Motion coherence and direction discrimination in healthy aging

Karin S. Pilz, Louisa Miller, Hannah C. Agnew

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

9 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Perceptual functions change with age, particularly motion perception. With regards to healthy ageing, previous studies mostly measured motion coherence thresholds for coarse motion direction discrimination along cardinal axes of motion. Here, we investigated age-related changes in the ability to discriminate between small angular differences in motion directions, which allows for a more specific assessment of age-related decline and its underlying mechanisms. We first assessed older (>60 years) and younger (<30 years) participants’ ability to discriminate coarse horizontal (left/right) and vertical (up/down) motion at 100% coherence and a stimulus duration of 400ms. In a second step, we determined participants’ motion coherence thresholds for vertical and horizontal coarse motion direction discrimination. In a third step, we used the individually determined motion coherence thresholds and tested fine motion direction discrimination for motion clockwise away from horizontal and vertical motion. Older adults performed as well as younger adults for discriminating motion away from vertical. Surprisingly, performance for discriminating motion away from horizontal was strongly decreased. Further analyses, however, showed a relationship between motion coherence thresholds for horizontal coarse motion direction discrimination and fine motion direction discrimination performance in older adults. In a control experiment, using motion coherence above threshold for all conditions, the difference in performance for horizontal and vertical fine motion direction discrimination for older adults disappeared. These results clearly contradict the notion of an overall age-related decline in motion perception, and, most importantly, highlight the importance of taking into account individual differences when assessing age-related changes in perceptual functions.
Original languageEnglish
Article number31
JournalJournal of Vision
Volume17
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 31 Jan 2017

Fingerprint

Motion Perception
Direction compound
Discrimination (Psychology)
Aptitude
Individuality
Young Adult

Keywords

  • motion perception
  • healthy aging
  • visual perception
  • direction discrimination
  • motion coherence

Cite this

Motion coherence and direction discrimination in healthy aging. / Pilz, Karin S.; Miller, Louisa; Agnew, Hannah C.

In: Journal of Vision, Vol. 17, 31, 31.01.2017.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Pilz, Karin S. ; Miller, Louisa ; Agnew, Hannah C. / Motion coherence and direction discrimination in healthy aging. In: Journal of Vision. 2017 ; Vol. 17.
@article{05a57ec2b0dc429db2f313a22a521ffc,
title = "Motion coherence and direction discrimination in healthy aging",
abstract = "Perceptual functions change with age, particularly motion perception. With regards to healthy ageing, previous studies mostly measured motion coherence thresholds for coarse motion direction discrimination along cardinal axes of motion. Here, we investigated age-related changes in the ability to discriminate between small angular differences in motion directions, which allows for a more specific assessment of age-related decline and its underlying mechanisms. We first assessed older (>60 years) and younger (<30 years) participants’ ability to discriminate coarse horizontal (left/right) and vertical (up/down) motion at 100{\%} coherence and a stimulus duration of 400ms. In a second step, we determined participants’ motion coherence thresholds for vertical and horizontal coarse motion direction discrimination. In a third step, we used the individually determined motion coherence thresholds and tested fine motion direction discrimination for motion clockwise away from horizontal and vertical motion. Older adults performed as well as younger adults for discriminating motion away from vertical. Surprisingly, performance for discriminating motion away from horizontal was strongly decreased. Further analyses, however, showed a relationship between motion coherence thresholds for horizontal coarse motion direction discrimination and fine motion direction discrimination performance in older adults. In a control experiment, using motion coherence above threshold for all conditions, the difference in performance for horizontal and vertical fine motion direction discrimination for older adults disappeared. These results clearly contradict the notion of an overall age-related decline in motion perception, and, most importantly, highlight the importance of taking into account individual differences when assessing age-related changes in perceptual functions.",
keywords = "motion perception, healthy aging, visual perception, direction discrimination, motion coherence",
author = "Pilz, {Karin S.} and Louisa Miller and Agnew, {Hannah C.}",
note = "This work was supported by a BBSRC grant to KSP (BB/K007173/1). Commercial relationships: none. Corresponding author: Karin S. Pilz. Email: k.s.pilz@abdn.ac.uk. Address: School of Psychology, William Guild Building, University of Aberdeen, Scotland, UK.",
year = "2017",
month = "1",
day = "31",
doi = "10.1167/17.1.31",
language = "English",
volume = "17",
journal = "Journal of Vision",
issn = "1534-7362",
publisher = "Association for Research in Vision and Ophthalmology Inc.",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Motion coherence and direction discrimination in healthy aging

AU - Pilz, Karin S.

AU - Miller, Louisa

AU - Agnew, Hannah C.

N1 - This work was supported by a BBSRC grant to KSP (BB/K007173/1). Commercial relationships: none. Corresponding author: Karin S. Pilz. Email: k.s.pilz@abdn.ac.uk. Address: School of Psychology, William Guild Building, University of Aberdeen, Scotland, UK.

PY - 2017/1/31

Y1 - 2017/1/31

N2 - Perceptual functions change with age, particularly motion perception. With regards to healthy ageing, previous studies mostly measured motion coherence thresholds for coarse motion direction discrimination along cardinal axes of motion. Here, we investigated age-related changes in the ability to discriminate between small angular differences in motion directions, which allows for a more specific assessment of age-related decline and its underlying mechanisms. We first assessed older (>60 years) and younger (<30 years) participants’ ability to discriminate coarse horizontal (left/right) and vertical (up/down) motion at 100% coherence and a stimulus duration of 400ms. In a second step, we determined participants’ motion coherence thresholds for vertical and horizontal coarse motion direction discrimination. In a third step, we used the individually determined motion coherence thresholds and tested fine motion direction discrimination for motion clockwise away from horizontal and vertical motion. Older adults performed as well as younger adults for discriminating motion away from vertical. Surprisingly, performance for discriminating motion away from horizontal was strongly decreased. Further analyses, however, showed a relationship between motion coherence thresholds for horizontal coarse motion direction discrimination and fine motion direction discrimination performance in older adults. In a control experiment, using motion coherence above threshold for all conditions, the difference in performance for horizontal and vertical fine motion direction discrimination for older adults disappeared. These results clearly contradict the notion of an overall age-related decline in motion perception, and, most importantly, highlight the importance of taking into account individual differences when assessing age-related changes in perceptual functions.

AB - Perceptual functions change with age, particularly motion perception. With regards to healthy ageing, previous studies mostly measured motion coherence thresholds for coarse motion direction discrimination along cardinal axes of motion. Here, we investigated age-related changes in the ability to discriminate between small angular differences in motion directions, which allows for a more specific assessment of age-related decline and its underlying mechanisms. We first assessed older (>60 years) and younger (<30 years) participants’ ability to discriminate coarse horizontal (left/right) and vertical (up/down) motion at 100% coherence and a stimulus duration of 400ms. In a second step, we determined participants’ motion coherence thresholds for vertical and horizontal coarse motion direction discrimination. In a third step, we used the individually determined motion coherence thresholds and tested fine motion direction discrimination for motion clockwise away from horizontal and vertical motion. Older adults performed as well as younger adults for discriminating motion away from vertical. Surprisingly, performance for discriminating motion away from horizontal was strongly decreased. Further analyses, however, showed a relationship between motion coherence thresholds for horizontal coarse motion direction discrimination and fine motion direction discrimination performance in older adults. In a control experiment, using motion coherence above threshold for all conditions, the difference in performance for horizontal and vertical fine motion direction discrimination for older adults disappeared. These results clearly contradict the notion of an overall age-related decline in motion perception, and, most importantly, highlight the importance of taking into account individual differences when assessing age-related changes in perceptual functions.

KW - motion perception

KW - healthy aging

KW - visual perception

KW - direction discrimination

KW - motion coherence

U2 - 10.1167/17.1.31

DO - 10.1167/17.1.31

M3 - Article

VL - 17

JO - Journal of Vision

JF - Journal of Vision

SN - 1534-7362

M1 - 31

ER -