biennial Conference on the Biology of Marine Mammals, Dunedin, New Zealand.

Meta-analyses of whale-watching impact studies: differences and similarities in disturbance responses among species. / Senigaglia, Valeria; Christiansen, Fredrik Oscar; Bejder, L.; Gendron, D; Lundquist, D J; Noren, D; Schaffar, A; Smith, J; Williams, R; Lusseau, David.

2013. Paper presented at The 20th Biennial Conference on the Biology of Marine Mammals, Dunedin, New Zealand.

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

Senigaglia, V, Christiansen, FO, Bejder, L, Gendron, D, Lundquist, DJ, Noren, D, Schaffar, A, Smith, J, Williams, R & Lusseau, D 2013, 'Meta-analyses of whale-watching impact studies: differences and similarities in disturbance responses among species' Paper presented at The 20th Biennial Conference on the Biology of Marine Mammals, Dunedin, New Zealand, 9/12/13 - 13/12/13, .
Senigaglia V, Christiansen FO, Bejder L, Gendron D, Lundquist DJ, Noren D et al. Meta-analyses of whale-watching impact studies: differences and similarities in disturbance responses among species. 2013. Paper presented at The 20th Biennial Conference on the Biology of Marine Mammals, Dunedin, New Zealand.
Senigaglia, Valeria ; Christiansen, Fredrik Oscar ; Bejder, L. ; Gendron, D ; Lundquist, D J ; Noren, D ; Schaffar, A ; Smith, J ; Williams, R ; Lusseau, David. / Meta-analyses of whale-watching impact studies: differences and similarities in disturbance responses among species. Paper presented at The 20th Biennial Conference on the Biology of Marine Mammals, Dunedin, New Zealand.
@conference{636549ac5e684e73971d6ba0dbf17615,
title = "Meta-analyses of whale-watching impact studies: differences and similarities in disturbance responses among species",
abstract = "Whale-watching activities are known to induce behavioural changes that are compatible with anti-predatory responses. However anti-predatory responses can vary depending on the species, population and/or site-specific environmental features. This variability makes it challenging to evaluate whale-watching disturbance and multiple metrics should therefore be used for any impact study. In this study we used meta-analyses to assess the consistency of anti-predatory responses among several studies on whale-watching disturbance. Changes in swimming speed, activity budget, inter-breath intervals, and deviation and directness index were used as proxies to measure whale-watching disturbance. We also assessed if these changes were due to extrinsic factors (the presence of whale watching regulations), intrinsic factors (species and animal body size) or environmental factors (habitat type). Our results showed that changes in the activity budget and directness and deviation index were the most consistently reliable metrics in capturing cetacean responses to whale-watching disturbance. Animals were more likely to travel and less likely to rest and forage (Q7=81.2, p< 0.0001, k=8; Q5=23.2, p=0.0003, k= 7; Q7=49.5, p< 0.0001, k=8) as a consequence of whale-watching presence. Body size also had an effect on resting activity with smaller animals being less likely to rest in the presence of boats (Q1=4.1, p=0.04, k=7). Our results showed a generalized tendency of cetaceans to increase their path sinuosity (deviation index) and decrease path linearity (directness index) in response to whale-watching disturbance (Q= 24.6, p= < 0.0001, τ2=0.09, k=5; Q= 8.94; p= 0.03, τ2=0.05, k=5). Path linearity and predictability also increased in corridor type habitats (SMD=1.55; p=0.004, k=5). We found that cetaceans overall showed similar anti-predatory responses to whale-watching activities. These behavioural changes reflect greater direct energy expenditure and fewer opportunities for energy recovery respectively and may cause long-term consequences to population fitness. We conclude with highlighting the validity of a meta-analytical approach in studying anthropogenic disturbances.",
author = "Valeria Senigaglia and Christiansen, {Fredrik Oscar} and L. Bejder and D Gendron and Lundquist, {D J} and D Noren and A Schaffar and J Smith and R Williams and David Lusseau",
year = "2013",
month = "12",
language = "English",
note = "The 20th Biennial Conference on the Biology of Marine Mammals ; Conference date: 09-12-2013 Through 13-12-2013",

}

TY - CONF

T1 - Meta-analyses of whale-watching impact studies: differences and similarities in disturbance responses among species

AU - Senigaglia, Valeria

AU - Christiansen, Fredrik Oscar

AU - Bejder, L.

AU - Gendron, D

AU - Lundquist, D J

AU - Noren, D

AU - Schaffar, A

AU - Smith, J

AU - Williams, R

AU - Lusseau, David

PY - 2013/12

Y1 - 2013/12

N2 - Whale-watching activities are known to induce behavioural changes that are compatible with anti-predatory responses. However anti-predatory responses can vary depending on the species, population and/or site-specific environmental features. This variability makes it challenging to evaluate whale-watching disturbance and multiple metrics should therefore be used for any impact study. In this study we used meta-analyses to assess the consistency of anti-predatory responses among several studies on whale-watching disturbance. Changes in swimming speed, activity budget, inter-breath intervals, and deviation and directness index were used as proxies to measure whale-watching disturbance. We also assessed if these changes were due to extrinsic factors (the presence of whale watching regulations), intrinsic factors (species and animal body size) or environmental factors (habitat type). Our results showed that changes in the activity budget and directness and deviation index were the most consistently reliable metrics in capturing cetacean responses to whale-watching disturbance. Animals were more likely to travel and less likely to rest and forage (Q7=81.2, p< 0.0001, k=8; Q5=23.2, p=0.0003, k= 7; Q7=49.5, p< 0.0001, k=8) as a consequence of whale-watching presence. Body size also had an effect on resting activity with smaller animals being less likely to rest in the presence of boats (Q1=4.1, p=0.04, k=7). Our results showed a generalized tendency of cetaceans to increase their path sinuosity (deviation index) and decrease path linearity (directness index) in response to whale-watching disturbance (Q= 24.6, p= < 0.0001, τ2=0.09, k=5; Q= 8.94; p= 0.03, τ2=0.05, k=5). Path linearity and predictability also increased in corridor type habitats (SMD=1.55; p=0.004, k=5). We found that cetaceans overall showed similar anti-predatory responses to whale-watching activities. These behavioural changes reflect greater direct energy expenditure and fewer opportunities for energy recovery respectively and may cause long-term consequences to population fitness. We conclude with highlighting the validity of a meta-analytical approach in studying anthropogenic disturbances.

AB - Whale-watching activities are known to induce behavioural changes that are compatible with anti-predatory responses. However anti-predatory responses can vary depending on the species, population and/or site-specific environmental features. This variability makes it challenging to evaluate whale-watching disturbance and multiple metrics should therefore be used for any impact study. In this study we used meta-analyses to assess the consistency of anti-predatory responses among several studies on whale-watching disturbance. Changes in swimming speed, activity budget, inter-breath intervals, and deviation and directness index were used as proxies to measure whale-watching disturbance. We also assessed if these changes were due to extrinsic factors (the presence of whale watching regulations), intrinsic factors (species and animal body size) or environmental factors (habitat type). Our results showed that changes in the activity budget and directness and deviation index were the most consistently reliable metrics in capturing cetacean responses to whale-watching disturbance. Animals were more likely to travel and less likely to rest and forage (Q7=81.2, p< 0.0001, k=8; Q5=23.2, p=0.0003, k= 7; Q7=49.5, p< 0.0001, k=8) as a consequence of whale-watching presence. Body size also had an effect on resting activity with smaller animals being less likely to rest in the presence of boats (Q1=4.1, p=0.04, k=7). Our results showed a generalized tendency of cetaceans to increase their path sinuosity (deviation index) and decrease path linearity (directness index) in response to whale-watching disturbance (Q= 24.6, p= < 0.0001, τ2=0.09, k=5; Q= 8.94; p= 0.03, τ2=0.05, k=5). Path linearity and predictability also increased in corridor type habitats (SMD=1.55; p=0.004, k=5). We found that cetaceans overall showed similar anti-predatory responses to whale-watching activities. These behavioural changes reflect greater direct energy expenditure and fewer opportunities for energy recovery respectively and may cause long-term consequences to population fitness. We conclude with highlighting the validity of a meta-analytical approach in studying anthropogenic disturbances.

M3 - Paper

ER -