Shifting environmental perspectives in agriculture: repeated Q analysis and the stability of preference structures

Ben Davies, Ian Hodge

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    26 Citations (Scopus)

    Abstract

    A critical issue in behavioural environmental studies is the evolution of attitudes over time. This analysis reports a unique longitudinal study of individual farmers’ perspectives using Q methodology, with a group of UK farmers’ opinions assessed in both 2001 and 2008. Three main outcomes are evident. Firstly, the set of farmers’ perspectives identified in 2001 appears to be still adequate to summarise the range of views present in 2008; thus substantially newsets of concerns do not appear to be forming over this period. Secondly, the proportions of farmers aligning themselves with particular perspectives appear to have shifted, indicating some clear reorientations of attitudes. Thirdly, these shifts indicate a small number of specific directions of change, oriented towards more productivist positions and away from more environmental interests. In summary, the key dimensions of agri-environmental concern amongst farmers overall do not appear to be significantly changing over this period, but the proportions of farmers that are sensitive to particular concerns do appear to have undergone some change. Given the unusual methodology, sample size and recruitment methods used these resultsmost certainly cannot be translated into population-wide effects, but they do provide a valuable opportunity for consideration of pathways of change.
    Original languageEnglish
    Pages (from-to)51-57
    Number of pages7
    JournalEcological Economics
    Volume83
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - Nov 2012

    Fingerprint

    agriculture
    methodology
    analysis
    Preference structure
    Farmers
    Agriculture
    opinion
    environmental study
    effect
    method
    Proportion

    Keywords

    • farmers
    • environmental attitudes
    • agriculture
    • temporal change
    • Q methodology
    • UK

    Cite this

    Shifting environmental perspectives in agriculture : repeated Q analysis and the stability of preference structures. / Davies, Ben; Hodge, Ian.

    In: Ecological Economics, Vol. 83, 11.2012, p. 51-57.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    @article{096affd0478945bea1adc2ed6d3a14a6,
    title = "Shifting environmental perspectives in agriculture: repeated Q analysis and the stability of preference structures",
    abstract = "A critical issue in behavioural environmental studies is the evolution of attitudes over time. This analysis reports a unique longitudinal study of individual farmers’ perspectives using Q methodology, with a group of UK farmers’ opinions assessed in both 2001 and 2008. Three main outcomes are evident. Firstly, the set of farmers’ perspectives identified in 2001 appears to be still adequate to summarise the range of views present in 2008; thus substantially newsets of concerns do not appear to be forming over this period. Secondly, the proportions of farmers aligning themselves with particular perspectives appear to have shifted, indicating some clear reorientations of attitudes. Thirdly, these shifts indicate a small number of specific directions of change, oriented towards more productivist positions and away from more environmental interests. In summary, the key dimensions of agri-environmental concern amongst farmers overall do not appear to be significantly changing over this period, but the proportions of farmers that are sensitive to particular concerns do appear to have undergone some change. Given the unusual methodology, sample size and recruitment methods used these resultsmost certainly cannot be translated into population-wide effects, but they do provide a valuable opportunity for consideration of pathways of change.",
    keywords = "farmers, environmental attitudes, agriculture, temporal change, Q methodology, UK",
    author = "Ben Davies and Ian Hodge",
    year = "2012",
    month = "11",
    doi = "10.1016/j.ecolecon.2012.08.013",
    language = "English",
    volume = "83",
    pages = "51--57",
    journal = "Ecological Economics",
    issn = "0921-8009",
    publisher = "ELSEVIER SCIENCE BV",

    }

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Shifting environmental perspectives in agriculture

    T2 - repeated Q analysis and the stability of preference structures

    AU - Davies, Ben

    AU - Hodge, Ian

    PY - 2012/11

    Y1 - 2012/11

    N2 - A critical issue in behavioural environmental studies is the evolution of attitudes over time. This analysis reports a unique longitudinal study of individual farmers’ perspectives using Q methodology, with a group of UK farmers’ opinions assessed in both 2001 and 2008. Three main outcomes are evident. Firstly, the set of farmers’ perspectives identified in 2001 appears to be still adequate to summarise the range of views present in 2008; thus substantially newsets of concerns do not appear to be forming over this period. Secondly, the proportions of farmers aligning themselves with particular perspectives appear to have shifted, indicating some clear reorientations of attitudes. Thirdly, these shifts indicate a small number of specific directions of change, oriented towards more productivist positions and away from more environmental interests. In summary, the key dimensions of agri-environmental concern amongst farmers overall do not appear to be significantly changing over this period, but the proportions of farmers that are sensitive to particular concerns do appear to have undergone some change. Given the unusual methodology, sample size and recruitment methods used these resultsmost certainly cannot be translated into population-wide effects, but they do provide a valuable opportunity for consideration of pathways of change.

    AB - A critical issue in behavioural environmental studies is the evolution of attitudes over time. This analysis reports a unique longitudinal study of individual farmers’ perspectives using Q methodology, with a group of UK farmers’ opinions assessed in both 2001 and 2008. Three main outcomes are evident. Firstly, the set of farmers’ perspectives identified in 2001 appears to be still adequate to summarise the range of views present in 2008; thus substantially newsets of concerns do not appear to be forming over this period. Secondly, the proportions of farmers aligning themselves with particular perspectives appear to have shifted, indicating some clear reorientations of attitudes. Thirdly, these shifts indicate a small number of specific directions of change, oriented towards more productivist positions and away from more environmental interests. In summary, the key dimensions of agri-environmental concern amongst farmers overall do not appear to be significantly changing over this period, but the proportions of farmers that are sensitive to particular concerns do appear to have undergone some change. Given the unusual methodology, sample size and recruitment methods used these resultsmost certainly cannot be translated into population-wide effects, but they do provide a valuable opportunity for consideration of pathways of change.

    KW - farmers

    KW - environmental attitudes

    KW - agriculture

    KW - temporal change

    KW - Q methodology

    KW - UK

    U2 - 10.1016/j.ecolecon.2012.08.013

    DO - 10.1016/j.ecolecon.2012.08.013

    M3 - Article

    VL - 83

    SP - 51

    EP - 57

    JO - Ecological Economics

    JF - Ecological Economics

    SN - 0921-8009

    ER -