Restoration and intensive management have no effect on evolutionary strategies

M. Hayward, R. Kowalczyk, Z. A. Krasinski, M. Krasinska, J. Dackiewicz, T. Cornulier

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

The European bison Bison bonasus is the largest extant terrestrial mammal on the European continent; however, the species went extinct in the wild in 1919. Restoration started in 1929 in Poland’s Bialowiez¿a Primeval Forest using captive individuals sourced from zoological gardens and breeding centres. Of the 7 founders, 2 individuals contributed 85% to the genetic make-up of the lowland line of the species. The Bialowiez¿a bison population numbered 820 in 2008, but very low genetic diversity and a high level of management have raised questions as to whether it still conforms to evolutionary predictions. We tested whether the sex ratio of European bison calves conformed to the Trivers-Willard hypothesis at the population level, i.e. whether it became increasingly female-biased as bison condition deteriorated following increased population density. We found that increased population density and reduced female body mass led to increasing female-biased calf sex ratios, whereas mast years (abundant food resources) corresponded to male-biased sex ratios. Despite the high degree of inbreeding and management, European bison are still responding as expected to variations in female body condition; however, the precautionary principle cautions managers of small populations that artificial selection can alter the evolutionary strategy of wildlife even though we did not detect this in theBialowiez¿a bison population.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)53-61
Number of pages9
JournalEndangered Species Research
Volume15
Issue number1
Early online date21 Oct 2011
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 21 Oct 2011

Fingerprint

sex ratio
population density
precautionary principle
zoo
body condition
inbreeding
body mass
mammal
breeding
food
restoration
effect
resource
prediction
wildlife
continent
genetic diversity

Keywords

  • body condition
  • local resource competition hypothesis
  • maternal investment
  • reproductive success
  • sex ratio manipulation
  • Trivers-Willard hypothesis
  • European bison
  • ungulates

Cite this

Restoration and intensive management have no effect on evolutionary strategies. / Hayward, M.; Kowalczyk, R.; Krasinski, Z. A.; Krasinska, M.; Dackiewicz, J.; Cornulier, T.

In: Endangered Species Research, Vol. 15, No. 1, 21.10.2011, p. 53-61.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Hayward, M, Kowalczyk, R, Krasinski, ZA, Krasinska, M, Dackiewicz, J & Cornulier, T 2011, 'Restoration and intensive management have no effect on evolutionary strategies', Endangered Species Research, vol. 15, no. 1, pp. 53-61. https://doi.org/10.3354/esr00371
Hayward, M. ; Kowalczyk, R. ; Krasinski, Z. A. ; Krasinska, M. ; Dackiewicz, J. ; Cornulier, T. / Restoration and intensive management have no effect on evolutionary strategies. In: Endangered Species Research. 2011 ; Vol. 15, No. 1. pp. 53-61.
@article{5099cba490dc4e969d44ddbbda7a170b,
title = "Restoration and intensive management have no effect on evolutionary strategies",
abstract = "The European bison Bison bonasus is the largest extant terrestrial mammal on the European continent; however, the species went extinct in the wild in 1919. Restoration started in 1929 in Poland’s Bialowiez¿a Primeval Forest using captive individuals sourced from zoological gardens and breeding centres. Of the 7 founders, 2 individuals contributed 85{\%} to the genetic make-up of the lowland line of the species. The Bialowiez¿a bison population numbered 820 in 2008, but very low genetic diversity and a high level of management have raised questions as to whether it still conforms to evolutionary predictions. We tested whether the sex ratio of European bison calves conformed to the Trivers-Willard hypothesis at the population level, i.e. whether it became increasingly female-biased as bison condition deteriorated following increased population density. We found that increased population density and reduced female body mass led to increasing female-biased calf sex ratios, whereas mast years (abundant food resources) corresponded to male-biased sex ratios. Despite the high degree of inbreeding and management, European bison are still responding as expected to variations in female body condition; however, the precautionary principle cautions managers of small populations that artificial selection can alter the evolutionary strategy of wildlife even though we did not detect this in theBialowiez¿a bison population.",
keywords = "body condition, local resource competition hypothesis, maternal investment, reproductive success, sex ratio manipulation, Trivers-Willard hypothesis, European bison, ungulates",
author = "M. Hayward and R. Kowalczyk and Krasinski, {Z. A.} and M. Krasinska and J. Dackiewicz and T. Cornulier",
year = "2011",
month = "10",
day = "21",
doi = "10.3354/esr00371",
language = "English",
volume = "15",
pages = "53--61",
journal = "Endangered Species Research",
issn = "1863-5407",
publisher = "Inter-Research",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Restoration and intensive management have no effect on evolutionary strategies

AU - Hayward, M.

AU - Kowalczyk, R.

AU - Krasinski, Z. A.

AU - Krasinska, M.

AU - Dackiewicz, J.

AU - Cornulier, T.

PY - 2011/10/21

Y1 - 2011/10/21

N2 - The European bison Bison bonasus is the largest extant terrestrial mammal on the European continent; however, the species went extinct in the wild in 1919. Restoration started in 1929 in Poland’s Bialowiez¿a Primeval Forest using captive individuals sourced from zoological gardens and breeding centres. Of the 7 founders, 2 individuals contributed 85% to the genetic make-up of the lowland line of the species. The Bialowiez¿a bison population numbered 820 in 2008, but very low genetic diversity and a high level of management have raised questions as to whether it still conforms to evolutionary predictions. We tested whether the sex ratio of European bison calves conformed to the Trivers-Willard hypothesis at the population level, i.e. whether it became increasingly female-biased as bison condition deteriorated following increased population density. We found that increased population density and reduced female body mass led to increasing female-biased calf sex ratios, whereas mast years (abundant food resources) corresponded to male-biased sex ratios. Despite the high degree of inbreeding and management, European bison are still responding as expected to variations in female body condition; however, the precautionary principle cautions managers of small populations that artificial selection can alter the evolutionary strategy of wildlife even though we did not detect this in theBialowiez¿a bison population.

AB - The European bison Bison bonasus is the largest extant terrestrial mammal on the European continent; however, the species went extinct in the wild in 1919. Restoration started in 1929 in Poland’s Bialowiez¿a Primeval Forest using captive individuals sourced from zoological gardens and breeding centres. Of the 7 founders, 2 individuals contributed 85% to the genetic make-up of the lowland line of the species. The Bialowiez¿a bison population numbered 820 in 2008, but very low genetic diversity and a high level of management have raised questions as to whether it still conforms to evolutionary predictions. We tested whether the sex ratio of European bison calves conformed to the Trivers-Willard hypothesis at the population level, i.e. whether it became increasingly female-biased as bison condition deteriorated following increased population density. We found that increased population density and reduced female body mass led to increasing female-biased calf sex ratios, whereas mast years (abundant food resources) corresponded to male-biased sex ratios. Despite the high degree of inbreeding and management, European bison are still responding as expected to variations in female body condition; however, the precautionary principle cautions managers of small populations that artificial selection can alter the evolutionary strategy of wildlife even though we did not detect this in theBialowiez¿a bison population.

KW - body condition

KW - local resource competition hypothesis

KW - maternal investment

KW - reproductive success

KW - sex ratio manipulation

KW - Trivers-Willard hypothesis

KW - European bison

KW - ungulates

U2 - 10.3354/esr00371

DO - 10.3354/esr00371

M3 - Article

VL - 15

SP - 53

EP - 61

JO - Endangered Species Research

JF - Endangered Species Research

SN - 1863-5407

IS - 1

ER -