Periacetabular radiolucent lines: Inter- and Intra-observer agreement on post-operative radiographs.

D. Kneif, George Patrick Ashcroft, P. H. Gibson, David J. Knight, W. M. Ledingham, James Douglas Hutchison

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

5 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Peri-acetabular radiolucent lines (RLLs) seen on "early" post-operative radiographs have been identified as a potential predictor of long-term implant performance. This study examines the inter- and intra-observer variation encountered when assessing such radiographs. Four consultant orthopaedic surgeons assessed the presence, extent and width of RLLs in 220 radiographs performed on 50 patients taken one to two weeks, six weeks, six months and one year following surgery. Inter-observer agreement was fair at 7-14 days but improved to moderate to good in films at six and 12 months. Intra-observer agreement was moderate to good at 7-10 days but again improved to good at 6 and 12 months. When only the presence or absence of RLLs was considered, both inter-observer and intra-observer agreement improved for both the six-month and one-year radiographs. This experiment shows that caution must be used for the interpretation of RLLs on hip radiographs taken during the very early post-operative period. We recommend that films taken at least six weeks to six months following surgery should be used for assessment to reduce observer variation. For optimum results, a single experienced observer should do the assessment with a simple classification.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)152-155
Number of pages3
JournalInternational Orthopaedics
Volume29
Issue number3
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2005

Keywords

  • TOTAL HIP-ARTHROPLASTY
  • BONE-CEMENT INTERFACE
  • 10-YEAR FOLLOW-UP
  • REPLACEMENT
  • COMPONENTS
  • SOCKETS
  • AUTOPSY

Cite this

Periacetabular radiolucent lines: Inter- and Intra-observer agreement on post-operative radiographs. / Kneif, D.; Ashcroft, George Patrick; Gibson, P. H.; Knight, David J.; Ledingham, W. M.; Hutchison, James Douglas.

In: International Orthopaedics, Vol. 29, No. 3, 2005, p. 152-155.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Kneif, D. ; Ashcroft, George Patrick ; Gibson, P. H. ; Knight, David J. ; Ledingham, W. M. ; Hutchison, James Douglas. / Periacetabular radiolucent lines: Inter- and Intra-observer agreement on post-operative radiographs. In: International Orthopaedics. 2005 ; Vol. 29, No. 3. pp. 152-155.
@article{85c1487d1ab648afb012c1a1ffc63176,
title = "Periacetabular radiolucent lines: Inter- and Intra-observer agreement on post-operative radiographs.",
abstract = "Peri-acetabular radiolucent lines (RLLs) seen on {"}early{"} post-operative radiographs have been identified as a potential predictor of long-term implant performance. This study examines the inter- and intra-observer variation encountered when assessing such radiographs. Four consultant orthopaedic surgeons assessed the presence, extent and width of RLLs in 220 radiographs performed on 50 patients taken one to two weeks, six weeks, six months and one year following surgery. Inter-observer agreement was fair at 7-14 days but improved to moderate to good in films at six and 12 months. Intra-observer agreement was moderate to good at 7-10 days but again improved to good at 6 and 12 months. When only the presence or absence of RLLs was considered, both inter-observer and intra-observer agreement improved for both the six-month and one-year radiographs. This experiment shows that caution must be used for the interpretation of RLLs on hip radiographs taken during the very early post-operative period. We recommend that films taken at least six weeks to six months following surgery should be used for assessment to reduce observer variation. For optimum results, a single experienced observer should do the assessment with a simple classification.",
keywords = "TOTAL HIP-ARTHROPLASTY, BONE-CEMENT INTERFACE, 10-YEAR FOLLOW-UP, REPLACEMENT, COMPONENTS, SOCKETS, AUTOPSY",
author = "D. Kneif and Ashcroft, {George Patrick} and Gibson, {P. H.} and Knight, {David J.} and Ledingham, {W. M.} and Hutchison, {James Douglas}",
year = "2005",
doi = "10.1007/s00264-005-0644-8",
language = "English",
volume = "29",
pages = "152--155",
journal = "International Orthopaedics",
issn = "0341-2695",
publisher = "Springer Verlag",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Periacetabular radiolucent lines: Inter- and Intra-observer agreement on post-operative radiographs.

AU - Kneif, D.

AU - Ashcroft, George Patrick

AU - Gibson, P. H.

AU - Knight, David J.

AU - Ledingham, W. M.

AU - Hutchison, James Douglas

PY - 2005

Y1 - 2005

N2 - Peri-acetabular radiolucent lines (RLLs) seen on "early" post-operative radiographs have been identified as a potential predictor of long-term implant performance. This study examines the inter- and intra-observer variation encountered when assessing such radiographs. Four consultant orthopaedic surgeons assessed the presence, extent and width of RLLs in 220 radiographs performed on 50 patients taken one to two weeks, six weeks, six months and one year following surgery. Inter-observer agreement was fair at 7-14 days but improved to moderate to good in films at six and 12 months. Intra-observer agreement was moderate to good at 7-10 days but again improved to good at 6 and 12 months. When only the presence or absence of RLLs was considered, both inter-observer and intra-observer agreement improved for both the six-month and one-year radiographs. This experiment shows that caution must be used for the interpretation of RLLs on hip radiographs taken during the very early post-operative period. We recommend that films taken at least six weeks to six months following surgery should be used for assessment to reduce observer variation. For optimum results, a single experienced observer should do the assessment with a simple classification.

AB - Peri-acetabular radiolucent lines (RLLs) seen on "early" post-operative radiographs have been identified as a potential predictor of long-term implant performance. This study examines the inter- and intra-observer variation encountered when assessing such radiographs. Four consultant orthopaedic surgeons assessed the presence, extent and width of RLLs in 220 radiographs performed on 50 patients taken one to two weeks, six weeks, six months and one year following surgery. Inter-observer agreement was fair at 7-14 days but improved to moderate to good in films at six and 12 months. Intra-observer agreement was moderate to good at 7-10 days but again improved to good at 6 and 12 months. When only the presence or absence of RLLs was considered, both inter-observer and intra-observer agreement improved for both the six-month and one-year radiographs. This experiment shows that caution must be used for the interpretation of RLLs on hip radiographs taken during the very early post-operative period. We recommend that films taken at least six weeks to six months following surgery should be used for assessment to reduce observer variation. For optimum results, a single experienced observer should do the assessment with a simple classification.

KW - TOTAL HIP-ARTHROPLASTY

KW - BONE-CEMENT INTERFACE

KW - 10-YEAR FOLLOW-UP

KW - REPLACEMENT

KW - COMPONENTS

KW - SOCKETS

KW - AUTOPSY

U2 - 10.1007/s00264-005-0644-8

DO - 10.1007/s00264-005-0644-8

M3 - Article

VL - 29

SP - 152

EP - 155

JO - International Orthopaedics

JF - International Orthopaedics

SN - 0341-2695

IS - 3

ER -