Natural language directed inference from ontologies

Chris Mellish, Jeff Z. Pan

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

17 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

This paper presents an investigation into the problem of content determination in natural language generation (NLG), using its an example the problem of determining what to say when asked "What is an A?", where A is a concept defined in an OWL ontology. It is shown that a naive approach to this problem, which just presents a set of the stated axioms, will often inadvertantly violate maxims of cooperative conversation. What is required instead is a kind of inference that generates logical conclusions of the axioms that are suitable for natural language presentation-natural language directed inference (NLDI). Although NLDI, in this case a kind of non-standard inference in description logics, is hard to formalise in general, for this problem we isolate a significant subproblem-that of enumerating subsumers of A that are suitable for natural language presentation. For this problem, which on the face of it appears intractable, we show how factors relevant to natural language presentation enable an optimised solution that is realistic in practice.

The paper makes a contribution to the increasingly important practical problem of explaining concepts in an ontology. It also makes a first step towards the development of domain independent principles for content determination. (c) 2008 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)1285-1315
Number of pages31
JournalArtificial Intelligence
Volume172
Issue number10
Early online date4 Mar 2008
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Jun 2008

Keywords

  • ontologies
  • natural language generation
  • non-standard reasoning
  • content determination

Cite this

Natural language directed inference from ontologies. / Mellish, Chris; Pan, Jeff Z.

In: Artificial Intelligence, Vol. 172, No. 10, 06.2008, p. 1285-1315.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Mellish, Chris ; Pan, Jeff Z. / Natural language directed inference from ontologies. In: Artificial Intelligence. 2008 ; Vol. 172, No. 10. pp. 1285-1315.
@article{27ef57f36d5e4f30be48504126fef2f1,
title = "Natural language directed inference from ontologies",
abstract = "This paper presents an investigation into the problem of content determination in natural language generation (NLG), using its an example the problem of determining what to say when asked {"}What is an A?{"}, where A is a concept defined in an OWL ontology. It is shown that a naive approach to this problem, which just presents a set of the stated axioms, will often inadvertantly violate maxims of cooperative conversation. What is required instead is a kind of inference that generates logical conclusions of the axioms that are suitable for natural language presentation-natural language directed inference (NLDI). Although NLDI, in this case a kind of non-standard inference in description logics, is hard to formalise in general, for this problem we isolate a significant subproblem-that of enumerating subsumers of A that are suitable for natural language presentation. For this problem, which on the face of it appears intractable, we show how factors relevant to natural language presentation enable an optimised solution that is realistic in practice.The paper makes a contribution to the increasingly important practical problem of explaining concepts in an ontology. It also makes a first step towards the development of domain independent principles for content determination. (c) 2008 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.",
keywords = "ontologies, natural language generation, non-standard reasoning, content determination",
author = "Chris Mellish and Pan, {Jeff Z.}",
note = "A paid open access option is available for this journal. Voluntary deposit by author of pre-print allowed on Institutions open scholarly website and pre-print servers Voluntary deposit by author of authors post-print allowed on institutions open scholarly website including Institutional Repository Deposit due to Funding Body, Institutional and Governmental mandate only allowed where separate agreement between repository and publisher exists Set statement to accompany deposit Published source must be acknowledged Must link to journal home page or articles' DOI Publisher's version/PDF cannot be used Articles in some journals can be made Open Access on payment of additional charge NIH Authors articles will be submitted to PMC after 12 months Authors who are required to deposit in subject repositories may also use Sponsorship Option Pre-print can not be deposited for The Lancet",
year = "2008",
month = "6",
doi = "10.1016/j.artint.2008.01.003",
language = "English",
volume = "172",
pages = "1285--1315",
journal = "Artificial Intelligence",
issn = "0004-3702",
publisher = "Elsevier",
number = "10",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Natural language directed inference from ontologies

AU - Mellish, Chris

AU - Pan, Jeff Z.

N1 - A paid open access option is available for this journal. Voluntary deposit by author of pre-print allowed on Institutions open scholarly website and pre-print servers Voluntary deposit by author of authors post-print allowed on institutions open scholarly website including Institutional Repository Deposit due to Funding Body, Institutional and Governmental mandate only allowed where separate agreement between repository and publisher exists Set statement to accompany deposit Published source must be acknowledged Must link to journal home page or articles' DOI Publisher's version/PDF cannot be used Articles in some journals can be made Open Access on payment of additional charge NIH Authors articles will be submitted to PMC after 12 months Authors who are required to deposit in subject repositories may also use Sponsorship Option Pre-print can not be deposited for The Lancet

PY - 2008/6

Y1 - 2008/6

N2 - This paper presents an investigation into the problem of content determination in natural language generation (NLG), using its an example the problem of determining what to say when asked "What is an A?", where A is a concept defined in an OWL ontology. It is shown that a naive approach to this problem, which just presents a set of the stated axioms, will often inadvertantly violate maxims of cooperative conversation. What is required instead is a kind of inference that generates logical conclusions of the axioms that are suitable for natural language presentation-natural language directed inference (NLDI). Although NLDI, in this case a kind of non-standard inference in description logics, is hard to formalise in general, for this problem we isolate a significant subproblem-that of enumerating subsumers of A that are suitable for natural language presentation. For this problem, which on the face of it appears intractable, we show how factors relevant to natural language presentation enable an optimised solution that is realistic in practice.The paper makes a contribution to the increasingly important practical problem of explaining concepts in an ontology. It also makes a first step towards the development of domain independent principles for content determination. (c) 2008 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.

AB - This paper presents an investigation into the problem of content determination in natural language generation (NLG), using its an example the problem of determining what to say when asked "What is an A?", where A is a concept defined in an OWL ontology. It is shown that a naive approach to this problem, which just presents a set of the stated axioms, will often inadvertantly violate maxims of cooperative conversation. What is required instead is a kind of inference that generates logical conclusions of the axioms that are suitable for natural language presentation-natural language directed inference (NLDI). Although NLDI, in this case a kind of non-standard inference in description logics, is hard to formalise in general, for this problem we isolate a significant subproblem-that of enumerating subsumers of A that are suitable for natural language presentation. For this problem, which on the face of it appears intractable, we show how factors relevant to natural language presentation enable an optimised solution that is realistic in practice.The paper makes a contribution to the increasingly important practical problem of explaining concepts in an ontology. It also makes a first step towards the development of domain independent principles for content determination. (c) 2008 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.

KW - ontologies

KW - natural language generation

KW - non-standard reasoning

KW - content determination

U2 - 10.1016/j.artint.2008.01.003

DO - 10.1016/j.artint.2008.01.003

M3 - Article

VL - 172

SP - 1285

EP - 1315

JO - Artificial Intelligence

JF - Artificial Intelligence

SN - 0004-3702

IS - 10

ER -