Multivariate statistical and other approaches for the separation of cereal from wild Poaceae pollen using a large Holocene dataset

J C Tweddle, Kevin J. Edwards, N R J Fieller

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

71 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The separation of the pollen of wild Poaceae species from that of domesticated cereal crops is of considerable importance to palynologists studying Holocene vegetational and agricultural change. Studies of the characteristics of modern pollen populations indicate that it may be possible to distinguish cereal pollen from that of many ( but not all) undomesticated Poaceae species, though there are few detailed investigations into the applicability of such studies to palaeoecological samples. This paper assesses the reliability of available keys for identifying sub-fossil grass pollen using a large Holocene dataset obtained from a series of well-dated profiles from lowland Yorkshire, England. Pollen within the dataset is classified using the keys of Andersen ( Danmarks Geol Undersogelse, Arbog, 1978, 69 - 92, 1979) and Kuster ( 1988), and the resulting identifications are compared. The possibilities of combining the two approaches and employing the multivariate statistical techniques of principal component and discriminant analysis to achieve greater confidence of identification are then investigated. Finally, the findings of the above analyses are used to discuss the interpretation of incidences of large Poaceae pollen (i.e. > 37 mm grain diameter as measured in silicone oil) within the palynological record, particularly during prehistory. The outcomes of this study will be of relevance to other investigations in which careful identification of large grass pollen is desirable, but where preservation or other factors prohibit accurate or confident identification of pollen surface pattern.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)15-30
Number of pages16
JournalVegetation History and Archaeobotany
Volume14
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2005

Keywords

  • Palynology
  • Holocene
  • Poaceae
  • cereal pollen
  • multivariate statistics
  • Yorkshire
  • England
  • ELM-DECLINE
  • IRELAND

Cite this

@article{28ae06275de846198fcca26abb2189a4,
title = "Multivariate statistical and other approaches for the separation of cereal from wild Poaceae pollen using a large Holocene dataset",
abstract = "The separation of the pollen of wild Poaceae species from that of domesticated cereal crops is of considerable importance to palynologists studying Holocene vegetational and agricultural change. Studies of the characteristics of modern pollen populations indicate that it may be possible to distinguish cereal pollen from that of many ( but not all) undomesticated Poaceae species, though there are few detailed investigations into the applicability of such studies to palaeoecological samples. This paper assesses the reliability of available keys for identifying sub-fossil grass pollen using a large Holocene dataset obtained from a series of well-dated profiles from lowland Yorkshire, England. Pollen within the dataset is classified using the keys of Andersen ( Danmarks Geol Undersogelse, Arbog, 1978, 69 - 92, 1979) and Kuster ( 1988), and the resulting identifications are compared. The possibilities of combining the two approaches and employing the multivariate statistical techniques of principal component and discriminant analysis to achieve greater confidence of identification are then investigated. Finally, the findings of the above analyses are used to discuss the interpretation of incidences of large Poaceae pollen (i.e. > 37 mm grain diameter as measured in silicone oil) within the palynological record, particularly during prehistory. The outcomes of this study will be of relevance to other investigations in which careful identification of large grass pollen is desirable, but where preservation or other factors prohibit accurate or confident identification of pollen surface pattern.",
keywords = "Palynology, Holocene, Poaceae, cereal pollen, multivariate statistics, Yorkshire, England, ELM-DECLINE, IRELAND",
author = "Tweddle, {J C} and Edwards, {Kevin J.} and Fieller, {N R J}",
year = "2005",
doi = "10.1007/s00334-005-0064-0",
language = "English",
volume = "14",
pages = "15--30",
journal = "Vegetation History and Archaeobotany",
issn = "0939-6314",
publisher = "Springer New York",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Multivariate statistical and other approaches for the separation of cereal from wild Poaceae pollen using a large Holocene dataset

AU - Tweddle, J C

AU - Edwards, Kevin J.

AU - Fieller, N R J

PY - 2005

Y1 - 2005

N2 - The separation of the pollen of wild Poaceae species from that of domesticated cereal crops is of considerable importance to palynologists studying Holocene vegetational and agricultural change. Studies of the characteristics of modern pollen populations indicate that it may be possible to distinguish cereal pollen from that of many ( but not all) undomesticated Poaceae species, though there are few detailed investigations into the applicability of such studies to palaeoecological samples. This paper assesses the reliability of available keys for identifying sub-fossil grass pollen using a large Holocene dataset obtained from a series of well-dated profiles from lowland Yorkshire, England. Pollen within the dataset is classified using the keys of Andersen ( Danmarks Geol Undersogelse, Arbog, 1978, 69 - 92, 1979) and Kuster ( 1988), and the resulting identifications are compared. The possibilities of combining the two approaches and employing the multivariate statistical techniques of principal component and discriminant analysis to achieve greater confidence of identification are then investigated. Finally, the findings of the above analyses are used to discuss the interpretation of incidences of large Poaceae pollen (i.e. > 37 mm grain diameter as measured in silicone oil) within the palynological record, particularly during prehistory. The outcomes of this study will be of relevance to other investigations in which careful identification of large grass pollen is desirable, but where preservation or other factors prohibit accurate or confident identification of pollen surface pattern.

AB - The separation of the pollen of wild Poaceae species from that of domesticated cereal crops is of considerable importance to palynologists studying Holocene vegetational and agricultural change. Studies of the characteristics of modern pollen populations indicate that it may be possible to distinguish cereal pollen from that of many ( but not all) undomesticated Poaceae species, though there are few detailed investigations into the applicability of such studies to palaeoecological samples. This paper assesses the reliability of available keys for identifying sub-fossil grass pollen using a large Holocene dataset obtained from a series of well-dated profiles from lowland Yorkshire, England. Pollen within the dataset is classified using the keys of Andersen ( Danmarks Geol Undersogelse, Arbog, 1978, 69 - 92, 1979) and Kuster ( 1988), and the resulting identifications are compared. The possibilities of combining the two approaches and employing the multivariate statistical techniques of principal component and discriminant analysis to achieve greater confidence of identification are then investigated. Finally, the findings of the above analyses are used to discuss the interpretation of incidences of large Poaceae pollen (i.e. > 37 mm grain diameter as measured in silicone oil) within the palynological record, particularly during prehistory. The outcomes of this study will be of relevance to other investigations in which careful identification of large grass pollen is desirable, but where preservation or other factors prohibit accurate or confident identification of pollen surface pattern.

KW - Palynology

KW - Holocene

KW - Poaceae

KW - cereal pollen

KW - multivariate statistics

KW - Yorkshire

KW - England

KW - ELM-DECLINE

KW - IRELAND

U2 - 10.1007/s00334-005-0064-0

DO - 10.1007/s00334-005-0064-0

M3 - Article

VL - 14

SP - 15

EP - 30

JO - Vegetation History and Archaeobotany

JF - Vegetation History and Archaeobotany

SN - 0939-6314

ER -