Motivated shortcomings in explanation

The role of comparative self-evaluation and awareness of explanation recipient's knowledge

Devin G. Ray, Josephine Neugebauer, Kai Sassenberg, Juergen Buder, Friedrich W. Hesse

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

12 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Being aware of someone else's existing knowledge is a prerequisite to effectively adapting an explanation to that person's learning needs. However, such knowledge awareness introduces the potential for motivated self-evaluation based on relative knowledge, that is, for social comparison. Because favorable social comparisons are actively defended, we propose that knowledge awareness might undermine information sharing in explanation when social comparison motives are active. We tested this hypothesis in a series of experiments in which participants provided explanations to an ostensible learning partner with or without knowledge awareness. Both dispositionally and situationally motivated social comparison interacted with knowledge awareness to reduce information sharing in explanation. Intriguingly, knowledge awareness uniformly facilitated adaptation of the information that was shared to address partner knowledge deficit. These results illustrate a tension in the components of effective explanation. At the same time that knowledge awareness effectively coordinates explanation content, it can lead to knowledge hoarding by knowledgeable explainers who are motivated to rely on knowledge differences between the self and the explanation recipient for self-evaluation.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)445-457
Number of pages13
JournalJournal of Experimental Psychology: General
Volume142
Issue number2
Early online date16 Jul 2012
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - May 2013

Fingerprint

Diagnostic Self Evaluation
Information Dissemination
Learning
Ego

Cite this

Motivated shortcomings in explanation : The role of comparative self-evaluation and awareness of explanation recipient's knowledge. / Ray, Devin G. ; Neugebauer, Josephine; Sassenberg, Kai; Buder, Juergen; Hesse, Friedrich W. .

In: Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, Vol. 142, No. 2, 05.2013, p. 445-457.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Ray, Devin G. ; Neugebauer, Josephine ; Sassenberg, Kai ; Buder, Juergen ; Hesse, Friedrich W. . / Motivated shortcomings in explanation : The role of comparative self-evaluation and awareness of explanation recipient's knowledge. In: Journal of Experimental Psychology: General. 2013 ; Vol. 142, No. 2. pp. 445-457.
@article{5c490b5d27f04048896f971bb357302c,
title = "Motivated shortcomings in explanation: The role of comparative self-evaluation and awareness of explanation recipient's knowledge",
abstract = "Being aware of someone else's existing knowledge is a prerequisite to effectively adapting an explanation to that person's learning needs. However, such knowledge awareness introduces the potential for motivated self-evaluation based on relative knowledge, that is, for social comparison. Because favorable social comparisons are actively defended, we propose that knowledge awareness might undermine information sharing in explanation when social comparison motives are active. We tested this hypothesis in a series of experiments in which participants provided explanations to an ostensible learning partner with or without knowledge awareness. Both dispositionally and situationally motivated social comparison interacted with knowledge awareness to reduce information sharing in explanation. Intriguingly, knowledge awareness uniformly facilitated adaptation of the information that was shared to address partner knowledge deficit. These results illustrate a tension in the components of effective explanation. At the same time that knowledge awareness effectively coordinates explanation content, it can lead to knowledge hoarding by knowledgeable explainers who are motivated to rely on knowledge differences between the self and the explanation recipient for self-evaluation.",
author = "Ray, {Devin G.} and Josephine Neugebauer and Kai Sassenberg and Juergen Buder and Hesse, {Friedrich W.}",
year = "2013",
month = "5",
doi = "10.1037/a0029339",
language = "English",
volume = "142",
pages = "445--457",
journal = "Journal of Experimental Psychology: General",
issn = "0096-3445",
publisher = "American Psychological Association Inc.",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Motivated shortcomings in explanation

T2 - The role of comparative self-evaluation and awareness of explanation recipient's knowledge

AU - Ray, Devin G.

AU - Neugebauer, Josephine

AU - Sassenberg, Kai

AU - Buder, Juergen

AU - Hesse, Friedrich W.

PY - 2013/5

Y1 - 2013/5

N2 - Being aware of someone else's existing knowledge is a prerequisite to effectively adapting an explanation to that person's learning needs. However, such knowledge awareness introduces the potential for motivated self-evaluation based on relative knowledge, that is, for social comparison. Because favorable social comparisons are actively defended, we propose that knowledge awareness might undermine information sharing in explanation when social comparison motives are active. We tested this hypothesis in a series of experiments in which participants provided explanations to an ostensible learning partner with or without knowledge awareness. Both dispositionally and situationally motivated social comparison interacted with knowledge awareness to reduce information sharing in explanation. Intriguingly, knowledge awareness uniformly facilitated adaptation of the information that was shared to address partner knowledge deficit. These results illustrate a tension in the components of effective explanation. At the same time that knowledge awareness effectively coordinates explanation content, it can lead to knowledge hoarding by knowledgeable explainers who are motivated to rely on knowledge differences between the self and the explanation recipient for self-evaluation.

AB - Being aware of someone else's existing knowledge is a prerequisite to effectively adapting an explanation to that person's learning needs. However, such knowledge awareness introduces the potential for motivated self-evaluation based on relative knowledge, that is, for social comparison. Because favorable social comparisons are actively defended, we propose that knowledge awareness might undermine information sharing in explanation when social comparison motives are active. We tested this hypothesis in a series of experiments in which participants provided explanations to an ostensible learning partner with or without knowledge awareness. Both dispositionally and situationally motivated social comparison interacted with knowledge awareness to reduce information sharing in explanation. Intriguingly, knowledge awareness uniformly facilitated adaptation of the information that was shared to address partner knowledge deficit. These results illustrate a tension in the components of effective explanation. At the same time that knowledge awareness effectively coordinates explanation content, it can lead to knowledge hoarding by knowledgeable explainers who are motivated to rely on knowledge differences between the self and the explanation recipient for self-evaluation.

U2 - 10.1037/a0029339

DO - 10.1037/a0029339

M3 - Article

VL - 142

SP - 445

EP - 457

JO - Journal of Experimental Psychology: General

JF - Journal of Experimental Psychology: General

SN - 0096-3445

IS - 2

ER -