Pessimistic assessment of white shark population status in South Africa

Comment on Andreotti et al. (2016)

Dylan T. Irion*, Leslie R. Noble, Alison A. Kock, Enrico Gennari, Matt L. Dicken, Adrian M. Hewitt, Alison V. Towner, Anthony J. Booth, Malcolm J. Smale, Geremy Cliff

*Corresponding author for this work

Research output: Contribution to journalComment/debate

4 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Andreotti et al. (2016; Mar Ecol Prog Ser 552:241-253) estimate an abundance (N) of 438 white sharks Carcharodon carcharias and a contemporary effective population size (CNe) of 333 individuals along the South African coast. N was estimated by using a mark-recapture analysis of photographic identification records from a single aggregation site (Gansbaai). CNe was calculated based on the levels of pairwise linkage disequilibrium of genetic material collected from 4 aggregation sites across approximately 965 km of South African coastline. However, due to the complex stock structure of white sharks and the model assumptions made by Andreotti et al. (2016), the conclusions drawn cannot be supported by their methods and data.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)251-255
Number of pages5
JournalMarine Ecology Progress Series
Volume577
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 18 Aug 2017

Fingerprint

Carcharodon carcharias
shark
South Africa
coast
effective population size
disequilibrium
coasts
linkage disequilibrium
population size
Africa
methodology

Keywords

  • Abundance
  • Carcharodon carcharias
  • Contemporary effective population size
  • Linkage disequilibrium
  • Mark-recapture
  • POPAN
  • White shark

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Ecology, Evolution, Behavior and Systematics
  • Ecology
  • Aquatic Science

Cite this

Irion, D. T., Noble, L. R., Kock, A. A., Gennari, E., Dicken, M. L., Hewitt, A. M., ... Cliff, G. (2017). Pessimistic assessment of white shark population status in South Africa: Comment on Andreotti et al. (2016). Marine Ecology Progress Series, 577, 251-255. https://doi.org/10.3354/meps12283

Pessimistic assessment of white shark population status in South Africa : Comment on Andreotti et al. (2016). / Irion, Dylan T.; Noble, Leslie R.; Kock, Alison A.; Gennari, Enrico; Dicken, Matt L.; Hewitt, Adrian M.; Towner, Alison V.; Booth, Anthony J.; Smale, Malcolm J.; Cliff, Geremy.

In: Marine Ecology Progress Series, Vol. 577, 18.08.2017, p. 251-255.

Research output: Contribution to journalComment/debate

Irion, DT, Noble, LR, Kock, AA, Gennari, E, Dicken, ML, Hewitt, AM, Towner, AV, Booth, AJ, Smale, MJ & Cliff, G 2017, 'Pessimistic assessment of white shark population status in South Africa: Comment on Andreotti et al. (2016)', Marine Ecology Progress Series, vol. 577, pp. 251-255. https://doi.org/10.3354/meps12283
Irion, Dylan T. ; Noble, Leslie R. ; Kock, Alison A. ; Gennari, Enrico ; Dicken, Matt L. ; Hewitt, Adrian M. ; Towner, Alison V. ; Booth, Anthony J. ; Smale, Malcolm J. ; Cliff, Geremy. / Pessimistic assessment of white shark population status in South Africa : Comment on Andreotti et al. (2016). In: Marine Ecology Progress Series. 2017 ; Vol. 577. pp. 251-255.
@article{858fd689558641fcb255fa570c6411e7,
title = "Pessimistic assessment of white shark population status in South Africa: Comment on Andreotti et al. (2016)",
abstract = "Andreotti et al. (2016; Mar Ecol Prog Ser 552:241-253) estimate an abundance (N) of 438 white sharks Carcharodon carcharias and a contemporary effective population size (CNe) of 333 individuals along the South African coast. N was estimated by using a mark-recapture analysis of photographic identification records from a single aggregation site (Gansbaai). CNe was calculated based on the levels of pairwise linkage disequilibrium of genetic material collected from 4 aggregation sites across approximately 965 km of South African coastline. However, due to the complex stock structure of white sharks and the model assumptions made by Andreotti et al. (2016), the conclusions drawn cannot be supported by their methods and data.",
keywords = "Abundance, Carcharodon carcharias, Contemporary effective population size, Linkage disequilibrium, Mark-recapture, POPAN, White shark",
author = "Irion, {Dylan T.} and Noble, {Leslie R.} and Kock, {Alison A.} and Enrico Gennari and Dicken, {Matt L.} and Hewitt, {Adrian M.} and Towner, {Alison V.} and Booth, {Anthony J.} and Smale, {Malcolm J.} and Geremy Cliff",
year = "2017",
month = "8",
day = "18",
doi = "10.3354/meps12283",
language = "English",
volume = "577",
pages = "251--255",
journal = "Marine Ecology Progress Series",
issn = "0171-8630",
publisher = "Inter-Research",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Pessimistic assessment of white shark population status in South Africa

T2 - Comment on Andreotti et al. (2016)

AU - Irion, Dylan T.

AU - Noble, Leslie R.

AU - Kock, Alison A.

AU - Gennari, Enrico

AU - Dicken, Matt L.

AU - Hewitt, Adrian M.

AU - Towner, Alison V.

AU - Booth, Anthony J.

AU - Smale, Malcolm J.

AU - Cliff, Geremy

PY - 2017/8/18

Y1 - 2017/8/18

N2 - Andreotti et al. (2016; Mar Ecol Prog Ser 552:241-253) estimate an abundance (N) of 438 white sharks Carcharodon carcharias and a contemporary effective population size (CNe) of 333 individuals along the South African coast. N was estimated by using a mark-recapture analysis of photographic identification records from a single aggregation site (Gansbaai). CNe was calculated based on the levels of pairwise linkage disequilibrium of genetic material collected from 4 aggregation sites across approximately 965 km of South African coastline. However, due to the complex stock structure of white sharks and the model assumptions made by Andreotti et al. (2016), the conclusions drawn cannot be supported by their methods and data.

AB - Andreotti et al. (2016; Mar Ecol Prog Ser 552:241-253) estimate an abundance (N) of 438 white sharks Carcharodon carcharias and a contemporary effective population size (CNe) of 333 individuals along the South African coast. N was estimated by using a mark-recapture analysis of photographic identification records from a single aggregation site (Gansbaai). CNe was calculated based on the levels of pairwise linkage disequilibrium of genetic material collected from 4 aggregation sites across approximately 965 km of South African coastline. However, due to the complex stock structure of white sharks and the model assumptions made by Andreotti et al. (2016), the conclusions drawn cannot be supported by their methods and data.

KW - Abundance

KW - Carcharodon carcharias

KW - Contemporary effective population size

KW - Linkage disequilibrium

KW - Mark-recapture

KW - POPAN

KW - White shark

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85027702243&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.3354/meps12283

DO - 10.3354/meps12283

M3 - Comment/debate

VL - 577

SP - 251

EP - 255

JO - Marine Ecology Progress Series

JF - Marine Ecology Progress Series

SN - 0171-8630

ER -