Self-Other Relations in Social Development and Autism

Multiple Roles for Mirror Neurons and Other Brain Bases

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

84 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Mirror neuron system dysfunction may underlie a self-other matching impairment, which has previously been suggested to account for autism. Embodied Cognition Theory, which proposes that action provides a foundation for cognition has tent further credence to these ideas. The hypotheses of a self-other matching deficit and impaired mirror neuron function in autism have now been well supported by studies employing a range of methodologies. However, underlying mechanisms require further exploration to explain how mirror neurons may be involved in attentional and mentalizing processes. Impairments in self-other matching and mirror neuron function are not necessarily inextricably linked and it seems possible that different sub-populations of mirror neurons, located in several regions, contribute differentially to social cognitive functions. It is hypothesized that mirror neuron coding for action-direction may be required for developing attentional sensitivity to self-directed actions, and consequently for person-oriented, stimulus-driven attention. Mirror neuron networks may vary for different types of social learning such as "automatic" imitation and imitation learning. Imitation learning may be more reliant on self-other comparison processes (based on mirror neurons) that identify differences as well as similarities between actions. Differential connectivity with the amygdala-orbitofrontal system may also be important. This could have implications for developing "theory of mind," with intentional self-other comparison being relevant to meta-representational abilities, and "automatic" imitation being more relevant to empathy. While it seems clear that autism is associated with impaired development of embodied aspects of cognition, the ways that mirror neurons contribute to these brain-behavior links are likely to be complex.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)73-90
Number of pages17
JournalAutism Research
Volume1
Issue number2
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Apr 2008

Keywords

  • autism
  • autistic disorder
  • Asperger's syndrome
  • imitation
  • gaze
  • attention
  • motor control
  • perception
  • action
  • mirror neurons
  • fMRI
  • parietal cortex
  • Broca's area
  • pSTS
  • 'theory of mind' (TOM)
  • temporo-parietal junction
  • event-related FMRI
  • spectrum disorders
  • Asperger-Syndrome
  • joint attention
  • biological motion
  • young-children
  • white-matter
  • functional-organization
  • neural representation

Cite this

@article{d5bf92b3e39241a29226321c2d2162b2,
title = "Self-Other Relations in Social Development and Autism: Multiple Roles for Mirror Neurons and Other Brain Bases",
abstract = "Mirror neuron system dysfunction may underlie a self-other matching impairment, which has previously been suggested to account for autism. Embodied Cognition Theory, which proposes that action provides a foundation for cognition has tent further credence to these ideas. The hypotheses of a self-other matching deficit and impaired mirror neuron function in autism have now been well supported by studies employing a range of methodologies. However, underlying mechanisms require further exploration to explain how mirror neurons may be involved in attentional and mentalizing processes. Impairments in self-other matching and mirror neuron function are not necessarily inextricably linked and it seems possible that different sub-populations of mirror neurons, located in several regions, contribute differentially to social cognitive functions. It is hypothesized that mirror neuron coding for action-direction may be required for developing attentional sensitivity to self-directed actions, and consequently for person-oriented, stimulus-driven attention. Mirror neuron networks may vary for different types of social learning such as {"}automatic{"} imitation and imitation learning. Imitation learning may be more reliant on self-other comparison processes (based on mirror neurons) that identify differences as well as similarities between actions. Differential connectivity with the amygdala-orbitofrontal system may also be important. This could have implications for developing {"}theory of mind,{"} with intentional self-other comparison being relevant to meta-representational abilities, and {"}automatic{"} imitation being more relevant to empathy. While it seems clear that autism is associated with impaired development of embodied aspects of cognition, the ways that mirror neurons contribute to these brain-behavior links are likely to be complex.",
keywords = "autism, autistic disorder, Asperger's syndrome, imitation, gaze, attention, motor control, perception, action, mirror neurons, fMRI, parietal cortex, Broca's area, pSTS, 'theory of mind' (TOM), temporo-parietal junction, event-related FMRI, spectrum disorders, Asperger-Syndrome, joint attention, biological motion, young-children, white-matter, functional-organization, neural representation",
author = "Williams, {Justin Hereward Gwilym}",
year = "2008",
month = "4",
doi = "10.1002/aur.15",
language = "English",
volume = "1",
pages = "73--90",
journal = "Autism Research",
issn = "1939-3792",
publisher = "John Wiley and Sons Inc.",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Self-Other Relations in Social Development and Autism

T2 - Multiple Roles for Mirror Neurons and Other Brain Bases

AU - Williams, Justin Hereward Gwilym

PY - 2008/4

Y1 - 2008/4

N2 - Mirror neuron system dysfunction may underlie a self-other matching impairment, which has previously been suggested to account for autism. Embodied Cognition Theory, which proposes that action provides a foundation for cognition has tent further credence to these ideas. The hypotheses of a self-other matching deficit and impaired mirror neuron function in autism have now been well supported by studies employing a range of methodologies. However, underlying mechanisms require further exploration to explain how mirror neurons may be involved in attentional and mentalizing processes. Impairments in self-other matching and mirror neuron function are not necessarily inextricably linked and it seems possible that different sub-populations of mirror neurons, located in several regions, contribute differentially to social cognitive functions. It is hypothesized that mirror neuron coding for action-direction may be required for developing attentional sensitivity to self-directed actions, and consequently for person-oriented, stimulus-driven attention. Mirror neuron networks may vary for different types of social learning such as "automatic" imitation and imitation learning. Imitation learning may be more reliant on self-other comparison processes (based on mirror neurons) that identify differences as well as similarities between actions. Differential connectivity with the amygdala-orbitofrontal system may also be important. This could have implications for developing "theory of mind," with intentional self-other comparison being relevant to meta-representational abilities, and "automatic" imitation being more relevant to empathy. While it seems clear that autism is associated with impaired development of embodied aspects of cognition, the ways that mirror neurons contribute to these brain-behavior links are likely to be complex.

AB - Mirror neuron system dysfunction may underlie a self-other matching impairment, which has previously been suggested to account for autism. Embodied Cognition Theory, which proposes that action provides a foundation for cognition has tent further credence to these ideas. The hypotheses of a self-other matching deficit and impaired mirror neuron function in autism have now been well supported by studies employing a range of methodologies. However, underlying mechanisms require further exploration to explain how mirror neurons may be involved in attentional and mentalizing processes. Impairments in self-other matching and mirror neuron function are not necessarily inextricably linked and it seems possible that different sub-populations of mirror neurons, located in several regions, contribute differentially to social cognitive functions. It is hypothesized that mirror neuron coding for action-direction may be required for developing attentional sensitivity to self-directed actions, and consequently for person-oriented, stimulus-driven attention. Mirror neuron networks may vary for different types of social learning such as "automatic" imitation and imitation learning. Imitation learning may be more reliant on self-other comparison processes (based on mirror neurons) that identify differences as well as similarities between actions. Differential connectivity with the amygdala-orbitofrontal system may also be important. This could have implications for developing "theory of mind," with intentional self-other comparison being relevant to meta-representational abilities, and "automatic" imitation being more relevant to empathy. While it seems clear that autism is associated with impaired development of embodied aspects of cognition, the ways that mirror neurons contribute to these brain-behavior links are likely to be complex.

KW - autism

KW - autistic disorder

KW - Asperger's syndrome

KW - imitation

KW - gaze

KW - attention

KW - motor control

KW - perception

KW - action

KW - mirror neurons

KW - fMRI

KW - parietal cortex

KW - Broca's area

KW - pSTS

KW - 'theory of mind' (TOM)

KW - temporo-parietal junction

KW - event-related FMRI

KW - spectrum disorders

KW - Asperger-Syndrome

KW - joint attention

KW - biological motion

KW - young-children

KW - white-matter

KW - functional-organization

KW - neural representation

U2 - 10.1002/aur.15

DO - 10.1002/aur.15

M3 - Article

VL - 1

SP - 73

EP - 90

JO - Autism Research

JF - Autism Research

SN - 1939-3792

IS - 2

ER -