The Challenges of Measuring Methane Fluxes and Concentrations over a Peatland Pasture

Dennis D. Baldocchi, Matteo Detto, Oliver Sonnentag, Joe Verfaillie, Yit Arn Teh, Whendee L. Silver, Maggi Kelly

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

73 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

We report on methane (CH4) concentrations and efflux densities that were measured over a drained and grazed, peatland pasture in the Sacramento-San Joaquin River Delta of California over a three year period. The site was ideal for micrometeorological flux measurements due to its very flat topography, its exposure to vigorous winds and its extended fetch along the predominant wind direction. Nevertheless, the interpretation of methane fluxes with eddy covariance proved to be extremely complicated by a number of geographical, biophysical, biogeochemical and site management factors.

Initial inspection of the data revealed unexpected results methane concentrations and efflux densities were greatest during the night rather than during the day. To explain this odd diurnal behavior in methane efflux densities and concentration, we tested two hypotheses. The prime hypothesis presupposed that the stable stratification of the nocturnal boundary layer elongated the flux footprint and enabled the flux tower to sense wetter fields at the western edge of the pasture, flooded drainage ditches, and/or a tidal marsh upwind of the pasture these land forms emitted methane at rates 10-100 times greater than the drained portion of the peatland. And, this methane was emitted into a shallower volume of the atmosphere due to the collapse of the nocturnal boundary layer, causing methane concentrations to rise faster. The alternative hypothesis attributed the higher nocturnal methane fluxes to cattle, as they may have congregated near the tower at night.

We investigated these hypotheses with: (1) a series of micrometeorological field measurements at companion sites upwind and downwind of the pasture; (2) a series of chamber-based flux measurements on the representative land classes; (3) through the lens of a one-dimensional planetary boundary layer (pbl), box model; and (4) via inspection of digital camera images for the presence or absence of cattle. Together, these pieces of data suggest that elevated methane fluxes and concentrations at night were due to the combined correlation between: (1) the collapse of the nocturnal boundary layer; (2) the elongation of the flux and concentration footprints; and (3) the preferential sampling of an elevated methane source, be it the cattle, wet proportions of the field or some combination. On the other hand, our flux measurements were not perturbed by methane emanating from the tidal marsh that was several kilometers upwind of the peatland pasture site.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)177-187
Number of pages11
JournalAgricultural and Forest Meteorology
Volume153
Early online date19 May 2011
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Feb 2012

Fingerprint

peatlands
methane production
peatland
methane
pasture
pastures
nocturnal boundary layer
flux measurement
cattle
salt marshes
footprint
San Joaquin River
marsh
measuring
drainage channels
wind direction
landforms
eddy covariance
Lens
fetch

Cite this

Baldocchi, D. D., Detto, M., Sonnentag, O., Verfaillie, J., Teh, Y. A., Silver, W. L., & Kelly, M. (2012). The Challenges of Measuring Methane Fluxes and Concentrations over a Peatland Pasture. Agricultural and Forest Meteorology, 153, 177-187. https://doi.org/DOI:10.1016/j.agrformet.2011.04.013

The Challenges of Measuring Methane Fluxes and Concentrations over a Peatland Pasture. / Baldocchi, Dennis D.; Detto, Matteo; Sonnentag, Oliver; Verfaillie, Joe; Teh, Yit Arn; Silver, Whendee L.; Kelly, Maggi.

In: Agricultural and Forest Meteorology, Vol. 153, 02.2012, p. 177-187.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Baldocchi, DD, Detto, M, Sonnentag, O, Verfaillie, J, Teh, YA, Silver, WL & Kelly, M 2012, 'The Challenges of Measuring Methane Fluxes and Concentrations over a Peatland Pasture', Agricultural and Forest Meteorology, vol. 153, pp. 177-187. https://doi.org/DOI:10.1016/j.agrformet.2011.04.013
Baldocchi, Dennis D. ; Detto, Matteo ; Sonnentag, Oliver ; Verfaillie, Joe ; Teh, Yit Arn ; Silver, Whendee L. ; Kelly, Maggi. / The Challenges of Measuring Methane Fluxes and Concentrations over a Peatland Pasture. In: Agricultural and Forest Meteorology. 2012 ; Vol. 153. pp. 177-187.
@article{bc2df8191e1c422f94e4e017ba032412,
title = "The Challenges of Measuring Methane Fluxes and Concentrations over a Peatland Pasture",
abstract = "We report on methane (CH4) concentrations and efflux densities that were measured over a drained and grazed, peatland pasture in the Sacramento-San Joaquin River Delta of California over a three year period. The site was ideal for micrometeorological flux measurements due to its very flat topography, its exposure to vigorous winds and its extended fetch along the predominant wind direction. Nevertheless, the interpretation of methane fluxes with eddy covariance proved to be extremely complicated by a number of geographical, biophysical, biogeochemical and site management factors.Initial inspection of the data revealed unexpected results methane concentrations and efflux densities were greatest during the night rather than during the day. To explain this odd diurnal behavior in methane efflux densities and concentration, we tested two hypotheses. The prime hypothesis presupposed that the stable stratification of the nocturnal boundary layer elongated the flux footprint and enabled the flux tower to sense wetter fields at the western edge of the pasture, flooded drainage ditches, and/or a tidal marsh upwind of the pasture these land forms emitted methane at rates 10-100 times greater than the drained portion of the peatland. And, this methane was emitted into a shallower volume of the atmosphere due to the collapse of the nocturnal boundary layer, causing methane concentrations to rise faster. The alternative hypothesis attributed the higher nocturnal methane fluxes to cattle, as they may have congregated near the tower at night.We investigated these hypotheses with: (1) a series of micrometeorological field measurements at companion sites upwind and downwind of the pasture; (2) a series of chamber-based flux measurements on the representative land classes; (3) through the lens of a one-dimensional planetary boundary layer (pbl), box model; and (4) via inspection of digital camera images for the presence or absence of cattle. Together, these pieces of data suggest that elevated methane fluxes and concentrations at night were due to the combined correlation between: (1) the collapse of the nocturnal boundary layer; (2) the elongation of the flux and concentration footprints; and (3) the preferential sampling of an elevated methane source, be it the cattle, wet proportions of the field or some combination. On the other hand, our flux measurements were not perturbed by methane emanating from the tidal marsh that was several kilometers upwind of the peatland pasture site.",
author = "Baldocchi, {Dennis D.} and Matteo Detto and Oliver Sonnentag and Joe Verfaillie and Teh, {Yit Arn} and Silver, {Whendee L.} and Maggi Kelly",
note = "Acknowledgements This work was funded by NSF-ATM grant number AGS-0628720 and the California Department of Water Resources grant #006550. We thank Mr. Ted Hehn for his able assistance in conducting the field measurements and servicing the instruments during the initial phase of the project. We thank Dr. Ed Dlugokencky and NOAA ESRL for the weekly of CH4 concentration from Trinidad Head, CA. We thank the California Department of Water Resources for permission to place our study site on their land and the land managers who maintained the rice study. We thank Los Gatos Research for the loan of a mobile flux system for use during the spring of 2010.",
year = "2012",
month = "2",
doi = "DOI:10.1016/j.agrformet.2011.04.013",
language = "English",
volume = "153",
pages = "177--187",
journal = "Agricultural and Forest Meteorology",
issn = "0168-1923",
publisher = "Elsevier",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - The Challenges of Measuring Methane Fluxes and Concentrations over a Peatland Pasture

AU - Baldocchi, Dennis D.

AU - Detto, Matteo

AU - Sonnentag, Oliver

AU - Verfaillie, Joe

AU - Teh, Yit Arn

AU - Silver, Whendee L.

AU - Kelly, Maggi

N1 - Acknowledgements This work was funded by NSF-ATM grant number AGS-0628720 and the California Department of Water Resources grant #006550. We thank Mr. Ted Hehn for his able assistance in conducting the field measurements and servicing the instruments during the initial phase of the project. We thank Dr. Ed Dlugokencky and NOAA ESRL for the weekly of CH4 concentration from Trinidad Head, CA. We thank the California Department of Water Resources for permission to place our study site on their land and the land managers who maintained the rice study. We thank Los Gatos Research for the loan of a mobile flux system for use during the spring of 2010.

PY - 2012/2

Y1 - 2012/2

N2 - We report on methane (CH4) concentrations and efflux densities that were measured over a drained and grazed, peatland pasture in the Sacramento-San Joaquin River Delta of California over a three year period. The site was ideal for micrometeorological flux measurements due to its very flat topography, its exposure to vigorous winds and its extended fetch along the predominant wind direction. Nevertheless, the interpretation of methane fluxes with eddy covariance proved to be extremely complicated by a number of geographical, biophysical, biogeochemical and site management factors.Initial inspection of the data revealed unexpected results methane concentrations and efflux densities were greatest during the night rather than during the day. To explain this odd diurnal behavior in methane efflux densities and concentration, we tested two hypotheses. The prime hypothesis presupposed that the stable stratification of the nocturnal boundary layer elongated the flux footprint and enabled the flux tower to sense wetter fields at the western edge of the pasture, flooded drainage ditches, and/or a tidal marsh upwind of the pasture these land forms emitted methane at rates 10-100 times greater than the drained portion of the peatland. And, this methane was emitted into a shallower volume of the atmosphere due to the collapse of the nocturnal boundary layer, causing methane concentrations to rise faster. The alternative hypothesis attributed the higher nocturnal methane fluxes to cattle, as they may have congregated near the tower at night.We investigated these hypotheses with: (1) a series of micrometeorological field measurements at companion sites upwind and downwind of the pasture; (2) a series of chamber-based flux measurements on the representative land classes; (3) through the lens of a one-dimensional planetary boundary layer (pbl), box model; and (4) via inspection of digital camera images for the presence or absence of cattle. Together, these pieces of data suggest that elevated methane fluxes and concentrations at night were due to the combined correlation between: (1) the collapse of the nocturnal boundary layer; (2) the elongation of the flux and concentration footprints; and (3) the preferential sampling of an elevated methane source, be it the cattle, wet proportions of the field or some combination. On the other hand, our flux measurements were not perturbed by methane emanating from the tidal marsh that was several kilometers upwind of the peatland pasture site.

AB - We report on methane (CH4) concentrations and efflux densities that were measured over a drained and grazed, peatland pasture in the Sacramento-San Joaquin River Delta of California over a three year period. The site was ideal for micrometeorological flux measurements due to its very flat topography, its exposure to vigorous winds and its extended fetch along the predominant wind direction. Nevertheless, the interpretation of methane fluxes with eddy covariance proved to be extremely complicated by a number of geographical, biophysical, biogeochemical and site management factors.Initial inspection of the data revealed unexpected results methane concentrations and efflux densities were greatest during the night rather than during the day. To explain this odd diurnal behavior in methane efflux densities and concentration, we tested two hypotheses. The prime hypothesis presupposed that the stable stratification of the nocturnal boundary layer elongated the flux footprint and enabled the flux tower to sense wetter fields at the western edge of the pasture, flooded drainage ditches, and/or a tidal marsh upwind of the pasture these land forms emitted methane at rates 10-100 times greater than the drained portion of the peatland. And, this methane was emitted into a shallower volume of the atmosphere due to the collapse of the nocturnal boundary layer, causing methane concentrations to rise faster. The alternative hypothesis attributed the higher nocturnal methane fluxes to cattle, as they may have congregated near the tower at night.We investigated these hypotheses with: (1) a series of micrometeorological field measurements at companion sites upwind and downwind of the pasture; (2) a series of chamber-based flux measurements on the representative land classes; (3) through the lens of a one-dimensional planetary boundary layer (pbl), box model; and (4) via inspection of digital camera images for the presence or absence of cattle. Together, these pieces of data suggest that elevated methane fluxes and concentrations at night were due to the combined correlation between: (1) the collapse of the nocturnal boundary layer; (2) the elongation of the flux and concentration footprints; and (3) the preferential sampling of an elevated methane source, be it the cattle, wet proportions of the field or some combination. On the other hand, our flux measurements were not perturbed by methane emanating from the tidal marsh that was several kilometers upwind of the peatland pasture site.

U2 - DOI:10.1016/j.agrformet.2011.04.013

DO - DOI:10.1016/j.agrformet.2011.04.013

M3 - Article

VL - 153

SP - 177

EP - 187

JO - Agricultural and Forest Meteorology

JF - Agricultural and Forest Meteorology

SN - 0168-1923

ER -