Tackling wicked environmental problems: The discourse and its influence on praxis in Scotland

D. Duckett (Corresponding Author), D. Feliciano, J. Martin-Ortega, J. Munoz-Rojas

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

22 Citations (Scopus)
9 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Complex, social-environmental issues can be classified as ‘wicked problems’ because they are incorrigible and hugely challenging for policy makers. Here we re-evaluate what makes problems wicked and assess various theoretical and pragmatic approaches that have been advanced to tackle them. We do so with the aim of contributing new insights to theory through answering the following research questions: What strategies to tackle wicked environmental problems are prominent in the literature?; To what extent do they provide pathways for tackling the defining characteristics of wicked environmental problems?; and, How are these strategies reflected in examples of practice? Our examples look at how emergent strategies have percolated, explicitly or implicitly, in the management of four problems in Scotland: (1) Securing sustainability and resilience of landscape and land-use systems through spatial planning; (2) Addressing population health through livestock disease control; (3) Mitigating climate change through woodland planting; and, (4) Mitigating rural diffuse pollution in freshwater systems. We present a consolidated set of characteristics of wicked problems against which we map strategies to tackle wicked problems proposed by a body of literature identified through a literature review and analysed using a thematic, qualitative approach. We identify fifteen strategies and show that most of these are, within the Scottish context, evident in practice. The extent to which the actual discourse has influenced praxis and how effective it has been is more difficult to determine but we conclude that, within a context of ‘incorrigible’ problems, small steps have been made towards taming an untameable beast.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)44-56
Number of pages13
JournalLandscape and Urban Planning
Volume154
Early online date12 May 2016
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Oct 2016

Fingerprint

disease control
spatial planning
literature review
environmental issue
livestock
woodland
sustainability
land use
climate change
policy
diffuse pollution
planting
health

Keywords

  • planning
  • land use
  • climate change
  • diffuse pollution
  • livestock disease
  • woodland planting

Cite this

Tackling wicked environmental problems : The discourse and its influence on praxis in Scotland. / Duckett, D. (Corresponding Author); Feliciano, D.; Martin-Ortega, J.; Munoz-Rojas, J.

In: Landscape and Urban Planning, Vol. 154, 10.2016, p. 44-56.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{6bb7bad84fb84a939da23472ac5ae680,
title = "Tackling wicked environmental problems: The discourse and its influence on praxis in Scotland",
abstract = "Complex, social-environmental issues can be classified as ‘wicked problems’ because they are incorrigible and hugely challenging for policy makers. Here we re-evaluate what makes problems wicked and assess various theoretical and pragmatic approaches that have been advanced to tackle them. We do so with the aim of contributing new insights to theory through answering the following research questions: What strategies to tackle wicked environmental problems are prominent in the literature?; To what extent do they provide pathways for tackling the defining characteristics of wicked environmental problems?; and, How are these strategies reflected in examples of practice? Our examples look at how emergent strategies have percolated, explicitly or implicitly, in the management of four problems in Scotland: (1) Securing sustainability and resilience of landscape and land-use systems through spatial planning; (2) Addressing population health through livestock disease control; (3) Mitigating climate change through woodland planting; and, (4) Mitigating rural diffuse pollution in freshwater systems. We present a consolidated set of characteristics of wicked problems against which we map strategies to tackle wicked problems proposed by a body of literature identified through a literature review and analysed using a thematic, qualitative approach. We identify fifteen strategies and show that most of these are, within the Scottish context, evident in practice. The extent to which the actual discourse has influenced praxis and how effective it has been is more difficult to determine but we conclude that, within a context of ‘incorrigible’ problems, small steps have been made towards taming an untameable beast.",
keywords = "planning , land use, climate change, diffuse pollution, livestock disease, woodland planting",
author = "D. Duckett and D. Feliciano and J. Martin-Ortega and J. Munoz-Rojas",
year = "2016",
month = "10",
doi = "10.1016/j.landurbplan.2016.03.015",
language = "English",
volume = "154",
pages = "44--56",
journal = "Landscape and Urban Planning",
issn = "0169-2046",
publisher = "Elsevier",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Tackling wicked environmental problems

T2 - The discourse and its influence on praxis in Scotland

AU - Duckett, D.

AU - Feliciano, D.

AU - Martin-Ortega, J.

AU - Munoz-Rojas, J.

PY - 2016/10

Y1 - 2016/10

N2 - Complex, social-environmental issues can be classified as ‘wicked problems’ because they are incorrigible and hugely challenging for policy makers. Here we re-evaluate what makes problems wicked and assess various theoretical and pragmatic approaches that have been advanced to tackle them. We do so with the aim of contributing new insights to theory through answering the following research questions: What strategies to tackle wicked environmental problems are prominent in the literature?; To what extent do they provide pathways for tackling the defining characteristics of wicked environmental problems?; and, How are these strategies reflected in examples of practice? Our examples look at how emergent strategies have percolated, explicitly or implicitly, in the management of four problems in Scotland: (1) Securing sustainability and resilience of landscape and land-use systems through spatial planning; (2) Addressing population health through livestock disease control; (3) Mitigating climate change through woodland planting; and, (4) Mitigating rural diffuse pollution in freshwater systems. We present a consolidated set of characteristics of wicked problems against which we map strategies to tackle wicked problems proposed by a body of literature identified through a literature review and analysed using a thematic, qualitative approach. We identify fifteen strategies and show that most of these are, within the Scottish context, evident in practice. The extent to which the actual discourse has influenced praxis and how effective it has been is more difficult to determine but we conclude that, within a context of ‘incorrigible’ problems, small steps have been made towards taming an untameable beast.

AB - Complex, social-environmental issues can be classified as ‘wicked problems’ because they are incorrigible and hugely challenging for policy makers. Here we re-evaluate what makes problems wicked and assess various theoretical and pragmatic approaches that have been advanced to tackle them. We do so with the aim of contributing new insights to theory through answering the following research questions: What strategies to tackle wicked environmental problems are prominent in the literature?; To what extent do they provide pathways for tackling the defining characteristics of wicked environmental problems?; and, How are these strategies reflected in examples of practice? Our examples look at how emergent strategies have percolated, explicitly or implicitly, in the management of four problems in Scotland: (1) Securing sustainability and resilience of landscape and land-use systems through spatial planning; (2) Addressing population health through livestock disease control; (3) Mitigating climate change through woodland planting; and, (4) Mitigating rural diffuse pollution in freshwater systems. We present a consolidated set of characteristics of wicked problems against which we map strategies to tackle wicked problems proposed by a body of literature identified through a literature review and analysed using a thematic, qualitative approach. We identify fifteen strategies and show that most of these are, within the Scottish context, evident in practice. The extent to which the actual discourse has influenced praxis and how effective it has been is more difficult to determine but we conclude that, within a context of ‘incorrigible’ problems, small steps have been made towards taming an untameable beast.

KW - planning

KW - land use

KW - climate change

KW - diffuse pollution

KW - livestock disease

KW - woodland planting

U2 - 10.1016/j.landurbplan.2016.03.015

DO - 10.1016/j.landurbplan.2016.03.015

M3 - Article

VL - 154

SP - 44

EP - 56

JO - Landscape and Urban Planning

JF - Landscape and Urban Planning

SN - 0169-2046

ER -