Pedigree error due to extra-pair reproduction substantially biases estimates of inbreeding depression

Jane M Reid, Lukas F Keller, Amy B Marr, Pirmin Nietlisbach, Rebecca J Sardell, Peter Arcese

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

25 Citations (Scopus)
5 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Understanding the evolutionary dynamics of inbreeding and inbreeding depression requires unbiased estimation of inbreeding depression across diverse mating systems. However, studies estimating inbreeding depression often measure inbreeding with error, for example, based on pedigree data derived from observed parental behavior that ignore paternity error stemming from multiple mating. Such paternity error causes error in estimated coefficients of inbreeding (f) and reproductive success and could bias estimates of inbreeding depression. We used complete "apparent" pedigree data compiled from observed parental behavior and analogous "actual" pedigree data comprising genetic parentage to quantify effects of paternity error stemming from extra-pair reproduction on estimates of f, reproductive success, and inbreeding depression in free-living song sparrows (Melospiza melodia). Paternity error caused widespread error in estimates of f and male reproductive success, causing inbreeding depression in male and female annual and lifetime reproductive success and juvenile male survival to be substantially underestimated. Conversely, inbreeding depression in adult male survival tended to be overestimated when paternity error was ignored. Pedigree error stemming from extra-pair reproduction therefore caused substantial and divergent bias in estimates of inbreeding depression that could bias tests of evolutionary theories regarding inbreeding and inbreeding depression and their links to variation in mating system.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)802-815
Number of pages14
JournalEvolution
Volume68
Issue number3
Early online date27 Nov 2013
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Mar 2014

Keywords

  • measurement error
  • lethal equivalents
  • polyandry
  • conservation genetics
  • paternity
  • lifetime reproductive success
  • sparrows melospiza-melodia
  • wild bird population
  • song sparrows
  • natural-population
  • Darwins finches
  • within-pair
  • fitness
  • fertilization
  • heritability

Cite this

Reid, J. M., Keller, L. F., Marr, A. B., Nietlisbach, P., Sardell, R. J., & Arcese, P. (2014). Pedigree error due to extra-pair reproduction substantially biases estimates of inbreeding depression. Evolution, 68(3), 802-815. https://doi.org/10.1111/evo.12305

Pedigree error due to extra-pair reproduction substantially biases estimates of inbreeding depression. / Reid, Jane M; Keller, Lukas F; Marr, Amy B; Nietlisbach, Pirmin; Sardell, Rebecca J; Arcese, Peter.

In: Evolution, Vol. 68, No. 3, 03.2014, p. 802-815.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Reid, JM, Keller, LF, Marr, AB, Nietlisbach, P, Sardell, RJ & Arcese, P 2014, 'Pedigree error due to extra-pair reproduction substantially biases estimates of inbreeding depression', Evolution, vol. 68, no. 3, pp. 802-815. https://doi.org/10.1111/evo.12305
Reid, Jane M ; Keller, Lukas F ; Marr, Amy B ; Nietlisbach, Pirmin ; Sardell, Rebecca J ; Arcese, Peter. / Pedigree error due to extra-pair reproduction substantially biases estimates of inbreeding depression. In: Evolution. 2014 ; Vol. 68, No. 3. pp. 802-815.
@article{1d54cf77fdef4c639e46bfab23c21b0a,
title = "Pedigree error due to extra-pair reproduction substantially biases estimates of inbreeding depression",
abstract = "Understanding the evolutionary dynamics of inbreeding and inbreeding depression requires unbiased estimation of inbreeding depression across diverse mating systems. However, studies estimating inbreeding depression often measure inbreeding with error, for example, based on pedigree data derived from observed parental behavior that ignore paternity error stemming from multiple mating. Such paternity error causes error in estimated coefficients of inbreeding (f) and reproductive success and could bias estimates of inbreeding depression. We used complete {"}apparent{"} pedigree data compiled from observed parental behavior and analogous {"}actual{"} pedigree data comprising genetic parentage to quantify effects of paternity error stemming from extra-pair reproduction on estimates of f, reproductive success, and inbreeding depression in free-living song sparrows (Melospiza melodia). Paternity error caused widespread error in estimates of f and male reproductive success, causing inbreeding depression in male and female annual and lifetime reproductive success and juvenile male survival to be substantially underestimated. Conversely, inbreeding depression in adult male survival tended to be overestimated when paternity error was ignored. Pedigree error stemming from extra-pair reproduction therefore caused substantial and divergent bias in estimates of inbreeding depression that could bias tests of evolutionary theories regarding inbreeding and inbreeding depression and their links to variation in mating system.",
keywords = "measurement error, lethal equivalents, polyandry, conservation genetics, paternity, lifetime reproductive success, sparrows melospiza-melodia, wild bird population, song sparrows, natural-population, Darwins finches, within-pair, fitness, fertilization, heritability",
author = "Reid, {Jane M} and Keller, {Lukas F} and Marr, {Amy B} and Pirmin Nietlisbach and Sardell, {Rebecca J} and Peter Arcese",
year = "2014",
month = "3",
doi = "10.1111/evo.12305",
language = "English",
volume = "68",
pages = "802--815",
journal = "Evolution",
issn = "0014-3820",
publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Pedigree error due to extra-pair reproduction substantially biases estimates of inbreeding depression

AU - Reid, Jane M

AU - Keller, Lukas F

AU - Marr, Amy B

AU - Nietlisbach, Pirmin

AU - Sardell, Rebecca J

AU - Arcese, Peter

PY - 2014/3

Y1 - 2014/3

N2 - Understanding the evolutionary dynamics of inbreeding and inbreeding depression requires unbiased estimation of inbreeding depression across diverse mating systems. However, studies estimating inbreeding depression often measure inbreeding with error, for example, based on pedigree data derived from observed parental behavior that ignore paternity error stemming from multiple mating. Such paternity error causes error in estimated coefficients of inbreeding (f) and reproductive success and could bias estimates of inbreeding depression. We used complete "apparent" pedigree data compiled from observed parental behavior and analogous "actual" pedigree data comprising genetic parentage to quantify effects of paternity error stemming from extra-pair reproduction on estimates of f, reproductive success, and inbreeding depression in free-living song sparrows (Melospiza melodia). Paternity error caused widespread error in estimates of f and male reproductive success, causing inbreeding depression in male and female annual and lifetime reproductive success and juvenile male survival to be substantially underestimated. Conversely, inbreeding depression in adult male survival tended to be overestimated when paternity error was ignored. Pedigree error stemming from extra-pair reproduction therefore caused substantial and divergent bias in estimates of inbreeding depression that could bias tests of evolutionary theories regarding inbreeding and inbreeding depression and their links to variation in mating system.

AB - Understanding the evolutionary dynamics of inbreeding and inbreeding depression requires unbiased estimation of inbreeding depression across diverse mating systems. However, studies estimating inbreeding depression often measure inbreeding with error, for example, based on pedigree data derived from observed parental behavior that ignore paternity error stemming from multiple mating. Such paternity error causes error in estimated coefficients of inbreeding (f) and reproductive success and could bias estimates of inbreeding depression. We used complete "apparent" pedigree data compiled from observed parental behavior and analogous "actual" pedigree data comprising genetic parentage to quantify effects of paternity error stemming from extra-pair reproduction on estimates of f, reproductive success, and inbreeding depression in free-living song sparrows (Melospiza melodia). Paternity error caused widespread error in estimates of f and male reproductive success, causing inbreeding depression in male and female annual and lifetime reproductive success and juvenile male survival to be substantially underestimated. Conversely, inbreeding depression in adult male survival tended to be overestimated when paternity error was ignored. Pedigree error stemming from extra-pair reproduction therefore caused substantial and divergent bias in estimates of inbreeding depression that could bias tests of evolutionary theories regarding inbreeding and inbreeding depression and their links to variation in mating system.

KW - measurement error

KW - lethal equivalents

KW - polyandry

KW - conservation genetics

KW - paternity

KW - lifetime reproductive success

KW - sparrows melospiza-melodia

KW - wild bird population

KW - song sparrows

KW - natural-population

KW - Darwins finches

KW - within-pair

KW - fitness

KW - fertilization

KW - heritability

U2 - 10.1111/evo.12305

DO - 10.1111/evo.12305

M3 - Article

VL - 68

SP - 802

EP - 815

JO - Evolution

JF - Evolution

SN - 0014-3820

IS - 3

ER -