Recruiting and retaining postpartum women from areas of social disadvantage in a weight-loss trial

an assessment of strategies employed in the WeighWell feasibility study

Maureen Macleod, Angela M. Craigie, Karen L. Barton, Shaun Treweek, Annie S. Anderson*, WeighWell Team

*Corresponding author for this work

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

6 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Little is known about the response of post-partum women from deprived backgrounds to weight management interventions, however behavioural intervention trials in disadvantaged communities are often characterised by recruitment difficulties. Recruitment and retention is key to the robust conduct of an effective trial, and exploratory work is essential prior to a definitive randomised controlled trial. This paper describes strategies used to recruit to the WeighWell feasibility study, which aimed to recruit 60 overweight or obese post-partum women living in areas of deprivation to a trial of a weight-loss intervention. Recruitment strategies included the following: (1) distribution of posters and business cards'; (2) newspaper advertisements; (3) visits to community groups; and (4) personalised letters of invitation sent via the National Health Service (NHS). Potential participants were screened for eligibility following response to a Freephone number. Body mass index was calculated using self-reported body weight and height. Over 6 months, 142 women responded of whom 65 (46%) met the eligibility criteria. The most effective methods for recruiting eligible women and those who went on to complete the study (n=36) were visits to community groups (37% and 42%, respectively), personalised letters (26% and 17%, respectively) and posters and business cards' (22% and 31%, respectively). These results emphasise the need to utilise a range of strategies beyond traditional NHS settings. Current approaches might be enhanced by sending personal contact letters via their General Practitioner to women identified as eligible at post-natal discharge. Under-reporting of body weight by self-report suggests that a threshold lower than 25kg/m2 should be utilised for screening purposes.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)322-331
Number of pages10
JournalMaternal and Child Nutrition
Volume9
Issue number3
Early online date29 Jan 2012
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Jul 2013

Keywords

  • post-partum
  • weight loss
  • recruitment
  • strategies
  • obesity

Cite this

Recruiting and retaining postpartum women from areas of social disadvantage in a weight-loss trial : an assessment of strategies employed in the WeighWell feasibility study. / Macleod, Maureen; Craigie, Angela M.; Barton, Karen L.; Treweek, Shaun; Anderson, Annie S.; WeighWell Team.

In: Maternal and Child Nutrition, Vol. 9, No. 3, 07.2013, p. 322-331.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{5f5e277c7f4e459f9b71197d3ce47696,
title = "Recruiting and retaining postpartum women from areas of social disadvantage in a weight-loss trial: an assessment of strategies employed in the WeighWell feasibility study",
abstract = "Little is known about the response of post-partum women from deprived backgrounds to weight management interventions, however behavioural intervention trials in disadvantaged communities are often characterised by recruitment difficulties. Recruitment and retention is key to the robust conduct of an effective trial, and exploratory work is essential prior to a definitive randomised controlled trial. This paper describes strategies used to recruit to the WeighWell feasibility study, which aimed to recruit 60 overweight or obese post-partum women living in areas of deprivation to a trial of a weight-loss intervention. Recruitment strategies included the following: (1) distribution of posters and business cards'; (2) newspaper advertisements; (3) visits to community groups; and (4) personalised letters of invitation sent via the National Health Service (NHS). Potential participants were screened for eligibility following response to a Freephone number. Body mass index was calculated using self-reported body weight and height. Over 6 months, 142 women responded of whom 65 (46{\%}) met the eligibility criteria. The most effective methods for recruiting eligible women and those who went on to complete the study (n=36) were visits to community groups (37{\%} and 42{\%}, respectively), personalised letters (26{\%} and 17{\%}, respectively) and posters and business cards' (22{\%} and 31{\%}, respectively). These results emphasise the need to utilise a range of strategies beyond traditional NHS settings. Current approaches might be enhanced by sending personal contact letters via their General Practitioner to women identified as eligible at post-natal discharge. Under-reporting of body weight by self-report suggests that a threshold lower than 25kg/m2 should be utilised for screening purposes.",
keywords = "post-partum, weight loss, recruitment, strategies, obesity",
author = "Maureen Macleod and Craigie, {Angela M.} and Barton, {Karen L.} and Shaun Treweek and Anderson, {Annie S.} and {WeighWell Team} and Anne Ludbrook",
note = "Acknowledgements The authors would like to thank Margaret Robertson, the project lifestyle counsellor and Amy Gregor for the development of study tools. Source of funding This work was funded by the Medical Research Council (Ref GO701771).",
year = "2013",
month = "7",
doi = "10.1111/j.1740-8709.2011.00393.x",
language = "English",
volume = "9",
pages = "322--331",
journal = "Maternal and Child Nutrition",
issn = "1740-8695",
publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Recruiting and retaining postpartum women from areas of social disadvantage in a weight-loss trial

T2 - an assessment of strategies employed in the WeighWell feasibility study

AU - Macleod, Maureen

AU - Craigie, Angela M.

AU - Barton, Karen L.

AU - Treweek, Shaun

AU - Anderson, Annie S.

AU - WeighWell Team

A2 - Ludbrook, Anne

N1 - Acknowledgements The authors would like to thank Margaret Robertson, the project lifestyle counsellor and Amy Gregor for the development of study tools. Source of funding This work was funded by the Medical Research Council (Ref GO701771).

PY - 2013/7

Y1 - 2013/7

N2 - Little is known about the response of post-partum women from deprived backgrounds to weight management interventions, however behavioural intervention trials in disadvantaged communities are often characterised by recruitment difficulties. Recruitment and retention is key to the robust conduct of an effective trial, and exploratory work is essential prior to a definitive randomised controlled trial. This paper describes strategies used to recruit to the WeighWell feasibility study, which aimed to recruit 60 overweight or obese post-partum women living in areas of deprivation to a trial of a weight-loss intervention. Recruitment strategies included the following: (1) distribution of posters and business cards'; (2) newspaper advertisements; (3) visits to community groups; and (4) personalised letters of invitation sent via the National Health Service (NHS). Potential participants were screened for eligibility following response to a Freephone number. Body mass index was calculated using self-reported body weight and height. Over 6 months, 142 women responded of whom 65 (46%) met the eligibility criteria. The most effective methods for recruiting eligible women and those who went on to complete the study (n=36) were visits to community groups (37% and 42%, respectively), personalised letters (26% and 17%, respectively) and posters and business cards' (22% and 31%, respectively). These results emphasise the need to utilise a range of strategies beyond traditional NHS settings. Current approaches might be enhanced by sending personal contact letters via their General Practitioner to women identified as eligible at post-natal discharge. Under-reporting of body weight by self-report suggests that a threshold lower than 25kg/m2 should be utilised for screening purposes.

AB - Little is known about the response of post-partum women from deprived backgrounds to weight management interventions, however behavioural intervention trials in disadvantaged communities are often characterised by recruitment difficulties. Recruitment and retention is key to the robust conduct of an effective trial, and exploratory work is essential prior to a definitive randomised controlled trial. This paper describes strategies used to recruit to the WeighWell feasibility study, which aimed to recruit 60 overweight or obese post-partum women living in areas of deprivation to a trial of a weight-loss intervention. Recruitment strategies included the following: (1) distribution of posters and business cards'; (2) newspaper advertisements; (3) visits to community groups; and (4) personalised letters of invitation sent via the National Health Service (NHS). Potential participants were screened for eligibility following response to a Freephone number. Body mass index was calculated using self-reported body weight and height. Over 6 months, 142 women responded of whom 65 (46%) met the eligibility criteria. The most effective methods for recruiting eligible women and those who went on to complete the study (n=36) were visits to community groups (37% and 42%, respectively), personalised letters (26% and 17%, respectively) and posters and business cards' (22% and 31%, respectively). These results emphasise the need to utilise a range of strategies beyond traditional NHS settings. Current approaches might be enhanced by sending personal contact letters via their General Practitioner to women identified as eligible at post-natal discharge. Under-reporting of body weight by self-report suggests that a threshold lower than 25kg/m2 should be utilised for screening purposes.

KW - post-partum

KW - weight loss

KW - recruitment

KW - strategies

KW - obesity

U2 - 10.1111/j.1740-8709.2011.00393.x

DO - 10.1111/j.1740-8709.2011.00393.x

M3 - Article

VL - 9

SP - 322

EP - 331

JO - Maternal and Child Nutrition

JF - Maternal and Child Nutrition

SN - 1740-8695

IS - 3

ER -