Status, taste and distinction in consumer culture

acknowledging the symbolic dimensions of inequality

Sandra Carlisle, Phil Hanlon, Margaret Hannah

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    13 Citations (Scopus)

    Abstract

    The relationship between social position and health has been the focus of extensive public health debate. In the UK and elsewhere, most researchers have focused on physical aspects of health, using indicators such as mortality and morbidity to draw a picture of profound and widening social inequalities. This paper draws attention to the (neglected) influence of contemporary culture on wellbeing, arguing that the social meanings created within consumer culture possess symbolic force that can add to wider inequalities. The possession of greater material and cultural resources by people of higher social status enables them to label their preferred forms of consumption and lifestyle as desirable and legitimate, thus conveying messages about superior taste and social distinction. Symbolic rather than material forms of inequality are implicated here, with consequences for the psychological wellbeing of disadvantaged people. This paper argues that analyses of inequality need broadening to include such considerations. However, there are implications for efforts to address health inequalities because this analysis suggests that if some forms of social inequality are removed, elements within society would be motivated to invent new forms to replace them. Therefore, this article suggests processes whereby people can develop the self-awareness needed to resist the glossy illusions of the good life represented by modern consumer capitalism.
    Original languageEnglish
    Pages (from-to)631-637
    Number of pages7
    JournalPublic Health
    Volume122
    Issue number6
    Early online date29 Jan 2008
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - Jun 2008

    Fingerprint

    Health
    Capitalism
    Vulnerable Populations
    Life Style
    Public Health
    Research Personnel
    Psychology
    Morbidity
    Mortality

    Keywords

    • symbolic dimensions of inequality
    • consumer culture
    • consumption and identity
    • lifestyle and social distinction
    • taste

    Cite this

    Status, taste and distinction in consumer culture : acknowledging the symbolic dimensions of inequality. / Carlisle, Sandra; Hanlon, Phil; Hannah, Margaret.

    In: Public Health, Vol. 122, No. 6, 06.2008, p. 631-637.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    Carlisle, Sandra ; Hanlon, Phil ; Hannah, Margaret. / Status, taste and distinction in consumer culture : acknowledging the symbolic dimensions of inequality. In: Public Health. 2008 ; Vol. 122, No. 6. pp. 631-637.
    @article{d4ecd35b7bae4c55a58d031071b4deb3,
    title = "Status, taste and distinction in consumer culture: acknowledging the symbolic dimensions of inequality",
    abstract = "The relationship between social position and health has been the focus of extensive public health debate. In the UK and elsewhere, most researchers have focused on physical aspects of health, using indicators such as mortality and morbidity to draw a picture of profound and widening social inequalities. This paper draws attention to the (neglected) influence of contemporary culture on wellbeing, arguing that the social meanings created within consumer culture possess symbolic force that can add to wider inequalities. The possession of greater material and cultural resources by people of higher social status enables them to label their preferred forms of consumption and lifestyle as desirable and legitimate, thus conveying messages about superior taste and social distinction. Symbolic rather than material forms of inequality are implicated here, with consequences for the psychological wellbeing of disadvantaged people. This paper argues that analyses of inequality need broadening to include such considerations. However, there are implications for efforts to address health inequalities because this analysis suggests that if some forms of social inequality are removed, elements within society would be motivated to invent new forms to replace them. Therefore, this article suggests processes whereby people can develop the self-awareness needed to resist the glossy illusions of the good life represented by modern consumer capitalism.",
    keywords = "symbolic dimensions of inequality, consumer culture, consumption and identity, lifestyle and social distinction, taste",
    author = "Sandra Carlisle and Phil Hanlon and Margaret Hannah",
    year = "2008",
    month = "6",
    doi = "10.1016/j.puhe.2007.09.011",
    language = "English",
    volume = "122",
    pages = "631--637",
    journal = "Public Health",
    issn = "0033-3506",
    publisher = "Elsevier",
    number = "6",

    }

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Status, taste and distinction in consumer culture

    T2 - acknowledging the symbolic dimensions of inequality

    AU - Carlisle, Sandra

    AU - Hanlon, Phil

    AU - Hannah, Margaret

    PY - 2008/6

    Y1 - 2008/6

    N2 - The relationship between social position and health has been the focus of extensive public health debate. In the UK and elsewhere, most researchers have focused on physical aspects of health, using indicators such as mortality and morbidity to draw a picture of profound and widening social inequalities. This paper draws attention to the (neglected) influence of contemporary culture on wellbeing, arguing that the social meanings created within consumer culture possess symbolic force that can add to wider inequalities. The possession of greater material and cultural resources by people of higher social status enables them to label their preferred forms of consumption and lifestyle as desirable and legitimate, thus conveying messages about superior taste and social distinction. Symbolic rather than material forms of inequality are implicated here, with consequences for the psychological wellbeing of disadvantaged people. This paper argues that analyses of inequality need broadening to include such considerations. However, there are implications for efforts to address health inequalities because this analysis suggests that if some forms of social inequality are removed, elements within society would be motivated to invent new forms to replace them. Therefore, this article suggests processes whereby people can develop the self-awareness needed to resist the glossy illusions of the good life represented by modern consumer capitalism.

    AB - The relationship between social position and health has been the focus of extensive public health debate. In the UK and elsewhere, most researchers have focused on physical aspects of health, using indicators such as mortality and morbidity to draw a picture of profound and widening social inequalities. This paper draws attention to the (neglected) influence of contemporary culture on wellbeing, arguing that the social meanings created within consumer culture possess symbolic force that can add to wider inequalities. The possession of greater material and cultural resources by people of higher social status enables them to label their preferred forms of consumption and lifestyle as desirable and legitimate, thus conveying messages about superior taste and social distinction. Symbolic rather than material forms of inequality are implicated here, with consequences for the psychological wellbeing of disadvantaged people. This paper argues that analyses of inequality need broadening to include such considerations. However, there are implications for efforts to address health inequalities because this analysis suggests that if some forms of social inequality are removed, elements within society would be motivated to invent new forms to replace them. Therefore, this article suggests processes whereby people can develop the self-awareness needed to resist the glossy illusions of the good life represented by modern consumer capitalism.

    KW - symbolic dimensions of inequality

    KW - consumer culture

    KW - consumption and identity

    KW - lifestyle and social distinction

    KW - taste

    U2 - 10.1016/j.puhe.2007.09.011

    DO - 10.1016/j.puhe.2007.09.011

    M3 - Article

    VL - 122

    SP - 631

    EP - 637

    JO - Public Health

    JF - Public Health

    SN - 0033-3506

    IS - 6

    ER -