Pseudo-replication confounds the assessment of long-distance detection of gillnets by porpoises: Comment on Nielsen et al. (2012)

Stephen M. Dawson, David M. Lusseau

Research output: Contribution to journalComment/debate

2 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The harbour porpoise Phocoena phocoena is one of the small cetacean species most frequently caught in gillnets. Understanding how this occurs is important to devising effective mitigation strategies. To assess the distance at which harbour porpoises can detect and avoid gillnets, Nielsen et al. (2012; Mar Ecol Prog Ser 453: 241-248) quantified the movement of porpoises through a study area when a gillnet was present, and when it was not. They claimed to provide evidence that porpoises detected gillnets at distances >80 m, much farther than was thought possible. We show, however, that their results are undermined by pseudo-replication, and hence that their conclusion is unreliable. Mixed-effects modelling (van de Pol & Wright 2009; Anim Behav 77: 753-758) can be used to avoid this problem.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)301-302
Number of pages2
JournalMarine Ecology Progress Series
Volume478
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 25 Mar 2013

Keywords

  • Harbour porpoise
  • Echolocation
  • Gillnet
  • Pseudo-replication
  • wild harbor porpoises
  • Phocoena-Phocoena
  • Pseudoreplication

Cite this

Pseudo-replication confounds the assessment of long-distance detection of gillnets by porpoises : Comment on Nielsen et al. (2012). / Dawson, Stephen M.; Lusseau, David M.

In: Marine Ecology Progress Series, Vol. 478, 25.03.2013, p. 301-302.

Research output: Contribution to journalComment/debate

@article{1e0fd19863164e01998c117a48443af7,
title = "Pseudo-replication confounds the assessment of long-distance detection of gillnets by porpoises: Comment on Nielsen et al. (2012)",
abstract = "The harbour porpoise Phocoena phocoena is one of the small cetacean species most frequently caught in gillnets. Understanding how this occurs is important to devising effective mitigation strategies. To assess the distance at which harbour porpoises can detect and avoid gillnets, Nielsen et al. (2012; Mar Ecol Prog Ser 453: 241-248) quantified the movement of porpoises through a study area when a gillnet was present, and when it was not. They claimed to provide evidence that porpoises detected gillnets at distances >80 m, much farther than was thought possible. We show, however, that their results are undermined by pseudo-replication, and hence that their conclusion is unreliable. Mixed-effects modelling (van de Pol & Wright 2009; Anim Behav 77: 753-758) can be used to avoid this problem.",
keywords = "Harbour porpoise, Echolocation, Gillnet, Pseudo-replication, wild harbor porpoises, Phocoena-Phocoena, Pseudoreplication",
author = "Dawson, {Stephen M.} and Lusseau, {David M.}",
year = "2013",
month = "3",
day = "25",
doi = "10.3354/meps10337",
language = "English",
volume = "478",
pages = "301--302",
journal = "Marine Ecology Progress Series",
issn = "0171-8630",
publisher = "Inter-Research",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Pseudo-replication confounds the assessment of long-distance detection of gillnets by porpoises

T2 - Comment on Nielsen et al. (2012)

AU - Dawson, Stephen M.

AU - Lusseau, David M.

PY - 2013/3/25

Y1 - 2013/3/25

N2 - The harbour porpoise Phocoena phocoena is one of the small cetacean species most frequently caught in gillnets. Understanding how this occurs is important to devising effective mitigation strategies. To assess the distance at which harbour porpoises can detect and avoid gillnets, Nielsen et al. (2012; Mar Ecol Prog Ser 453: 241-248) quantified the movement of porpoises through a study area when a gillnet was present, and when it was not. They claimed to provide evidence that porpoises detected gillnets at distances >80 m, much farther than was thought possible. We show, however, that their results are undermined by pseudo-replication, and hence that their conclusion is unreliable. Mixed-effects modelling (van de Pol & Wright 2009; Anim Behav 77: 753-758) can be used to avoid this problem.

AB - The harbour porpoise Phocoena phocoena is one of the small cetacean species most frequently caught in gillnets. Understanding how this occurs is important to devising effective mitigation strategies. To assess the distance at which harbour porpoises can detect and avoid gillnets, Nielsen et al. (2012; Mar Ecol Prog Ser 453: 241-248) quantified the movement of porpoises through a study area when a gillnet was present, and when it was not. They claimed to provide evidence that porpoises detected gillnets at distances >80 m, much farther than was thought possible. We show, however, that their results are undermined by pseudo-replication, and hence that their conclusion is unreliable. Mixed-effects modelling (van de Pol & Wright 2009; Anim Behav 77: 753-758) can be used to avoid this problem.

KW - Harbour porpoise

KW - Echolocation

KW - Gillnet

KW - Pseudo-replication

KW - wild harbor porpoises

KW - Phocoena-Phocoena

KW - Pseudoreplication

U2 - 10.3354/meps10337

DO - 10.3354/meps10337

M3 - Comment/debate

VL - 478

SP - 301

EP - 302

JO - Marine Ecology Progress Series

JF - Marine Ecology Progress Series

SN - 0171-8630

ER -