New Technological Interventions in Conservation Conflicts: Countering Emotions and Contested Knowledge

Audrey Verma (Corresponding Author), Rene Van der Wal, Anke Fischer

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

2 Citations (Scopus)
6 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

New technologies have increasingly featured in environmental conservation conflicts. We examined the deployment of imaging devices such as sonar equipment and cameras to survey the Fal estuary in Cornwall, UK. Due to heavy use of these waters, there have been several disputes coalescing around protected marine features, including the estuary’s rare maerl beds. A comparison of two cases, scallop dredging and docks development, showed technical instruments being deployed to produce information about the marine environment as evidence to inform decision-making. The use of imaging devices stimulated political action and was regarded as a move away from emotion-based decision-making towards desired objectivity. Simultaneously, however, the process of deploying these devices was challenged and there was recognition that the resultant information could be used to construct the estuary as a politically charged space. Thus, rather than clarifying and resolving contentious issues, technological interventions generated new baselines for knowledge contestation and amplified ongoing battles for credibility and authority.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)683-695
Number of pages13
JournalHuman Ecology
Volume45
Issue number5
Early online date11 Sep 2017
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Oct 2017

Fingerprint

emotion
conservation
decision making
estuary
sonar
political action
objectivity
technical development
dredging
credibility
marine environment
new technology
water
evidence
conflict
Emotion
Conservation
Decision Making
Estuary
Imaging

Keywords

  • Knowledge contestation
  • Digital imaging
  • Technologies for nature conservation
  • Evidence production
  • Maerl
  • Fal River, Cornwall, UK

Cite this

New Technological Interventions in Conservation Conflicts : Countering Emotions and Contested Knowledge. / Verma, Audrey (Corresponding Author); Van der Wal, Rene; Fischer, Anke.

In: Human Ecology, Vol. 45, No. 5, 10.2017, p. 683-695.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{7e4e8c9aa97743479fc8e9874261fbf0,
title = "New Technological Interventions in Conservation Conflicts: Countering Emotions and Contested Knowledge",
abstract = "New technologies have increasingly featured in environmental conservation conflicts. We examined the deployment of imaging devices such as sonar equipment and cameras to survey the Fal estuary in Cornwall, UK. Due to heavy use of these waters, there have been several disputes coalescing around protected marine features, including the estuary’s rare maerl beds. A comparison of two cases, scallop dredging and docks development, showed technical instruments being deployed to produce information about the marine environment as evidence to inform decision-making. The use of imaging devices stimulated political action and was regarded as a move away from emotion-based decision-making towards desired objectivity. Simultaneously, however, the process of deploying these devices was challenged and there was recognition that the resultant information could be used to construct the estuary as a politically charged space. Thus, rather than clarifying and resolving contentious issues, technological interventions generated new baselines for knowledge contestation and amplified ongoing battles for credibility and authority.",
keywords = "Knowledge contestation, Digital imaging , Technologies for nature conservation, Evidence production, Maerl, Fal River, Cornwall, UK",
author = "Audrey Verma and {Van der Wal}, Rene and Anke Fischer",
note = "RCUK Digital Economy programme Grant number EP/G066051/1 Open access via Springer Compact Agreement",
year = "2017",
month = "10",
doi = "10.1007/s10745-017-9936-z",
language = "English",
volume = "45",
pages = "683--695",
journal = "Human Ecology",
issn = "0300-7839",
publisher = "Springer Science + Business Media",
number = "5",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - New Technological Interventions in Conservation Conflicts

T2 - Countering Emotions and Contested Knowledge

AU - Verma, Audrey

AU - Van der Wal, Rene

AU - Fischer, Anke

N1 - RCUK Digital Economy programme Grant number EP/G066051/1 Open access via Springer Compact Agreement

PY - 2017/10

Y1 - 2017/10

N2 - New technologies have increasingly featured in environmental conservation conflicts. We examined the deployment of imaging devices such as sonar equipment and cameras to survey the Fal estuary in Cornwall, UK. Due to heavy use of these waters, there have been several disputes coalescing around protected marine features, including the estuary’s rare maerl beds. A comparison of two cases, scallop dredging and docks development, showed technical instruments being deployed to produce information about the marine environment as evidence to inform decision-making. The use of imaging devices stimulated political action and was regarded as a move away from emotion-based decision-making towards desired objectivity. Simultaneously, however, the process of deploying these devices was challenged and there was recognition that the resultant information could be used to construct the estuary as a politically charged space. Thus, rather than clarifying and resolving contentious issues, technological interventions generated new baselines for knowledge contestation and amplified ongoing battles for credibility and authority.

AB - New technologies have increasingly featured in environmental conservation conflicts. We examined the deployment of imaging devices such as sonar equipment and cameras to survey the Fal estuary in Cornwall, UK. Due to heavy use of these waters, there have been several disputes coalescing around protected marine features, including the estuary’s rare maerl beds. A comparison of two cases, scallop dredging and docks development, showed technical instruments being deployed to produce information about the marine environment as evidence to inform decision-making. The use of imaging devices stimulated political action and was regarded as a move away from emotion-based decision-making towards desired objectivity. Simultaneously, however, the process of deploying these devices was challenged and there was recognition that the resultant information could be used to construct the estuary as a politically charged space. Thus, rather than clarifying and resolving contentious issues, technological interventions generated new baselines for knowledge contestation and amplified ongoing battles for credibility and authority.

KW - Knowledge contestation

KW - Digital imaging

KW - Technologies for nature conservation

KW - Evidence production

KW - Maerl

KW - Fal River, Cornwall, UK

U2 - 10.1007/s10745-017-9936-z

DO - 10.1007/s10745-017-9936-z

M3 - Article

VL - 45

SP - 683

EP - 695

JO - Human Ecology

JF - Human Ecology

SN - 0300-7839

IS - 5

ER -