Puritanism and truthfulness in Iris Murdoch's ethics

Tony Milligan

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

Abstract

In what follows I want to suggest, and to some extent argue, that Iris Murdoch’s understanding of puritanism is central to her ethic and that it constrains, or gives shape to, her account of truthfulness. But this does not indicate that truthfulness is a derivative concept while puritanism is in some way a concept of a higher order. Murdoch is, after all, a conceptual holist. She adheres to the view that concepts all hang together albeit not in the manner of a closed and self-validating system. An understanding of truthfulness can be constrained by an understanding of puritanism and, at the same time actual truthfulness can still be a key Murdochian virtue alongside other virtues such as humility and moral courage. For Murdoch, these are important character traits for agents who attempt to rein in their egocentricity in the face of the importance of the other. The fact that Murdoch’s comments on these virtues tend to be unsystematic also need not indicate (as is sometimes suggested, notably by Alasdair MacIntyre) that Murdoch lacks a sufficiently clear and detailed attitude towards particular virtues and towards the very idea of virtue. It may just as readily be seen as a preference for the exploration of particular virtues in the light of richly-detailed narratives. In line with this preference, I will comment upon her understanding of truthfulness in the light of her attitude towards puritanism and truth in A Fairly Honourable Defeat (1970).
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationIris Murdoch Connected
EditorsMark Luprecht
PublisherUniversity of Tennessee
ISBN (Print)978-1621900566
Publication statusPublished - 19 Sep 2014

Publication series

NameTennessee Studies in Literature
PublisherUniversity of Tennessee Press

Fingerprint

Puritanism
Truthfulness
Iris Murdoch
Defeat
Courage
Character Traits
Derivatives
Humility
Alasdair MacIntyre

Keywords

  • puritanism
  • Murdoch
  • truthfulness

Cite this

Milligan, T. (2014). Puritanism and truthfulness in Iris Murdoch's ethics. In M. Luprecht (Ed.), Iris Murdoch Connected (Tennessee Studies in Literature). University of Tennessee .

Puritanism and truthfulness in Iris Murdoch's ethics. / Milligan, Tony.

Iris Murdoch Connected. ed. / Mark Luprecht. University of Tennessee , 2014. (Tennessee Studies in Literature).

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

Milligan, T 2014, Puritanism and truthfulness in Iris Murdoch's ethics. in M Luprecht (ed.), Iris Murdoch Connected. Tennessee Studies in Literature, University of Tennessee .
Milligan T. Puritanism and truthfulness in Iris Murdoch's ethics. In Luprecht M, editor, Iris Murdoch Connected. University of Tennessee . 2014. (Tennessee Studies in Literature).
Milligan, Tony. / Puritanism and truthfulness in Iris Murdoch's ethics. Iris Murdoch Connected. editor / Mark Luprecht. University of Tennessee , 2014. (Tennessee Studies in Literature).
@inbook{585d1689720c43e7a1cf74769c495b47,
title = "Puritanism and truthfulness in Iris Murdoch's ethics",
abstract = "In what follows I want to suggest, and to some extent argue, that Iris Murdoch’s understanding of puritanism is central to her ethic and that it constrains, or gives shape to, her account of truthfulness. But this does not indicate that truthfulness is a derivative concept while puritanism is in some way a concept of a higher order. Murdoch is, after all, a conceptual holist. She adheres to the view that concepts all hang together albeit not in the manner of a closed and self-validating system. An understanding of truthfulness can be constrained by an understanding of puritanism and, at the same time actual truthfulness can still be a key Murdochian virtue alongside other virtues such as humility and moral courage. For Murdoch, these are important character traits for agents who attempt to rein in their egocentricity in the face of the importance of the other. The fact that Murdoch’s comments on these virtues tend to be unsystematic also need not indicate (as is sometimes suggested, notably by Alasdair MacIntyre) that Murdoch lacks a sufficiently clear and detailed attitude towards particular virtues and towards the very idea of virtue. It may just as readily be seen as a preference for the exploration of particular virtues in the light of richly-detailed narratives. In line with this preference, I will comment upon her understanding of truthfulness in the light of her attitude towards puritanism and truth in A Fairly Honourable Defeat (1970).",
keywords = "puritanism, Murdoch, truthfulness",
author = "Tony Milligan",
year = "2014",
month = "9",
day = "19",
language = "English",
isbn = "978-1621900566",
series = "Tennessee Studies in Literature",
publisher = "University of Tennessee",
editor = "Mark Luprecht",
booktitle = "Iris Murdoch Connected",

}

TY - CHAP

T1 - Puritanism and truthfulness in Iris Murdoch's ethics

AU - Milligan, Tony

PY - 2014/9/19

Y1 - 2014/9/19

N2 - In what follows I want to suggest, and to some extent argue, that Iris Murdoch’s understanding of puritanism is central to her ethic and that it constrains, or gives shape to, her account of truthfulness. But this does not indicate that truthfulness is a derivative concept while puritanism is in some way a concept of a higher order. Murdoch is, after all, a conceptual holist. She adheres to the view that concepts all hang together albeit not in the manner of a closed and self-validating system. An understanding of truthfulness can be constrained by an understanding of puritanism and, at the same time actual truthfulness can still be a key Murdochian virtue alongside other virtues such as humility and moral courage. For Murdoch, these are important character traits for agents who attempt to rein in their egocentricity in the face of the importance of the other. The fact that Murdoch’s comments on these virtues tend to be unsystematic also need not indicate (as is sometimes suggested, notably by Alasdair MacIntyre) that Murdoch lacks a sufficiently clear and detailed attitude towards particular virtues and towards the very idea of virtue. It may just as readily be seen as a preference for the exploration of particular virtues in the light of richly-detailed narratives. In line with this preference, I will comment upon her understanding of truthfulness in the light of her attitude towards puritanism and truth in A Fairly Honourable Defeat (1970).

AB - In what follows I want to suggest, and to some extent argue, that Iris Murdoch’s understanding of puritanism is central to her ethic and that it constrains, or gives shape to, her account of truthfulness. But this does not indicate that truthfulness is a derivative concept while puritanism is in some way a concept of a higher order. Murdoch is, after all, a conceptual holist. She adheres to the view that concepts all hang together albeit not in the manner of a closed and self-validating system. An understanding of truthfulness can be constrained by an understanding of puritanism and, at the same time actual truthfulness can still be a key Murdochian virtue alongside other virtues such as humility and moral courage. For Murdoch, these are important character traits for agents who attempt to rein in their egocentricity in the face of the importance of the other. The fact that Murdoch’s comments on these virtues tend to be unsystematic also need not indicate (as is sometimes suggested, notably by Alasdair MacIntyre) that Murdoch lacks a sufficiently clear and detailed attitude towards particular virtues and towards the very idea of virtue. It may just as readily be seen as a preference for the exploration of particular virtues in the light of richly-detailed narratives. In line with this preference, I will comment upon her understanding of truthfulness in the light of her attitude towards puritanism and truth in A Fairly Honourable Defeat (1970).

KW - puritanism

KW - Murdoch

KW - truthfulness

M3 - Chapter

SN - 978-1621900566

T3 - Tennessee Studies in Literature

BT - Iris Murdoch Connected

A2 - Luprecht, Mark

PB - University of Tennessee

ER -