National healthcare rhetoric beyond the nation: The materiality of narrative in cosmetic surgery tourism

Debra Gimlin

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

2 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

This article examines the narrative strategies employed by US and UK plastic surgeons’ associations to discredit the practice of aesthetic tourism. Cosmetic surgery tourism, one of a broad set of activities involving travel for medical care, represents a growing marketplace and, thus, a significant professional threat to aesthetic/plastic surgeons practising ‘at home’. Drawing from an analysis of five associations’ websites, I argue that their claims about aesthetic tourism’s dangers reflect the same repertoires of evaluation – that is, lines of argumentation deemed credible within particular national settings – employed by American and British consumers of cosmetic surgery to defend their actions as ‘deserved’ and ‘legitimate’. While evaluative repertoires are grounded in material conditions, those conditions allow for flexibility in their implementation. When US and UK physicians’ associations employ the narrative strategies made available by their own nation, they do so in ways that present cosmetic surgery – when conducted abroad – as ‘undeserved’ and ‘illegitimate’
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)302-318
Number of pages17
JournalTourist Studies
Volume14
Issue number3
Early online date28 May 2014
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Dec 2014

Fingerprint

esthetics
health care
tourism
plastic
Rhetoric
Surgery
Tourism
Materiality
Healthcare
Plastics

Keywords

  • tourist studies
  • cosmetic surgery
  • medical tourism
  • culture
  • narrative

Cite this

National healthcare rhetoric beyond the nation : The materiality of narrative in cosmetic surgery tourism. / Gimlin, Debra.

In: Tourist Studies, Vol. 14, No. 3, 12.2014, p. 302-318.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{3d9be04a88e1415f873beec4fb3f26b7,
title = "National healthcare rhetoric beyond the nation: The materiality of narrative in cosmetic surgery tourism",
abstract = "This article examines the narrative strategies employed by US and UK plastic surgeons’ associations to discredit the practice of aesthetic tourism. Cosmetic surgery tourism, one of a broad set of activities involving travel for medical care, represents a growing marketplace and, thus, a significant professional threat to aesthetic/plastic surgeons practising ‘at home’. Drawing from an analysis of five associations’ websites, I argue that their claims about aesthetic tourism’s dangers reflect the same repertoires of evaluation – that is, lines of argumentation deemed credible within particular national settings – employed by American and British consumers of cosmetic surgery to defend their actions as ‘deserved’ and ‘legitimate’. While evaluative repertoires are grounded in material conditions, those conditions allow for flexibility in their implementation. When US and UK physicians’ associations employ the narrative strategies made available by their own nation, they do so in ways that present cosmetic surgery – when conducted abroad – as ‘undeserved’ and ‘illegitimate’",
keywords = "tourist studies, cosmetic surgery, medical tourism, culture, narrative",
author = "Debra Gimlin",
note = "Funding This research was funded by the British Academy (SG46213).",
year = "2014",
month = "12",
doi = "10.1177/1468797614536335",
language = "English",
volume = "14",
pages = "302--318",
journal = "Tourist Studies",
issn = "1468-7976",
publisher = "SAGE Publications Ltd",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - National healthcare rhetoric beyond the nation

T2 - The materiality of narrative in cosmetic surgery tourism

AU - Gimlin, Debra

N1 - Funding This research was funded by the British Academy (SG46213).

PY - 2014/12

Y1 - 2014/12

N2 - This article examines the narrative strategies employed by US and UK plastic surgeons’ associations to discredit the practice of aesthetic tourism. Cosmetic surgery tourism, one of a broad set of activities involving travel for medical care, represents a growing marketplace and, thus, a significant professional threat to aesthetic/plastic surgeons practising ‘at home’. Drawing from an analysis of five associations’ websites, I argue that their claims about aesthetic tourism’s dangers reflect the same repertoires of evaluation – that is, lines of argumentation deemed credible within particular national settings – employed by American and British consumers of cosmetic surgery to defend their actions as ‘deserved’ and ‘legitimate’. While evaluative repertoires are grounded in material conditions, those conditions allow for flexibility in their implementation. When US and UK physicians’ associations employ the narrative strategies made available by their own nation, they do so in ways that present cosmetic surgery – when conducted abroad – as ‘undeserved’ and ‘illegitimate’

AB - This article examines the narrative strategies employed by US and UK plastic surgeons’ associations to discredit the practice of aesthetic tourism. Cosmetic surgery tourism, one of a broad set of activities involving travel for medical care, represents a growing marketplace and, thus, a significant professional threat to aesthetic/plastic surgeons practising ‘at home’. Drawing from an analysis of five associations’ websites, I argue that their claims about aesthetic tourism’s dangers reflect the same repertoires of evaluation – that is, lines of argumentation deemed credible within particular national settings – employed by American and British consumers of cosmetic surgery to defend their actions as ‘deserved’ and ‘legitimate’. While evaluative repertoires are grounded in material conditions, those conditions allow for flexibility in their implementation. When US and UK physicians’ associations employ the narrative strategies made available by their own nation, they do so in ways that present cosmetic surgery – when conducted abroad – as ‘undeserved’ and ‘illegitimate’

KW - tourist studies

KW - cosmetic surgery

KW - medical tourism

KW - culture

KW - narrative

U2 - 10.1177/1468797614536335

DO - 10.1177/1468797614536335

M3 - Article

VL - 14

SP - 302

EP - 318

JO - Tourist Studies

JF - Tourist Studies

SN - 1468-7976

IS - 3

ER -