More of the same?

Conflicting perspectives of obesity causation and intervention amongst overweight people, health professionals and policy makers

Joe Greener, Flora Douglas, Edwin van Teijlingen

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

63 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

This paper presents the findings of a qualitative study conducted in the United Kingdom of the perceptions of overweight individuals, as well as health professionals and policy makers working in the area of obesity prevention and weight management. In 2006-2007, we conducted interviews with 34 men and women (18-50 years old) who self identified as being overweight; 20 health professionals; and 9 policy makers. We explored their understandings of the causes of obesity/overweight; beliefs about factors that enabled or inhibited weight loss/gain; and opinions regarding effective obesity/overweight interventions. We found a range of views, which corresponded with biomedical and socio-ecological perspectives of health and disease. The lay overweight respondents viewed the problem of obesity arising from their personal shortcomings (i.e. motivational and physical), juxtaposed to blame-absolving accounts often involving specific challenges associated with day-to-day living. All respondents presented personal stories of complex battles of short-term weight loss and longer-term weight gain, usually characterised by a sense of failure. All expressed a strong sense of personal responsibility to overcome their weight problems, and looked to another not-yet-tried, technocratic weight loss programme to address the problem, despite all reporting past failures. Health professionals and policy makers on the other hand viewed obesity as a socio-ecologically determined problem, detailing social and environmental explanations. Health professionals were more inclined towards individual-orientated weight management interventions as effective responses. Policy makers considered environmental and social policy changes as most likely to make a substantial difference to current obesity trends, but considered it unlikely that such policies would be implemented without the political will and popular support. Our data highlight dissonance between policy maker, health professional and public obesity perceptions and points to a challenge for those who believe that wholesale systemic change is required if obesity trends are to be reduced or halted.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)1042-1049
Number of pages8
JournalSocial Science & Medicine
Volume70
Issue number7
Early online date26 Jan 2010
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Apr 2010

Fingerprint

Health Policy
Administrative Personnel
health policy
Causality
health professionals
Obesity
Weights and Measures
social problem
Weight Gain
Weight Loss
trend
Health
management
environmental policy
Environmental Policy
Weight Reduction Programs
Politicians
Health Professionals
Causation
Social Problems

Keywords

  • administrative personnel
  • adolescent
  • adult
  • attitude of health personnel
  • attitude to health
  • dissent and disputes
  • female
  • Great Britain
  • health policy
  • humans
  • interviews as topic
  • male
  • middle aged
  • obesity
  • overweight
  • qualitative research
  • social environment
  • young adult
  • obesogenic environments
  • lay beliefs
  • attitudes
  • UK

Cite this

More of the same? Conflicting perspectives of obesity causation and intervention amongst overweight people, health professionals and policy makers. / Greener, Joe; Douglas, Flora; van Teijlingen, Edwin.

In: Social Science & Medicine, Vol. 70, No. 7, 04.2010, p. 1042-1049.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{86c62a9653694ec8af00cf07bc44be80,
title = "More of the same?: Conflicting perspectives of obesity causation and intervention amongst overweight people, health professionals and policy makers",
abstract = "This paper presents the findings of a qualitative study conducted in the United Kingdom of the perceptions of overweight individuals, as well as health professionals and policy makers working in the area of obesity prevention and weight management. In 2006-2007, we conducted interviews with 34 men and women (18-50 years old) who self identified as being overweight; 20 health professionals; and 9 policy makers. We explored their understandings of the causes of obesity/overweight; beliefs about factors that enabled or inhibited weight loss/gain; and opinions regarding effective obesity/overweight interventions. We found a range of views, which corresponded with biomedical and socio-ecological perspectives of health and disease. The lay overweight respondents viewed the problem of obesity arising from their personal shortcomings (i.e. motivational and physical), juxtaposed to blame-absolving accounts often involving specific challenges associated with day-to-day living. All respondents presented personal stories of complex battles of short-term weight loss and longer-term weight gain, usually characterised by a sense of failure. All expressed a strong sense of personal responsibility to overcome their weight problems, and looked to another not-yet-tried, technocratic weight loss programme to address the problem, despite all reporting past failures. Health professionals and policy makers on the other hand viewed obesity as a socio-ecologically determined problem, detailing social and environmental explanations. Health professionals were more inclined towards individual-orientated weight management interventions as effective responses. Policy makers considered environmental and social policy changes as most likely to make a substantial difference to current obesity trends, but considered it unlikely that such policies would be implemented without the political will and popular support. Our data highlight dissonance between policy maker, health professional and public obesity perceptions and points to a challenge for those who believe that wholesale systemic change is required if obesity trends are to be reduced or halted.",
keywords = "administrative personnel, adolescent, adult, attitude of health personnel, attitude to health, dissent and disputes, female, Great Britain, health policy, humans, interviews as topic, male, middle aged, obesity, overweight, qualitative research, social environment, young adult, obesogenic environments, lay beliefs, attitudes, UK",
author = "Joe Greener and Flora Douglas and {van Teijlingen}, Edwin",
note = "(c) 2010 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.",
year = "2010",
month = "4",
doi = "10.1016/j.socscimed.2009.11.017",
language = "English",
volume = "70",
pages = "1042--1049",
journal = "Social Science & Medicine",
issn = "0277-9536",
publisher = "Elsevier Limited",
number = "7",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - More of the same?

T2 - Conflicting perspectives of obesity causation and intervention amongst overweight people, health professionals and policy makers

AU - Greener, Joe

AU - Douglas, Flora

AU - van Teijlingen, Edwin

N1 - (c) 2010 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

PY - 2010/4

Y1 - 2010/4

N2 - This paper presents the findings of a qualitative study conducted in the United Kingdom of the perceptions of overweight individuals, as well as health professionals and policy makers working in the area of obesity prevention and weight management. In 2006-2007, we conducted interviews with 34 men and women (18-50 years old) who self identified as being overweight; 20 health professionals; and 9 policy makers. We explored their understandings of the causes of obesity/overweight; beliefs about factors that enabled or inhibited weight loss/gain; and opinions regarding effective obesity/overweight interventions. We found a range of views, which corresponded with biomedical and socio-ecological perspectives of health and disease. The lay overweight respondents viewed the problem of obesity arising from their personal shortcomings (i.e. motivational and physical), juxtaposed to blame-absolving accounts often involving specific challenges associated with day-to-day living. All respondents presented personal stories of complex battles of short-term weight loss and longer-term weight gain, usually characterised by a sense of failure. All expressed a strong sense of personal responsibility to overcome their weight problems, and looked to another not-yet-tried, technocratic weight loss programme to address the problem, despite all reporting past failures. Health professionals and policy makers on the other hand viewed obesity as a socio-ecologically determined problem, detailing social and environmental explanations. Health professionals were more inclined towards individual-orientated weight management interventions as effective responses. Policy makers considered environmental and social policy changes as most likely to make a substantial difference to current obesity trends, but considered it unlikely that such policies would be implemented without the political will and popular support. Our data highlight dissonance between policy maker, health professional and public obesity perceptions and points to a challenge for those who believe that wholesale systemic change is required if obesity trends are to be reduced or halted.

AB - This paper presents the findings of a qualitative study conducted in the United Kingdom of the perceptions of overweight individuals, as well as health professionals and policy makers working in the area of obesity prevention and weight management. In 2006-2007, we conducted interviews with 34 men and women (18-50 years old) who self identified as being overweight; 20 health professionals; and 9 policy makers. We explored their understandings of the causes of obesity/overweight; beliefs about factors that enabled or inhibited weight loss/gain; and opinions regarding effective obesity/overweight interventions. We found a range of views, which corresponded with biomedical and socio-ecological perspectives of health and disease. The lay overweight respondents viewed the problem of obesity arising from their personal shortcomings (i.e. motivational and physical), juxtaposed to blame-absolving accounts often involving specific challenges associated with day-to-day living. All respondents presented personal stories of complex battles of short-term weight loss and longer-term weight gain, usually characterised by a sense of failure. All expressed a strong sense of personal responsibility to overcome their weight problems, and looked to another not-yet-tried, technocratic weight loss programme to address the problem, despite all reporting past failures. Health professionals and policy makers on the other hand viewed obesity as a socio-ecologically determined problem, detailing social and environmental explanations. Health professionals were more inclined towards individual-orientated weight management interventions as effective responses. Policy makers considered environmental and social policy changes as most likely to make a substantial difference to current obesity trends, but considered it unlikely that such policies would be implemented without the political will and popular support. Our data highlight dissonance between policy maker, health professional and public obesity perceptions and points to a challenge for those who believe that wholesale systemic change is required if obesity trends are to be reduced or halted.

KW - administrative personnel

KW - adolescent

KW - adult

KW - attitude of health personnel

KW - attitude to health

KW - dissent and disputes

KW - female

KW - Great Britain

KW - health policy

KW - humans

KW - interviews as topic

KW - male

KW - middle aged

KW - obesity

KW - overweight

KW - qualitative research

KW - social environment

KW - young adult

KW - obesogenic environments

KW - lay beliefs

KW - attitudes

KW - UK

U2 - 10.1016/j.socscimed.2009.11.017

DO - 10.1016/j.socscimed.2009.11.017

M3 - Article

VL - 70

SP - 1042

EP - 1049

JO - Social Science & Medicine

JF - Social Science & Medicine

SN - 0277-9536

IS - 7

ER -