On the material dependence of experimental shear fracture orientation

Enrique Gomez Rivas (Corresponding Author), Albert Griera

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

1 Citation (Scopus)
3 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

It is not uncommon to observe shear fractures in ductile rocks oriented at more than 45° with respect to the maximum compression direction. Since these orientations cannot be explained with the classic Mohr-Coulumb or Tresca yield criteria, Zheng et al. (Journal of Structural Geology, 35: 1394–1405, 2011) proposed the maximum effective moment (MEM) failure criterion. This rule suggests that shear fractures in ductile rocks form at ~55° with the maximum compression axis and that this orientation is material-independent and, therefore, universal. Zheng et al. (Science China: Earth Sciences, 57(11): 2819–2824, 2014) used data from our own experiments as supporting evidence of their failure criterion. In this contribution we discuss why shear fracture formation in ductile rocks indeed strongly depends on the mechanical properties of the deforming medium, and why experimental data should not be taken to prove the validity of the MEM criterion. The formation mechanisms and orientations of shear fractures in our experiments significantly vary depending on the material strength and degree and type of anisotropy (composite and intrinsic). We therefore demonstrate using experimental data that a universal failure angle in ductile and anisotropic rocks does not apply. Additionally, we highlight some inconsistencies of the MEM criterion.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)2357-2362
Number of pages6
JournalScience China Earth Sciences
Volume58
Issue number12
Early online date3 Dec 2015
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Dec 2015

Fingerprint

fracture orientation
rock
compression
structural geology
formation mechanism
Earth science
mechanical property
anisotropy
experiment
material

Keywords

  • shear fracture
  • anisotropy
  • fracture orientation
  • Material properties
  • failure criteria
  • ductile deformation

Cite this

On the material dependence of experimental shear fracture orientation. / Gomez Rivas, Enrique (Corresponding Author); Griera, Albert.

In: Science China Earth Sciences, Vol. 58, No. 12, 12.2015, p. 2357-2362.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Gomez Rivas, Enrique ; Griera, Albert. / On the material dependence of experimental shear fracture orientation. In: Science China Earth Sciences. 2015 ; Vol. 58, No. 12. pp. 2357-2362.
@article{bbf17686afd24e70a4f939c0339cd41c,
title = "On the material dependence of experimental shear fracture orientation",
abstract = "It is not uncommon to observe shear fractures in ductile rocks oriented at more than 45° with respect to the maximum compression direction. Since these orientations cannot be explained with the classic Mohr-Coulumb or Tresca yield criteria, Zheng et al. (Journal of Structural Geology, 35: 1394–1405, 2011) proposed the maximum effective moment (MEM) failure criterion. This rule suggests that shear fractures in ductile rocks form at ~55° with the maximum compression axis and that this orientation is material-independent and, therefore, universal. Zheng et al. (Science China: Earth Sciences, 57(11): 2819–2824, 2014) used data from our own experiments as supporting evidence of their failure criterion. In this contribution we discuss why shear fracture formation in ductile rocks indeed strongly depends on the mechanical properties of the deforming medium, and why experimental data should not be taken to prove the validity of the MEM criterion. The formation mechanisms and orientations of shear fractures in our experiments significantly vary depending on the material strength and degree and type of anisotropy (composite and intrinsic). We therefore demonstrate using experimental data that a universal failure angle in ductile and anisotropic rocks does not apply. Additionally, we highlight some inconsistencies of the MEM criterion.",
keywords = "shear fracture, anisotropy, fracture orientation, Material properties, failure criteria, ductile deformation",
author = "{Gomez Rivas}, Enrique and Albert Griera",
year = "2015",
month = "12",
doi = "10.1007/s11430-015-5217-0",
language = "English",
volume = "58",
pages = "2357--2362",
journal = "Science China Earth Sciences",
issn = "1674-7313",
publisher = "Science in China Press",
number = "12",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - On the material dependence of experimental shear fracture orientation

AU - Gomez Rivas, Enrique

AU - Griera, Albert

PY - 2015/12

Y1 - 2015/12

N2 - It is not uncommon to observe shear fractures in ductile rocks oriented at more than 45° with respect to the maximum compression direction. Since these orientations cannot be explained with the classic Mohr-Coulumb or Tresca yield criteria, Zheng et al. (Journal of Structural Geology, 35: 1394–1405, 2011) proposed the maximum effective moment (MEM) failure criterion. This rule suggests that shear fractures in ductile rocks form at ~55° with the maximum compression axis and that this orientation is material-independent and, therefore, universal. Zheng et al. (Science China: Earth Sciences, 57(11): 2819–2824, 2014) used data from our own experiments as supporting evidence of their failure criterion. In this contribution we discuss why shear fracture formation in ductile rocks indeed strongly depends on the mechanical properties of the deforming medium, and why experimental data should not be taken to prove the validity of the MEM criterion. The formation mechanisms and orientations of shear fractures in our experiments significantly vary depending on the material strength and degree and type of anisotropy (composite and intrinsic). We therefore demonstrate using experimental data that a universal failure angle in ductile and anisotropic rocks does not apply. Additionally, we highlight some inconsistencies of the MEM criterion.

AB - It is not uncommon to observe shear fractures in ductile rocks oriented at more than 45° with respect to the maximum compression direction. Since these orientations cannot be explained with the classic Mohr-Coulumb or Tresca yield criteria, Zheng et al. (Journal of Structural Geology, 35: 1394–1405, 2011) proposed the maximum effective moment (MEM) failure criterion. This rule suggests that shear fractures in ductile rocks form at ~55° with the maximum compression axis and that this orientation is material-independent and, therefore, universal. Zheng et al. (Science China: Earth Sciences, 57(11): 2819–2824, 2014) used data from our own experiments as supporting evidence of their failure criterion. In this contribution we discuss why shear fracture formation in ductile rocks indeed strongly depends on the mechanical properties of the deforming medium, and why experimental data should not be taken to prove the validity of the MEM criterion. The formation mechanisms and orientations of shear fractures in our experiments significantly vary depending on the material strength and degree and type of anisotropy (composite and intrinsic). We therefore demonstrate using experimental data that a universal failure angle in ductile and anisotropic rocks does not apply. Additionally, we highlight some inconsistencies of the MEM criterion.

KW - shear fracture

KW - anisotropy

KW - fracture orientation

KW - Material properties

KW - failure criteria

KW - ductile deformation

U2 - 10.1007/s11430-015-5217-0

DO - 10.1007/s11430-015-5217-0

M3 - Article

VL - 58

SP - 2357

EP - 2362

JO - Science China Earth Sciences

JF - Science China Earth Sciences

SN - 1674-7313

IS - 12

ER -