Passing a USA National Bar Exam: a First Corpus for Experimentation

Adam Zachary Wyner, Biralatei James Fawei, Jeff Z Pan

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

4 Citations (Scopus)
8 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Bar exams provide are a key watershed by which legal professionals demonstrate their knowledge of the law and its application. Passing the bar entitles one to practice the law in a given jurisdiction. The bar provides a excellent benchmark for the performance of legal information systems since passing the bar would arguably signal that the system has acquired key aspects of legal reason on a par with a human lawyer. The paper presents a first experiment with actual bar exam material, treating it as a form of textual entailment from the question to an answer. The Gold Standard is provided by the company which provides the bar exam. The paper reports a textual entailment student on a US bar exam, running `out of the box' the Excitement Open Platform for textual entailment. The results and evaluation show that the tool can identify wrong answers (non-entailment) with a high F1 score, it performs poorly in identifying the correct answer (entailment). The results provide a baseline performance measure against which to evaluate future improvements. The reasons for the poor performance are examined, and proposals are made to augment the tool in the future.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationLREC 2016, Tenth International Conference on Language Resources and Evaluation
EditorsNicoletta Calzolari , Khalid Choukri, Thierry Declerck, Sara Goggi, Marko Grobelnik, Bente Maegaard, Joseph Mariani, Helene Mazo, Asunción Moreno, Jan Odijk, Stelios Piperidis
PublisherLREC
Number of pages7
ISBN (Print)978-2-9517408-9-1
Publication statusPublished - 23 May 2016
EventTenth International Conference on Language Resources and Evaluation - Grand Hotel Bernardin Conference Center, Portorož, Slovenia
Duration: 23 May 201628 May 2016

Conference

ConferenceTenth International Conference on Language Resources and Evaluation
CountrySlovenia
CityPortorož
Period23/05/1628/05/16

Fingerprint

Watersheds
Information systems
Students
Industry
Experiments

Keywords

  • textual entailment
  • bar exam
  • legal reasoning
  • natural language processing

Cite this

Wyner, A. Z., Fawei, B. J., & Pan, J. Z. (2016). Passing a USA National Bar Exam: a First Corpus for Experimentation. In N. Calzolari , K. Choukri, T. Declerck, S. Goggi, M. Grobelnik, B. Maegaard, J. Mariani, H. Mazo, A. Moreno, J. Odijk, ... S. Piperidis (Eds.), LREC 2016, Tenth International Conference on Language Resources and Evaluation LREC.

Passing a USA National Bar Exam : a First Corpus for Experimentation. / Wyner, Adam Zachary; Fawei, Biralatei James; Pan, Jeff Z.

LREC 2016, Tenth International Conference on Language Resources and Evaluation. ed. / Nicoletta Calzolari ; Khalid Choukri; Thierry Declerck; Sara Goggi; Marko Grobelnik; Bente Maegaard; Joseph Mariani; Helene Mazo; Asunción Moreno; Jan Odijk; Stelios Piperidis. LREC, 2016.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

Wyner, AZ, Fawei, BJ & Pan, JZ 2016, Passing a USA National Bar Exam: a First Corpus for Experimentation. in N Calzolari , K Choukri, T Declerck, S Goggi, M Grobelnik, B Maegaard, J Mariani, H Mazo, A Moreno, J Odijk & S Piperidis (eds), LREC 2016, Tenth International Conference on Language Resources and Evaluation. LREC, Tenth International Conference on Language Resources and Evaluation, Portorož, Slovenia, 23/05/16.
Wyner AZ, Fawei BJ, Pan JZ. Passing a USA National Bar Exam: a First Corpus for Experimentation. In Calzolari N, Choukri K, Declerck T, Goggi S, Grobelnik M, Maegaard B, Mariani J, Mazo H, Moreno A, Odijk J, Piperidis S, editors, LREC 2016, Tenth International Conference on Language Resources and Evaluation. LREC. 2016
Wyner, Adam Zachary ; Fawei, Biralatei James ; Pan, Jeff Z. / Passing a USA National Bar Exam : a First Corpus for Experimentation. LREC 2016, Tenth International Conference on Language Resources and Evaluation. editor / Nicoletta Calzolari ; Khalid Choukri ; Thierry Declerck ; Sara Goggi ; Marko Grobelnik ; Bente Maegaard ; Joseph Mariani ; Helene Mazo ; Asunción Moreno ; Jan Odijk ; Stelios Piperidis. LREC, 2016.
@inproceedings{6e1e0a8352914ba8a01a047d429cc6c1,
title = "Passing a USA National Bar Exam: a First Corpus for Experimentation",
abstract = "Bar exams provide are a key watershed by which legal professionals demonstrate their knowledge of the law and its application. Passing the bar entitles one to practice the law in a given jurisdiction. The bar provides a excellent benchmark for the performance of legal information systems since passing the bar would arguably signal that the system has acquired key aspects of legal reason on a par with a human lawyer. The paper presents a first experiment with actual bar exam material, treating it as a form of textual entailment from the question to an answer. The Gold Standard is provided by the company which provides the bar exam. The paper reports a textual entailment student on a US bar exam, running `out of the box' the Excitement Open Platform for textual entailment. The results and evaluation show that the tool can identify wrong answers (non-entailment) with a high F1 score, it performs poorly in identifying the correct answer (entailment). The results provide a baseline performance measure against which to evaluate future improvements. The reasons for the poor performance are examined, and proposals are made to augment the tool in the future.",
keywords = "textual entailment, bar exam, legal reasoning, natural language processing",
author = "Wyner, {Adam Zachary} and Fawei, {Biralatei James} and Pan, {Jeff Z}",
year = "2016",
month = "5",
day = "23",
language = "English",
isbn = "978-2-9517408-9-1",
editor = "{Calzolari }, {Nicoletta } and Choukri, {Khalid } and Declerck, {Thierry } and Goggi, {Sara } and Marko Grobelnik and Bente Maegaard and Joseph Mariani and Helene Mazo and Moreno, {Asunci{\'o}n } and Jan Odijk and Stelios Piperidis",
booktitle = "LREC 2016, Tenth International Conference on Language Resources and Evaluation",
publisher = "LREC",

}

TY - GEN

T1 - Passing a USA National Bar Exam

T2 - a First Corpus for Experimentation

AU - Wyner, Adam Zachary

AU - Fawei, Biralatei James

AU - Pan, Jeff Z

PY - 2016/5/23

Y1 - 2016/5/23

N2 - Bar exams provide are a key watershed by which legal professionals demonstrate their knowledge of the law and its application. Passing the bar entitles one to practice the law in a given jurisdiction. The bar provides a excellent benchmark for the performance of legal information systems since passing the bar would arguably signal that the system has acquired key aspects of legal reason on a par with a human lawyer. The paper presents a first experiment with actual bar exam material, treating it as a form of textual entailment from the question to an answer. The Gold Standard is provided by the company which provides the bar exam. The paper reports a textual entailment student on a US bar exam, running `out of the box' the Excitement Open Platform for textual entailment. The results and evaluation show that the tool can identify wrong answers (non-entailment) with a high F1 score, it performs poorly in identifying the correct answer (entailment). The results provide a baseline performance measure against which to evaluate future improvements. The reasons for the poor performance are examined, and proposals are made to augment the tool in the future.

AB - Bar exams provide are a key watershed by which legal professionals demonstrate their knowledge of the law and its application. Passing the bar entitles one to practice the law in a given jurisdiction. The bar provides a excellent benchmark for the performance of legal information systems since passing the bar would arguably signal that the system has acquired key aspects of legal reason on a par with a human lawyer. The paper presents a first experiment with actual bar exam material, treating it as a form of textual entailment from the question to an answer. The Gold Standard is provided by the company which provides the bar exam. The paper reports a textual entailment student on a US bar exam, running `out of the box' the Excitement Open Platform for textual entailment. The results and evaluation show that the tool can identify wrong answers (non-entailment) with a high F1 score, it performs poorly in identifying the correct answer (entailment). The results provide a baseline performance measure against which to evaluate future improvements. The reasons for the poor performance are examined, and proposals are made to augment the tool in the future.

KW - textual entailment

KW - bar exam

KW - legal reasoning

KW - natural language processing

M3 - Conference contribution

SN - 978-2-9517408-9-1

BT - LREC 2016, Tenth International Conference on Language Resources and Evaluation

A2 - Calzolari , Nicoletta

A2 - Choukri, Khalid

A2 - Declerck, Thierry

A2 - Goggi, Sara

A2 - Grobelnik, Marko

A2 - Maegaard, Bente

A2 - Mariani, Joseph

A2 - Mazo, Helene

A2 - Moreno, Asunción

A2 - Odijk, Jan

A2 - Piperidis, Stelios

PB - LREC

ER -