Services just for men?

Insights from a national study of the well men services pilots

Flora C G Douglas, Joe Greener, Edwin Van Teijlingen, Anne Ludbrook

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

7 Citations (Scopus)
4 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Background

Men continue to have a lower life expectancy in most countries compared to women. Explanations of this gendered health inequality tend to focus on male risk taking, unhealthy lifestyle choices and resistance to seeking help from health services. In the period 2005–2008 the Scottish Government funded a nationwide community health promotion programme aimed at improving men’s health, called Well Men Service Pilots (henceforth WMS).

Method

This paper explores WMS programme users’ perspectives and experiences of health help-seeking against theories of hegemonic masculinity as explanatory frameworks for men’s behaviour around health and illness, and their views on a male-specific focus of the programme. It is based on a secondary analysis of 43 semi-structured interviews with men who engaged with this programme.

Results

We challenge the commonly held notion of men as being disinterested in their health, and point to their heterogeneity in relation to their views about health and notions of health seeking. Moreover, men in our study were largely ambivalent about the need for gender specific services, despite their positive reactions to the programme in general.

Conclusions

Our findings question the utility of some theories of masculinity that posit somewhat simplistic explanations for men’s reluctance to seek help from formal healthcare services. They also suggest that providing male-specific health services may not significantly address men’s supposed reluctance to seek help from formal health services. Essentially, age seemed to be more important than gender. All encompassing health programmes are likely to fail to meet their health improvement objectives if they attempt to engage with men on the simple basis that they are male.
Original languageEnglish
Article number425
Number of pages10
JournalBMC Public Health
Volume13
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 May 2013

Fingerprint

Health
Health Services
Masculinity
Men's Health
Pilots
Risk-Taking
Life Expectancy
Health Promotion
Life Style
Economics
Interviews
Delivery of Health Care

Keywords

  • men’s health
  • health-seeking behaviour
  • health promotion
  • prevention
  • primary care
  • qualitative interviews

Cite this

Services just for men? Insights from a national study of the well men services pilots. / Douglas, Flora C G; Greener, Joe; Van Teijlingen, Edwin ; Ludbrook, Anne.

In: BMC Public Health, Vol. 13, 425, 01.05.2013.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Douglas, Flora C G ; Greener, Joe ; Van Teijlingen, Edwin ; Ludbrook, Anne. / Services just for men? Insights from a national study of the well men services pilots. In: BMC Public Health. 2013 ; Vol. 13.
@article{9e0acc0df2d14e73b3ff180324d99a43,
title = "Services just for men?: Insights from a national study of the well men services pilots",
abstract = "BackgroundMen continue to have a lower life expectancy in most countries compared to women. Explanations of this gendered health inequality tend to focus on male risk taking, unhealthy lifestyle choices and resistance to seeking help from health services. In the period 2005–2008 the Scottish Government funded a nationwide community health promotion programme aimed at improving men’s health, called Well Men Service Pilots (henceforth WMS). MethodThis paper explores WMS programme users’ perspectives and experiences of health help-seeking against theories of hegemonic masculinity as explanatory frameworks for men’s behaviour around health and illness, and their views on a male-specific focus of the programme. It is based on a secondary analysis of 43 semi-structured interviews with men who engaged with this programme. ResultsWe challenge the commonly held notion of men as being disinterested in their health, and point to their heterogeneity in relation to their views about health and notions of health seeking. Moreover, men in our study were largely ambivalent about the need for gender specific services, despite their positive reactions to the programme in general. ConclusionsOur findings question the utility of some theories of masculinity that posit somewhat simplistic explanations for men’s reluctance to seek help from formal healthcare services. They also suggest that providing male-specific health services may not significantly address men’s supposed reluctance to seek help from formal health services. Essentially, age seemed to be more important than gender. All encompassing health programmes are likely to fail to meet their health improvement objectives if they attempt to engage with men on the simple basis that they are male.",
keywords = "men’s health, health-seeking behaviour, health promotion, prevention, primary care , qualitative interviews",
author = "Douglas, {Flora C G} and Joe Greener and {Van Teijlingen}, Edwin and Anne Ludbrook",
year = "2013",
month = "5",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1186/1471-2458-13-425",
language = "English",
volume = "13",
journal = "BMC Public Health",
issn = "1471-2458",
publisher = "BioMed Central",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Services just for men?

T2 - Insights from a national study of the well men services pilots

AU - Douglas, Flora C G

AU - Greener, Joe

AU - Van Teijlingen, Edwin

AU - Ludbrook, Anne

PY - 2013/5/1

Y1 - 2013/5/1

N2 - BackgroundMen continue to have a lower life expectancy in most countries compared to women. Explanations of this gendered health inequality tend to focus on male risk taking, unhealthy lifestyle choices and resistance to seeking help from health services. In the period 2005–2008 the Scottish Government funded a nationwide community health promotion programme aimed at improving men’s health, called Well Men Service Pilots (henceforth WMS). MethodThis paper explores WMS programme users’ perspectives and experiences of health help-seeking against theories of hegemonic masculinity as explanatory frameworks for men’s behaviour around health and illness, and their views on a male-specific focus of the programme. It is based on a secondary analysis of 43 semi-structured interviews with men who engaged with this programme. ResultsWe challenge the commonly held notion of men as being disinterested in their health, and point to their heterogeneity in relation to their views about health and notions of health seeking. Moreover, men in our study were largely ambivalent about the need for gender specific services, despite their positive reactions to the programme in general. ConclusionsOur findings question the utility of some theories of masculinity that posit somewhat simplistic explanations for men’s reluctance to seek help from formal healthcare services. They also suggest that providing male-specific health services may not significantly address men’s supposed reluctance to seek help from formal health services. Essentially, age seemed to be more important than gender. All encompassing health programmes are likely to fail to meet their health improvement objectives if they attempt to engage with men on the simple basis that they are male.

AB - BackgroundMen continue to have a lower life expectancy in most countries compared to women. Explanations of this gendered health inequality tend to focus on male risk taking, unhealthy lifestyle choices and resistance to seeking help from health services. In the period 2005–2008 the Scottish Government funded a nationwide community health promotion programme aimed at improving men’s health, called Well Men Service Pilots (henceforth WMS). MethodThis paper explores WMS programme users’ perspectives and experiences of health help-seeking against theories of hegemonic masculinity as explanatory frameworks for men’s behaviour around health and illness, and their views on a male-specific focus of the programme. It is based on a secondary analysis of 43 semi-structured interviews with men who engaged with this programme. ResultsWe challenge the commonly held notion of men as being disinterested in their health, and point to their heterogeneity in relation to their views about health and notions of health seeking. Moreover, men in our study were largely ambivalent about the need for gender specific services, despite their positive reactions to the programme in general. ConclusionsOur findings question the utility of some theories of masculinity that posit somewhat simplistic explanations for men’s reluctance to seek help from formal healthcare services. They also suggest that providing male-specific health services may not significantly address men’s supposed reluctance to seek help from formal health services. Essentially, age seemed to be more important than gender. All encompassing health programmes are likely to fail to meet their health improvement objectives if they attempt to engage with men on the simple basis that they are male.

KW - men’s health

KW - health-seeking behaviour

KW - health promotion

KW - prevention

KW - primary care

KW - qualitative interviews

U2 - 10.1186/1471-2458-13-425

DO - 10.1186/1471-2458-13-425

M3 - Article

VL - 13

JO - BMC Public Health

JF - BMC Public Health

SN - 1471-2458

M1 - 425

ER -