Simulation of soil organic carbon response at forest cultivation sequences using C-13 measurements

Pia Gottschalk, Jessica Bellarby, Claire Chenu, Bente Foereid, Pete Smith, Martin Wattenbach, Shamie Zingore, Jo Smith

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

15 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

When deforestation is followed by continuous arable cropping, a permanent decline of between 22% and 42% in the soil organic carbon (SOC) has been reported. This systematic loss of soil carbon (C) is mainly attributed to the loss of physically protected SOC. The Rothamsted Carbon model (RothC) does not include a description of the processes of physical protection of SOC and so losses of C during continuous cultivation of previously uncultivated land are not likely to be accurately simulated. Our results show that in the first years following deforestation, RothC does not capture the fast drop in forest derived soil C. However, the model does satisfactorily simulate the changes in SOC derived from the following crops. Uncertainty in input data and accounting for erosion, does not explain the underestimation of decomposition after deforestation by RothC. A simple approach to increase decomposition by multiplying rate constants is evaluated. This approach needs high multiplication rates and leads to an overestimation of plant input values to sustain SOC equilibrium levels. However, the ability of RothC to simulate changes in the forest derived SOC can be greatly improved with an implementation of a simple approach to account for SOC dynamics due to the loss of physically protected C. This approach implements a new soil carbon pool into RothC which represents the labile but protected carbon fraction which builds up under minimally disturbed land uses, and which loses its protection once the soil is disturbed. The new pool is calibrated using C-13 natural abundance analysis in conjunction with soil fractionation. (C) 2009 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)41-54
Number of pages14
JournalOrganic Geochemistry
Volume41
Issue number1
Early online date6 May 2009
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Jan 2010

Keywords

  • long-term experiments
  • NET primary production
  • land-use change
  • natural-abundance
  • matter dynamics
  • computer-simulation
  • physical protection
  • size-fractions
  • model
  • turnover

Cite this

Simulation of soil organic carbon response at forest cultivation sequences using C-13 measurements. / Gottschalk, Pia; Bellarby, Jessica; Chenu, Claire; Foereid, Bente; Smith, Pete; Wattenbach, Martin; Zingore, Shamie; Smith, Jo.

In: Organic Geochemistry, Vol. 41, No. 1, 01.2010, p. 41-54.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Gottschalk, Pia ; Bellarby, Jessica ; Chenu, Claire ; Foereid, Bente ; Smith, Pete ; Wattenbach, Martin ; Zingore, Shamie ; Smith, Jo. / Simulation of soil organic carbon response at forest cultivation sequences using C-13 measurements. In: Organic Geochemistry. 2010 ; Vol. 41, No. 1. pp. 41-54.
@article{0f4bef7805bf4888b2741e20f7c7f3b3,
title = "Simulation of soil organic carbon response at forest cultivation sequences using C-13 measurements",
abstract = "When deforestation is followed by continuous arable cropping, a permanent decline of between 22{\%} and 42{\%} in the soil organic carbon (SOC) has been reported. This systematic loss of soil carbon (C) is mainly attributed to the loss of physically protected SOC. The Rothamsted Carbon model (RothC) does not include a description of the processes of physical protection of SOC and so losses of C during continuous cultivation of previously uncultivated land are not likely to be accurately simulated. Our results show that in the first years following deforestation, RothC does not capture the fast drop in forest derived soil C. However, the model does satisfactorily simulate the changes in SOC derived from the following crops. Uncertainty in input data and accounting for erosion, does not explain the underestimation of decomposition after deforestation by RothC. A simple approach to increase decomposition by multiplying rate constants is evaluated. This approach needs high multiplication rates and leads to an overestimation of plant input values to sustain SOC equilibrium levels. However, the ability of RothC to simulate changes in the forest derived SOC can be greatly improved with an implementation of a simple approach to account for SOC dynamics due to the loss of physically protected C. This approach implements a new soil carbon pool into RothC which represents the labile but protected carbon fraction which builds up under minimally disturbed land uses, and which loses its protection once the soil is disturbed. The new pool is calibrated using C-13 natural abundance analysis in conjunction with soil fractionation. (C) 2009 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.",
keywords = "long-term experiments, NET primary production, land-use change, natural-abundance, matter dynamics, computer-simulation, physical protection, size-fractions, model, turnover",
author = "Pia Gottschalk and Jessica Bellarby and Claire Chenu and Bente Foereid and Pete Smith and Martin Wattenbach and Shamie Zingore and Jo Smith",
year = "2010",
month = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.orggeochem.2009.04.017",
language = "English",
volume = "41",
pages = "41--54",
journal = "Organic Geochemistry",
issn = "0146-6380",
publisher = "Elsevier Limited",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Simulation of soil organic carbon response at forest cultivation sequences using C-13 measurements

AU - Gottschalk, Pia

AU - Bellarby, Jessica

AU - Chenu, Claire

AU - Foereid, Bente

AU - Smith, Pete

AU - Wattenbach, Martin

AU - Zingore, Shamie

AU - Smith, Jo

PY - 2010/1

Y1 - 2010/1

N2 - When deforestation is followed by continuous arable cropping, a permanent decline of between 22% and 42% in the soil organic carbon (SOC) has been reported. This systematic loss of soil carbon (C) is mainly attributed to the loss of physically protected SOC. The Rothamsted Carbon model (RothC) does not include a description of the processes of physical protection of SOC and so losses of C during continuous cultivation of previously uncultivated land are not likely to be accurately simulated. Our results show that in the first years following deforestation, RothC does not capture the fast drop in forest derived soil C. However, the model does satisfactorily simulate the changes in SOC derived from the following crops. Uncertainty in input data and accounting for erosion, does not explain the underestimation of decomposition after deforestation by RothC. A simple approach to increase decomposition by multiplying rate constants is evaluated. This approach needs high multiplication rates and leads to an overestimation of plant input values to sustain SOC equilibrium levels. However, the ability of RothC to simulate changes in the forest derived SOC can be greatly improved with an implementation of a simple approach to account for SOC dynamics due to the loss of physically protected C. This approach implements a new soil carbon pool into RothC which represents the labile but protected carbon fraction which builds up under minimally disturbed land uses, and which loses its protection once the soil is disturbed. The new pool is calibrated using C-13 natural abundance analysis in conjunction with soil fractionation. (C) 2009 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

AB - When deforestation is followed by continuous arable cropping, a permanent decline of between 22% and 42% in the soil organic carbon (SOC) has been reported. This systematic loss of soil carbon (C) is mainly attributed to the loss of physically protected SOC. The Rothamsted Carbon model (RothC) does not include a description of the processes of physical protection of SOC and so losses of C during continuous cultivation of previously uncultivated land are not likely to be accurately simulated. Our results show that in the first years following deforestation, RothC does not capture the fast drop in forest derived soil C. However, the model does satisfactorily simulate the changes in SOC derived from the following crops. Uncertainty in input data and accounting for erosion, does not explain the underestimation of decomposition after deforestation by RothC. A simple approach to increase decomposition by multiplying rate constants is evaluated. This approach needs high multiplication rates and leads to an overestimation of plant input values to sustain SOC equilibrium levels. However, the ability of RothC to simulate changes in the forest derived SOC can be greatly improved with an implementation of a simple approach to account for SOC dynamics due to the loss of physically protected C. This approach implements a new soil carbon pool into RothC which represents the labile but protected carbon fraction which builds up under minimally disturbed land uses, and which loses its protection once the soil is disturbed. The new pool is calibrated using C-13 natural abundance analysis in conjunction with soil fractionation. (C) 2009 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

KW - long-term experiments

KW - NET primary production

KW - land-use change

KW - natural-abundance

KW - matter dynamics

KW - computer-simulation

KW - physical protection

KW - size-fractions

KW - model

KW - turnover

U2 - 10.1016/j.orggeochem.2009.04.017

DO - 10.1016/j.orggeochem.2009.04.017

M3 - Article

VL - 41

SP - 41

EP - 54

JO - Organic Geochemistry

JF - Organic Geochemistry

SN - 0146-6380

IS - 1

ER -