'Scotland as a Potential Small State'

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

Abstract

The inclusion of Scotland in a compendium on small states might come as a surprise to global observers who witnessed Scotland – by a margin of 55 per cent to 45 per cent – vote against the proposal to become an independent country in September 2014. Nevertheless, the process by which Scotland reached this decision, and the subsequent constitutional journey the UK itself embarked upon, provides a fascinating insight into how small would-be states think, plan and operate. The referendum campaign and, particularly, the Scottish National Party (SNP)’s proposals for independence were framed not, as one might expect, in terms of national identity and nationalism, but in terms of public policy outcomes and democratic accountability. From those proposals, it is clear to see the type of state that the SNP envisioned Scotland becoming. This chapter, through analysis of the Scottish Government’s (2013) White Paper on independence, Scotland’s Future, as well as close consideration of the referendum campaign, contributes to the small-state literature by examining the prospective features of an independent Scottish state. Of particular interest here is the influence of the so-called ‘Nordic model’ on the Scottish Government’s thinking – the proposals, specifically, to develop a social investment model, albeit with lower levels of taxation than most social investment states. It assesses the scope for changes to the institutional setting that would have been required to deliver such a model in Scotland.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationSmall States in the Modern World: Vulnerabilities and Opportunities
EditorsHarald Baldersheim, Michael Keating
Place of PublicationCheltenham
PublisherEdward Elgar Publishing Ltd.
Pages145-162
Number of pages18
ISBN (Print)978 1 78471 143 6
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2015

Publication series

NameSocial and Political Science 2015

Fingerprint

small state
social investment
referendum
campaign
taxation
national identity
nationalism
voter
public policy
inclusion
responsibility

Cite this

Harvey, M. (2015). 'Scotland as a Potential Small State'. In H. Baldersheim, & M. Keating (Eds.), Small States in the Modern World: Vulnerabilities and Opportunities (pp. 145-162). (Social and Political Science 2015). Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing Ltd.. https://doi.org/10.4337/9781784711443.00020

'Scotland as a Potential Small State'. / Harvey, Malcolm.

Small States in the Modern World: Vulnerabilities and Opportunities. ed. / Harald Baldersheim; Michael Keating. Cheltenham : Edward Elgar Publishing Ltd., 2015. p. 145-162 (Social and Political Science 2015).

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

Harvey, M 2015, 'Scotland as a Potential Small State'. in H Baldersheim & M Keating (eds), Small States in the Modern World: Vulnerabilities and Opportunities. Social and Political Science 2015, Edward Elgar Publishing Ltd., Cheltenham, pp. 145-162. https://doi.org/10.4337/9781784711443.00020
Harvey M. 'Scotland as a Potential Small State'. In Baldersheim H, Keating M, editors, Small States in the Modern World: Vulnerabilities and Opportunities. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing Ltd. 2015. p. 145-162. (Social and Political Science 2015). https://doi.org/10.4337/9781784711443.00020
Harvey, Malcolm. / 'Scotland as a Potential Small State'. Small States in the Modern World: Vulnerabilities and Opportunities. editor / Harald Baldersheim ; Michael Keating. Cheltenham : Edward Elgar Publishing Ltd., 2015. pp. 145-162 (Social and Political Science 2015).
@inbook{49f583abb9614789a1dbe815ab39c552,
title = "'Scotland as a Potential Small State'",
abstract = "The inclusion of Scotland in a compendium on small states might come as a surprise to global observers who witnessed Scotland – by a margin of 55 per cent to 45 per cent – vote against the proposal to become an independent country in September 2014. Nevertheless, the process by which Scotland reached this decision, and the subsequent constitutional journey the UK itself embarked upon, provides a fascinating insight into how small would-be states think, plan and operate. The referendum campaign and, particularly, the Scottish National Party (SNP)’s proposals for independence were framed not, as one might expect, in terms of national identity and nationalism, but in terms of public policy outcomes and democratic accountability. From those proposals, it is clear to see the type of state that the SNP envisioned Scotland becoming. This chapter, through analysis of the Scottish Government’s (2013) White Paper on independence, Scotland’s Future, as well as close consideration of the referendum campaign, contributes to the small-state literature by examining the prospective features of an independent Scottish state. Of particular interest here is the influence of the so-called ‘Nordic model’ on the Scottish Government’s thinking – the proposals, specifically, to develop a social investment model, albeit with lower levels of taxation than most social investment states. It assesses the scope for changes to the institutional setting that would have been required to deliver such a model in Scotland.",
author = "Malcolm Harvey",
year = "2015",
doi = "10.4337/9781784711443.00020",
language = "English",
isbn = "978 1 78471 143 6",
series = "Social and Political Science 2015",
publisher = "Edward Elgar Publishing Ltd.",
pages = "145--162",
editor = "Harald Baldersheim and Michael Keating",
booktitle = "Small States in the Modern World: Vulnerabilities and Opportunities",

}

TY - CHAP

T1 - 'Scotland as a Potential Small State'

AU - Harvey, Malcolm

PY - 2015

Y1 - 2015

N2 - The inclusion of Scotland in a compendium on small states might come as a surprise to global observers who witnessed Scotland – by a margin of 55 per cent to 45 per cent – vote against the proposal to become an independent country in September 2014. Nevertheless, the process by which Scotland reached this decision, and the subsequent constitutional journey the UK itself embarked upon, provides a fascinating insight into how small would-be states think, plan and operate. The referendum campaign and, particularly, the Scottish National Party (SNP)’s proposals for independence were framed not, as one might expect, in terms of national identity and nationalism, but in terms of public policy outcomes and democratic accountability. From those proposals, it is clear to see the type of state that the SNP envisioned Scotland becoming. This chapter, through analysis of the Scottish Government’s (2013) White Paper on independence, Scotland’s Future, as well as close consideration of the referendum campaign, contributes to the small-state literature by examining the prospective features of an independent Scottish state. Of particular interest here is the influence of the so-called ‘Nordic model’ on the Scottish Government’s thinking – the proposals, specifically, to develop a social investment model, albeit with lower levels of taxation than most social investment states. It assesses the scope for changes to the institutional setting that would have been required to deliver such a model in Scotland.

AB - The inclusion of Scotland in a compendium on small states might come as a surprise to global observers who witnessed Scotland – by a margin of 55 per cent to 45 per cent – vote against the proposal to become an independent country in September 2014. Nevertheless, the process by which Scotland reached this decision, and the subsequent constitutional journey the UK itself embarked upon, provides a fascinating insight into how small would-be states think, plan and operate. The referendum campaign and, particularly, the Scottish National Party (SNP)’s proposals for independence were framed not, as one might expect, in terms of national identity and nationalism, but in terms of public policy outcomes and democratic accountability. From those proposals, it is clear to see the type of state that the SNP envisioned Scotland becoming. This chapter, through analysis of the Scottish Government’s (2013) White Paper on independence, Scotland’s Future, as well as close consideration of the referendum campaign, contributes to the small-state literature by examining the prospective features of an independent Scottish state. Of particular interest here is the influence of the so-called ‘Nordic model’ on the Scottish Government’s thinking – the proposals, specifically, to develop a social investment model, albeit with lower levels of taxation than most social investment states. It assesses the scope for changes to the institutional setting that would have been required to deliver such a model in Scotland.

U2 - 10.4337/9781784711443.00020

DO - 10.4337/9781784711443.00020

M3 - Chapter

SN - 978 1 78471 143 6

T3 - Social and Political Science 2015

SP - 145

EP - 162

BT - Small States in the Modern World: Vulnerabilities and Opportunities

A2 - Baldersheim, Harald

A2 - Keating, Michael

PB - Edward Elgar Publishing Ltd.

CY - Cheltenham

ER -