Rapid monitoring of species abundance for biodiversity conservation

consistency and reliability of the MacKinnon lists technique

R. MacLeod, S.K. Herzog, A. Maccormick, S. R. Ewing, R. Bryce, K. Evans

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

13 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Effective monitoring of biodiversity for conservation requires information on spatial and temporal variation in species’ abundances. As conservation resources are limited, monitoring methods are required that enable rapid and cost effective data collection. There are many traditional methods of estimating absolute abundance, such as territory mapping and distance sampling. However, these typically require more time, expertise and finances than are available across much of the globe. This is especially so in the tropics, where high species richness, low densities of many species and structurally complex environments also make monitoring particularly challenging. The MacKinnon lists technique is a rapid assessment methodology designed for use in species rich environments. This method is typically used to estimate species richness, but it has also been suggested that it can generate consistent abundance indices, even when observer experience and environmental conditions vary. If this suggestion is correct, the MacKinnon lists method could be used to assess spatial or temporal changes in abundance using diverse survey data. Here, we provide the first detailed assessment of intra- and inter-observer consistency of the Mackinnon List method in generating species abundance indices that could be useful for conservation monitoring purposes. As a case study, we use one of the world’s most diverse avifaunas, that of the forested Bolivian Andes. We show that MacKinnon lists can provide species abundance indices that are consistent between observers of markedly different experience of the focal avifauna (zero to six years), and between assessments carried out in different stages of the breeding season, between which detectability of individuals differed significantly. We believe this is the first time that a biodiversity monitoring method has been demonstrated to produce consistent abundance indices for a highly diverse avian tropical assemblage. We also suggest that the MacKinnon lists methodology has the potential to be a very useful conservation monitoring tool for many taxa in species rich environments, such as the tropics.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)1374-1381
Number of pages8
JournalBiological Conservation
Volume144
Issue number5
Early online date21 Feb 2011
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - May 2011

Fingerprint

abundance index
biodiversity
monitoring
species richness
methodology
avifauna
tropics
breeding season
finance
method
species diversity
temporal variation
spatial variation
environmental conditions
natural resources conservation
sampling
cost
case studies
environmental factors

Cite this

Rapid monitoring of species abundance for biodiversity conservation : consistency and reliability of the MacKinnon lists technique. / MacLeod, R.; Herzog, S.K.; Maccormick, A.; Ewing, S. R.; Bryce, R.; Evans, K.

In: Biological Conservation, Vol. 144, No. 5, 05.2011, p. 1374-1381.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

MacLeod, R. ; Herzog, S.K. ; Maccormick, A. ; Ewing, S. R. ; Bryce, R. ; Evans, K. / Rapid monitoring of species abundance for biodiversity conservation : consistency and reliability of the MacKinnon lists technique. In: Biological Conservation. 2011 ; Vol. 144, No. 5. pp. 1374-1381.
@article{301bb7be0f554932bbec31ae421cea61,
title = "Rapid monitoring of species abundance for biodiversity conservation: consistency and reliability of the MacKinnon lists technique",
abstract = "Effective monitoring of biodiversity for conservation requires information on spatial and temporal variation in species’ abundances. As conservation resources are limited, monitoring methods are required that enable rapid and cost effective data collection. There are many traditional methods of estimating absolute abundance, such as territory mapping and distance sampling. However, these typically require more time, expertise and finances than are available across much of the globe. This is especially so in the tropics, where high species richness, low densities of many species and structurally complex environments also make monitoring particularly challenging. The MacKinnon lists technique is a rapid assessment methodology designed for use in species rich environments. This method is typically used to estimate species richness, but it has also been suggested that it can generate consistent abundance indices, even when observer experience and environmental conditions vary. If this suggestion is correct, the MacKinnon lists method could be used to assess spatial or temporal changes in abundance using diverse survey data. Here, we provide the first detailed assessment of intra- and inter-observer consistency of the Mackinnon List method in generating species abundance indices that could be useful for conservation monitoring purposes. As a case study, we use one of the world’s most diverse avifaunas, that of the forested Bolivian Andes. We show that MacKinnon lists can provide species abundance indices that are consistent between observers of markedly different experience of the focal avifauna (zero to six years), and between assessments carried out in different stages of the breeding season, between which detectability of individuals differed significantly. We believe this is the first time that a biodiversity monitoring method has been demonstrated to produce consistent abundance indices for a highly diverse avian tropical assemblage. We also suggest that the MacKinnon lists methodology has the potential to be a very useful conservation monitoring tool for many taxa in species rich environments, such as the tropics.",
author = "R. MacLeod and S.K. Herzog and A. Maccormick and Ewing, {S. R.} and R. Bryce and K. Evans",
year = "2011",
month = "5",
doi = "10.1016/j.biocon.2010.12.008",
language = "English",
volume = "144",
pages = "1374--1381",
journal = "Biological Conservation",
issn = "0006-3207",
publisher = "Elsevier BV",
number = "5",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Rapid monitoring of species abundance for biodiversity conservation

T2 - consistency and reliability of the MacKinnon lists technique

AU - MacLeod, R.

AU - Herzog, S.K.

AU - Maccormick, A.

AU - Ewing, S. R.

AU - Bryce, R.

AU - Evans, K.

PY - 2011/5

Y1 - 2011/5

N2 - Effective monitoring of biodiversity for conservation requires information on spatial and temporal variation in species’ abundances. As conservation resources are limited, monitoring methods are required that enable rapid and cost effective data collection. There are many traditional methods of estimating absolute abundance, such as territory mapping and distance sampling. However, these typically require more time, expertise and finances than are available across much of the globe. This is especially so in the tropics, where high species richness, low densities of many species and structurally complex environments also make monitoring particularly challenging. The MacKinnon lists technique is a rapid assessment methodology designed for use in species rich environments. This method is typically used to estimate species richness, but it has also been suggested that it can generate consistent abundance indices, even when observer experience and environmental conditions vary. If this suggestion is correct, the MacKinnon lists method could be used to assess spatial or temporal changes in abundance using diverse survey data. Here, we provide the first detailed assessment of intra- and inter-observer consistency of the Mackinnon List method in generating species abundance indices that could be useful for conservation monitoring purposes. As a case study, we use one of the world’s most diverse avifaunas, that of the forested Bolivian Andes. We show that MacKinnon lists can provide species abundance indices that are consistent between observers of markedly different experience of the focal avifauna (zero to six years), and between assessments carried out in different stages of the breeding season, between which detectability of individuals differed significantly. We believe this is the first time that a biodiversity monitoring method has been demonstrated to produce consistent abundance indices for a highly diverse avian tropical assemblage. We also suggest that the MacKinnon lists methodology has the potential to be a very useful conservation monitoring tool for many taxa in species rich environments, such as the tropics.

AB - Effective monitoring of biodiversity for conservation requires information on spatial and temporal variation in species’ abundances. As conservation resources are limited, monitoring methods are required that enable rapid and cost effective data collection. There are many traditional methods of estimating absolute abundance, such as territory mapping and distance sampling. However, these typically require more time, expertise and finances than are available across much of the globe. This is especially so in the tropics, where high species richness, low densities of many species and structurally complex environments also make monitoring particularly challenging. The MacKinnon lists technique is a rapid assessment methodology designed for use in species rich environments. This method is typically used to estimate species richness, but it has also been suggested that it can generate consistent abundance indices, even when observer experience and environmental conditions vary. If this suggestion is correct, the MacKinnon lists method could be used to assess spatial or temporal changes in abundance using diverse survey data. Here, we provide the first detailed assessment of intra- and inter-observer consistency of the Mackinnon List method in generating species abundance indices that could be useful for conservation monitoring purposes. As a case study, we use one of the world’s most diverse avifaunas, that of the forested Bolivian Andes. We show that MacKinnon lists can provide species abundance indices that are consistent between observers of markedly different experience of the focal avifauna (zero to six years), and between assessments carried out in different stages of the breeding season, between which detectability of individuals differed significantly. We believe this is the first time that a biodiversity monitoring method has been demonstrated to produce consistent abundance indices for a highly diverse avian tropical assemblage. We also suggest that the MacKinnon lists methodology has the potential to be a very useful conservation monitoring tool for many taxa in species rich environments, such as the tropics.

U2 - 10.1016/j.biocon.2010.12.008

DO - 10.1016/j.biocon.2010.12.008

M3 - Article

VL - 144

SP - 1374

EP - 1381

JO - Biological Conservation

JF - Biological Conservation

SN - 0006-3207

IS - 5

ER -