Opposite-sex siblings decrease attraction, but not prosocial attributions, to self-resembling opposite-sex faces

Lisa M. DeBruine, Benedict C. Jones, Christopher D. Watkins, S. Craig Roberts, Anthony C. Little, Finlay G. Smith, Michelle C. Quist

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

27 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Contextual cues of genetic relatedness to familiar individuals, such as cosocialization and maternal-perinatal association, modulate prosocial and inbreeding-avoidance behaviors toward specific potential siblings. These findings have been interpreted as evidence that contextual cues of kinship indirectly influence social behavior by affecting the perceived probability of genetic relatedness to familiar individuals. Here, we test a more general alternative model in which contextual cues of kinship can influence the kin-recognition system more directly, changing how the mechanisms that regulate social behavior respond to cues of kinship, even in unfamiliar individuals for whom contextual cues of kinship are absent. We show that having opposite-sex siblings influences inbreeding-relevant perceptions of facial resemblance but not prosocial perceptions. Women with brothers were less attracted to self-resembling, unfamiliar male faces than were women without brothers, and both groups found self-resemblance to be equally trustworthy for the same faces. Further analyses suggest that this effect is driven by younger, rather than older, brothers, consistent with the proposal that only younger siblings exhibit the strong kinship cue of maternal-perinatal association. Our findings provide evidence that experience with opposite-sex siblings can directly influence inbreeding-avoidance mechanisms and demonstrate a striking functional dissociation between the mechanisms that regulate inbreeding and the mechanisms that regulate prosocial behavior toward kin.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)11710-11714
Number of pages5
JournalPNAS
Volume108
Issue number28
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 12 Jul 2011

Keywords

  • inclusive fitness
  • incest avoidance
  • optimal outbreeding
  • individual differences
  • face perception
  • human kin recognition
  • facial resemblance
  • decision making
  • female faces
  • preferences
  • trustworthiness
  • judgments
  • incest
  • westermarck
  • perception

Cite this

DeBruine, L. M., Jones, B. C., Watkins, C. D., Roberts, S. C., Little, A. C., Smith, F. G., & Quist, M. C. (2011). Opposite-sex siblings decrease attraction, but not prosocial attributions, to self-resembling opposite-sex faces. PNAS, 108(28), 11710-11714. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1105919108

Opposite-sex siblings decrease attraction, but not prosocial attributions, to self-resembling opposite-sex faces. / DeBruine, Lisa M.; Jones, Benedict C.; Watkins, Christopher D.; Roberts, S. Craig; Little, Anthony C.; Smith, Finlay G.; Quist, Michelle C.

In: PNAS, Vol. 108, No. 28, 12.07.2011, p. 11710-11714.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

DeBruine, LM, Jones, BC, Watkins, CD, Roberts, SC, Little, AC, Smith, FG & Quist, MC 2011, 'Opposite-sex siblings decrease attraction, but not prosocial attributions, to self-resembling opposite-sex faces', PNAS, vol. 108, no. 28, pp. 11710-11714. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1105919108
DeBruine LM, Jones BC, Watkins CD, Roberts SC, Little AC, Smith FG et al. Opposite-sex siblings decrease attraction, but not prosocial attributions, to self-resembling opposite-sex faces. PNAS. 2011 Jul 12;108(28):11710-11714. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1105919108
DeBruine, Lisa M. ; Jones, Benedict C. ; Watkins, Christopher D. ; Roberts, S. Craig ; Little, Anthony C. ; Smith, Finlay G. ; Quist, Michelle C. / Opposite-sex siblings decrease attraction, but not prosocial attributions, to self-resembling opposite-sex faces. In: PNAS. 2011 ; Vol. 108, No. 28. pp. 11710-11714.
@article{2a3e20f178994c0caf1130e28f5e1114,
title = "Opposite-sex siblings decrease attraction, but not prosocial attributions, to self-resembling opposite-sex faces",
abstract = "Contextual cues of genetic relatedness to familiar individuals, such as cosocialization and maternal-perinatal association, modulate prosocial and inbreeding-avoidance behaviors toward specific potential siblings. These findings have been interpreted as evidence that contextual cues of kinship indirectly influence social behavior by affecting the perceived probability of genetic relatedness to familiar individuals. Here, we test a more general alternative model in which contextual cues of kinship can influence the kin-recognition system more directly, changing how the mechanisms that regulate social behavior respond to cues of kinship, even in unfamiliar individuals for whom contextual cues of kinship are absent. We show that having opposite-sex siblings influences inbreeding-relevant perceptions of facial resemblance but not prosocial perceptions. Women with brothers were less attracted to self-resembling, unfamiliar male faces than were women without brothers, and both groups found self-resemblance to be equally trustworthy for the same faces. Further analyses suggest that this effect is driven by younger, rather than older, brothers, consistent with the proposal that only younger siblings exhibit the strong kinship cue of maternal-perinatal association. Our findings provide evidence that experience with opposite-sex siblings can directly influence inbreeding-avoidance mechanisms and demonstrate a striking functional dissociation between the mechanisms that regulate inbreeding and the mechanisms that regulate prosocial behavior toward kin.",
keywords = "inclusive fitness, incest avoidance, optimal outbreeding, individual differences, face perception, human kin recognition, facial resemblance, decision making, female faces, preferences, trustworthiness, judgments, incest, westermarck, perception",
author = "DeBruine, {Lisa M.} and Jones, {Benedict C.} and Watkins, {Christopher D.} and Roberts, {S. Craig} and Little, {Anthony C.} and Smith, {Finlay G.} and Quist, {Michelle C.}",
year = "2011",
month = "7",
day = "12",
doi = "10.1073/pnas.1105919108",
language = "English",
volume = "108",
pages = "11710--11714",
journal = "PNAS",
issn = "0027-8424",
publisher = "NATL ACAD SCIENCES",
number = "28",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Opposite-sex siblings decrease attraction, but not prosocial attributions, to self-resembling opposite-sex faces

AU - DeBruine, Lisa M.

AU - Jones, Benedict C.

AU - Watkins, Christopher D.

AU - Roberts, S. Craig

AU - Little, Anthony C.

AU - Smith, Finlay G.

AU - Quist, Michelle C.

PY - 2011/7/12

Y1 - 2011/7/12

N2 - Contextual cues of genetic relatedness to familiar individuals, such as cosocialization and maternal-perinatal association, modulate prosocial and inbreeding-avoidance behaviors toward specific potential siblings. These findings have been interpreted as evidence that contextual cues of kinship indirectly influence social behavior by affecting the perceived probability of genetic relatedness to familiar individuals. Here, we test a more general alternative model in which contextual cues of kinship can influence the kin-recognition system more directly, changing how the mechanisms that regulate social behavior respond to cues of kinship, even in unfamiliar individuals for whom contextual cues of kinship are absent. We show that having opposite-sex siblings influences inbreeding-relevant perceptions of facial resemblance but not prosocial perceptions. Women with brothers were less attracted to self-resembling, unfamiliar male faces than were women without brothers, and both groups found self-resemblance to be equally trustworthy for the same faces. Further analyses suggest that this effect is driven by younger, rather than older, brothers, consistent with the proposal that only younger siblings exhibit the strong kinship cue of maternal-perinatal association. Our findings provide evidence that experience with opposite-sex siblings can directly influence inbreeding-avoidance mechanisms and demonstrate a striking functional dissociation between the mechanisms that regulate inbreeding and the mechanisms that regulate prosocial behavior toward kin.

AB - Contextual cues of genetic relatedness to familiar individuals, such as cosocialization and maternal-perinatal association, modulate prosocial and inbreeding-avoidance behaviors toward specific potential siblings. These findings have been interpreted as evidence that contextual cues of kinship indirectly influence social behavior by affecting the perceived probability of genetic relatedness to familiar individuals. Here, we test a more general alternative model in which contextual cues of kinship can influence the kin-recognition system more directly, changing how the mechanisms that regulate social behavior respond to cues of kinship, even in unfamiliar individuals for whom contextual cues of kinship are absent. We show that having opposite-sex siblings influences inbreeding-relevant perceptions of facial resemblance but not prosocial perceptions. Women with brothers were less attracted to self-resembling, unfamiliar male faces than were women without brothers, and both groups found self-resemblance to be equally trustworthy for the same faces. Further analyses suggest that this effect is driven by younger, rather than older, brothers, consistent with the proposal that only younger siblings exhibit the strong kinship cue of maternal-perinatal association. Our findings provide evidence that experience with opposite-sex siblings can directly influence inbreeding-avoidance mechanisms and demonstrate a striking functional dissociation between the mechanisms that regulate inbreeding and the mechanisms that regulate prosocial behavior toward kin.

KW - inclusive fitness

KW - incest avoidance

KW - optimal outbreeding

KW - individual differences

KW - face perception

KW - human kin recognition

KW - facial resemblance

KW - decision making

KW - female faces

KW - preferences

KW - trustworthiness

KW - judgments

KW - incest

KW - westermarck

KW - perception

U2 - 10.1073/pnas.1105919108

DO - 10.1073/pnas.1105919108

M3 - Article

VL - 108

SP - 11710

EP - 11714

JO - PNAS

JF - PNAS

SN - 0027-8424

IS - 28

ER -