The devil and the detail

an illustration of otherness in John Nalson's 'An Impartial Collection'

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

An Impartial Collection of the Great Affairs of State was published in London, in two volumes, between 1682 and 1683. Its author John Nalson was a fervent believer in the twin pillars of the monarchy and the Anglican Church. In An Impartial Collection he holds up the internecine conflict of the 1640s as an example not to be followed during the 1680s, a period of further religious and political upheaval. Nalson’s text is anything but neutral, and its perspective is neatly summarised in the engraved frontispiece, which prefaces the first volume. This article will examine how this illustration, depicting a weeping Britannia accosted by a two-faced clergyman and a devil, adapts and revises an established visual vocabulary of ‘otherness’, implying disruption to English lives and liberties with origins both foreign and domestic. Such polemical imagery relies on shock value and provocation, but also contributes to a sophisticated conversation between a range of pictorial sources, reshaping old material to new concerns, and raising important questions regarding the visual literacy and acuity of its viewers.
Original languageEnglish
JournalBulletin of the John Rylands University Library of Manchester
Volume95
Issue number2
Publication statusAccepted/In press - 29 Apr 2019

Fingerprint

clergyman
provocation
monarchy
foreignness
vocabulary
conversation
church
literacy
Values
Devil
Otherness
Monarchy
Vocabulary
1680s
1640s
Viewer
Anglican Church
Frontispiece
Clergymen
Imagery

Keywords

  • frontispiece
  • engraving
  • otherness
  • Exclusion Crisis
  • propaganda

Cite this

@article{2ab8e3c9c3d94dde994c627aa23122f8,
title = "The devil and the detail: an illustration of otherness in John Nalson's 'An Impartial Collection'",
abstract = "An Impartial Collection of the Great Affairs of State was published in London, in two volumes, between 1682 and 1683. Its author John Nalson was a fervent believer in the twin pillars of the monarchy and the Anglican Church. In An Impartial Collection he holds up the internecine conflict of the 1640s as an example not to be followed during the 1680s, a period of further religious and political upheaval. Nalson’s text is anything but neutral, and its perspective is neatly summarised in the engraved frontispiece, which prefaces the first volume. This article will examine how this illustration, depicting a weeping Britannia accosted by a two-faced clergyman and a devil, adapts and revises an established visual vocabulary of ‘otherness’, implying disruption to English lives and liberties with origins both foreign and domestic. Such polemical imagery relies on shock value and provocation, but also contributes to a sophisticated conversation between a range of pictorial sources, reshaping old material to new concerns, and raising important questions regarding the visual literacy and acuity of its viewers.",
keywords = "frontispiece, engraving, otherness, Exclusion Crisis, propaganda",
author = "Pierce, {Helen Suzanne}",
year = "2019",
month = "4",
day = "29",
language = "English",
volume = "95",
journal = "Bulletin of the John Rylands University Library of Manchester",
issn = "0301-102X",
publisher = "John Rylands University Library",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - The devil and the detail

T2 - an illustration of otherness in John Nalson's 'An Impartial Collection'

AU - Pierce, Helen Suzanne

PY - 2019/4/29

Y1 - 2019/4/29

N2 - An Impartial Collection of the Great Affairs of State was published in London, in two volumes, between 1682 and 1683. Its author John Nalson was a fervent believer in the twin pillars of the monarchy and the Anglican Church. In An Impartial Collection he holds up the internecine conflict of the 1640s as an example not to be followed during the 1680s, a period of further religious and political upheaval. Nalson’s text is anything but neutral, and its perspective is neatly summarised in the engraved frontispiece, which prefaces the first volume. This article will examine how this illustration, depicting a weeping Britannia accosted by a two-faced clergyman and a devil, adapts and revises an established visual vocabulary of ‘otherness’, implying disruption to English lives and liberties with origins both foreign and domestic. Such polemical imagery relies on shock value and provocation, but also contributes to a sophisticated conversation between a range of pictorial sources, reshaping old material to new concerns, and raising important questions regarding the visual literacy and acuity of its viewers.

AB - An Impartial Collection of the Great Affairs of State was published in London, in two volumes, between 1682 and 1683. Its author John Nalson was a fervent believer in the twin pillars of the monarchy and the Anglican Church. In An Impartial Collection he holds up the internecine conflict of the 1640s as an example not to be followed during the 1680s, a period of further religious and political upheaval. Nalson’s text is anything but neutral, and its perspective is neatly summarised in the engraved frontispiece, which prefaces the first volume. This article will examine how this illustration, depicting a weeping Britannia accosted by a two-faced clergyman and a devil, adapts and revises an established visual vocabulary of ‘otherness’, implying disruption to English lives and liberties with origins both foreign and domestic. Such polemical imagery relies on shock value and provocation, but also contributes to a sophisticated conversation between a range of pictorial sources, reshaping old material to new concerns, and raising important questions regarding the visual literacy and acuity of its viewers.

KW - frontispiece

KW - engraving

KW - otherness

KW - Exclusion Crisis

KW - propaganda

M3 - Article

VL - 95

JO - Bulletin of the John Rylands University Library of Manchester

JF - Bulletin of the John Rylands University Library of Manchester

SN - 0301-102X

IS - 2

ER -