Second generation endometrial ablation techniques for heavy menstrual bleeding: network meta-analysis

J. P. Daniels, L. J. Middleton, R. Champaneria, K. S. Khan, K. Cooper, B. W. J. Mol, S. Bhattacharya, Int Heavy Menstrual Bleeding IPD M

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

65 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Objective To determine the relative effectiveness of second generation ablation techniques in the treatment of heavy menstrual bleeding.

Design Network meta-analysis on the primary outcome measures of amenorrhoea, heavy bleeding, and patients' dissatisfaction with treatment.

Data sources Nineteen randomised controlled trials (involving 3287 women) were identified through electronic searches of the Cochrane Library, Medline, Embase and PsycINFO databases from inception to April 2011. The reference lists of known relevant articles were searched for further articles. Two reviewers independently selected articles without language restrictions.

Eligibility criteria for selecting studies Randomised controlled trials involving second generation endometrial destruction techniques for women with heavy menstrual bleeding unresponsive to medical treatment.

Results Of the three most commonly used techniques, network meta-analysis showed that bipolar radiofrequency and microwave ablation resulted in higher rates of amenorrhoea than thermal balloon ablation at around 12 months (odds ratio 2.51, 95% confidence interval 1.53 to 4.12, P<0.001; and 1.66, 1.01 to 2.71, P=0.05, respectively), but there was no evidence of a convincing difference between the three techniques in the number of women dissatisfied with treatment or still experiencing heavy bleeding. Compared with bipolar radio frequency and microwave devices, an increased number of women still experienced heavy bleeding after free fluid ablation (2.19, 1.07 to 4.50, P=0.03; and 2.91, 1.23 to 6.88, P=0.02, respectively). Compared with radio frequency ablation, free fluid ablation was associated with reduced rates of amenorrhoea (0.36, 0.19 to 0.67, P=0.004) and increased rates of dissatisfaction (4.79, 1.07 to 21.5, P=0.04). Of the less commonly used devices, endometrial laser intrauterine thermotherapy was associated with increased rates of amenorrhoea compared with all the other devices, while cryoablation led to a reduced rate compared with bipolar radio frequency and microwave.

Conclusions Bipolar radio frequency and microwave ablative devices are more effective than thermal balloon and free fluid ablation in the treatment of heavy menstrual bleeding with second generation endometrial ablation devices.

Original languageEnglish
Article numbere2564
Number of pages12
JournalBMJ
Volume344
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 23 Apr 2012

Cite this

Daniels, J. P., Middleton, L. J., Champaneria, R., Khan, K. S., Cooper, K., Mol, B. W. J., ... Int Heavy Menstrual Bleeding IPD M (2012). Second generation endometrial ablation techniques for heavy menstrual bleeding: network meta-analysis. BMJ, 344, [e2564]. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.e2564

Second generation endometrial ablation techniques for heavy menstrual bleeding : network meta-analysis. / Daniels, J. P.; Middleton, L. J.; Champaneria, R.; Khan, K. S.; Cooper, K.; Mol, B. W. J.; Bhattacharya, S.; Int Heavy Menstrual Bleeding IPD M.

In: BMJ, Vol. 344, e2564, 23.04.2012.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Daniels, JP, Middleton, LJ, Champaneria, R, Khan, KS, Cooper, K, Mol, BWJ, Bhattacharya, S & Int Heavy Menstrual Bleeding IPD M 2012, 'Second generation endometrial ablation techniques for heavy menstrual bleeding: network meta-analysis', BMJ, vol. 344, e2564. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.e2564
Daniels, J. P. ; Middleton, L. J. ; Champaneria, R. ; Khan, K. S. ; Cooper, K. ; Mol, B. W. J. ; Bhattacharya, S. ; Int Heavy Menstrual Bleeding IPD M. / Second generation endometrial ablation techniques for heavy menstrual bleeding : network meta-analysis. In: BMJ. 2012 ; Vol. 344.
@article{871a1bb802f940e9a984fa9a02087fe4,
title = "Second generation endometrial ablation techniques for heavy menstrual bleeding: network meta-analysis",
abstract = "Objective To determine the relative effectiveness of second generation ablation techniques in the treatment of heavy menstrual bleeding.Design Network meta-analysis on the primary outcome measures of amenorrhoea, heavy bleeding, and patients' dissatisfaction with treatment.Data sources Nineteen randomised controlled trials (involving 3287 women) were identified through electronic searches of the Cochrane Library, Medline, Embase and PsycINFO databases from inception to April 2011. The reference lists of known relevant articles were searched for further articles. Two reviewers independently selected articles without language restrictions.Eligibility criteria for selecting studies Randomised controlled trials involving second generation endometrial destruction techniques for women with heavy menstrual bleeding unresponsive to medical treatment.Results Of the three most commonly used techniques, network meta-analysis showed that bipolar radiofrequency and microwave ablation resulted in higher rates of amenorrhoea than thermal balloon ablation at around 12 months (odds ratio 2.51, 95{\%} confidence interval 1.53 to 4.12, P<0.001; and 1.66, 1.01 to 2.71, P=0.05, respectively), but there was no evidence of a convincing difference between the three techniques in the number of women dissatisfied with treatment or still experiencing heavy bleeding. Compared with bipolar radio frequency and microwave devices, an increased number of women still experienced heavy bleeding after free fluid ablation (2.19, 1.07 to 4.50, P=0.03; and 2.91, 1.23 to 6.88, P=0.02, respectively). Compared with radio frequency ablation, free fluid ablation was associated with reduced rates of amenorrhoea (0.36, 0.19 to 0.67, P=0.004) and increased rates of dissatisfaction (4.79, 1.07 to 21.5, P=0.04). Of the less commonly used devices, endometrial laser intrauterine thermotherapy was associated with increased rates of amenorrhoea compared with all the other devices, while cryoablation led to a reduced rate compared with bipolar radio frequency and microwave.Conclusions Bipolar radio frequency and microwave ablative devices are more effective than thermal balloon and free fluid ablation in the treatment of heavy menstrual bleeding with second generation endometrial ablation devices.",
author = "Daniels, {J. P.} and Middleton, {L. J.} and R. Champaneria and Khan, {K. S.} and K. Cooper and Mol, {B. W. J.} and S. Bhattacharya and {Int Heavy Menstrual Bleeding IPD M}",
year = "2012",
month = "4",
day = "23",
doi = "10.1136/bmj.e2564",
language = "English",
volume = "344",
journal = "BMJ",
issn = "0959-8146",
publisher = "BMJ Publishing Group",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Second generation endometrial ablation techniques for heavy menstrual bleeding

T2 - network meta-analysis

AU - Daniels, J. P.

AU - Middleton, L. J.

AU - Champaneria, R.

AU - Khan, K. S.

AU - Cooper, K.

AU - Mol, B. W. J.

AU - Bhattacharya, S.

AU - Int Heavy Menstrual Bleeding IPD M

PY - 2012/4/23

Y1 - 2012/4/23

N2 - Objective To determine the relative effectiveness of second generation ablation techniques in the treatment of heavy menstrual bleeding.Design Network meta-analysis on the primary outcome measures of amenorrhoea, heavy bleeding, and patients' dissatisfaction with treatment.Data sources Nineteen randomised controlled trials (involving 3287 women) were identified through electronic searches of the Cochrane Library, Medline, Embase and PsycINFO databases from inception to April 2011. The reference lists of known relevant articles were searched for further articles. Two reviewers independently selected articles without language restrictions.Eligibility criteria for selecting studies Randomised controlled trials involving second generation endometrial destruction techniques for women with heavy menstrual bleeding unresponsive to medical treatment.Results Of the three most commonly used techniques, network meta-analysis showed that bipolar radiofrequency and microwave ablation resulted in higher rates of amenorrhoea than thermal balloon ablation at around 12 months (odds ratio 2.51, 95% confidence interval 1.53 to 4.12, P<0.001; and 1.66, 1.01 to 2.71, P=0.05, respectively), but there was no evidence of a convincing difference between the three techniques in the number of women dissatisfied with treatment or still experiencing heavy bleeding. Compared with bipolar radio frequency and microwave devices, an increased number of women still experienced heavy bleeding after free fluid ablation (2.19, 1.07 to 4.50, P=0.03; and 2.91, 1.23 to 6.88, P=0.02, respectively). Compared with radio frequency ablation, free fluid ablation was associated with reduced rates of amenorrhoea (0.36, 0.19 to 0.67, P=0.004) and increased rates of dissatisfaction (4.79, 1.07 to 21.5, P=0.04). Of the less commonly used devices, endometrial laser intrauterine thermotherapy was associated with increased rates of amenorrhoea compared with all the other devices, while cryoablation led to a reduced rate compared with bipolar radio frequency and microwave.Conclusions Bipolar radio frequency and microwave ablative devices are more effective than thermal balloon and free fluid ablation in the treatment of heavy menstrual bleeding with second generation endometrial ablation devices.

AB - Objective To determine the relative effectiveness of second generation ablation techniques in the treatment of heavy menstrual bleeding.Design Network meta-analysis on the primary outcome measures of amenorrhoea, heavy bleeding, and patients' dissatisfaction with treatment.Data sources Nineteen randomised controlled trials (involving 3287 women) were identified through electronic searches of the Cochrane Library, Medline, Embase and PsycINFO databases from inception to April 2011. The reference lists of known relevant articles were searched for further articles. Two reviewers independently selected articles without language restrictions.Eligibility criteria for selecting studies Randomised controlled trials involving second generation endometrial destruction techniques for women with heavy menstrual bleeding unresponsive to medical treatment.Results Of the three most commonly used techniques, network meta-analysis showed that bipolar radiofrequency and microwave ablation resulted in higher rates of amenorrhoea than thermal balloon ablation at around 12 months (odds ratio 2.51, 95% confidence interval 1.53 to 4.12, P<0.001; and 1.66, 1.01 to 2.71, P=0.05, respectively), but there was no evidence of a convincing difference between the three techniques in the number of women dissatisfied with treatment or still experiencing heavy bleeding. Compared with bipolar radio frequency and microwave devices, an increased number of women still experienced heavy bleeding after free fluid ablation (2.19, 1.07 to 4.50, P=0.03; and 2.91, 1.23 to 6.88, P=0.02, respectively). Compared with radio frequency ablation, free fluid ablation was associated with reduced rates of amenorrhoea (0.36, 0.19 to 0.67, P=0.004) and increased rates of dissatisfaction (4.79, 1.07 to 21.5, P=0.04). Of the less commonly used devices, endometrial laser intrauterine thermotherapy was associated with increased rates of amenorrhoea compared with all the other devices, while cryoablation led to a reduced rate compared with bipolar radio frequency and microwave.Conclusions Bipolar radio frequency and microwave ablative devices are more effective than thermal balloon and free fluid ablation in the treatment of heavy menstrual bleeding with second generation endometrial ablation devices.

U2 - 10.1136/bmj.e2564

DO - 10.1136/bmj.e2564

M3 - Article

VL - 344

JO - BMJ

JF - BMJ

SN - 0959-8146

M1 - e2564

ER -