The effect of long-term soil management on the physical and biological resilience of a range of arable and grassland soils in England

Andrew S. Gregory*, Chris W. Watts, Bryan S. Griffiths, Paul D. Hallett, Hsueh L. Kuan, Andrew P. Whitmore

*Corresponding author for this work

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

71 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

In agricultural systems, soils are subjected to a range of stresses which may affect soil physical and biological properties and compromise the ability of the soil to function. How the soil responds to stress both initially and over time defines resistance and resilience respectively and is key to sustainable soil management. As soil organic matter (OM) is a fundamental soil property, we hypothesised that resilience would be controlled, in part, by this. As soil OM is itself affected by long-term soil management, we therefore sought to establish a direct link between this and resilience to physical and biological stresses.

Fifteen soils were taken from a range of arable and grassland sites in England, including the Broadbalk and Highfield long-term experiments at Rothamsted. The soils were subjected to physical (uniaxial compaction stress) or biological (transient heat stress or persistent Cu stress) stresses in the laboratory and the effects on general physical (void ratio) and biological (substrate-induced respiration) functions were monitored over a recovery period of up to 28 days. Wet-dry and freeze-thaw cycles were also imposed on the soils following the initial recovery after compression.

The initial recovery of void ratio following compression was greater in grassland soils (0.28-0.80) than arable soils (0.16-0.58) which was probably related to the elastic effect of particulate OM and the redistribution of the greater water content in the former soils. Wet-dry and freeze-thaw cycles had an additional effect in soils with clay contents greater than 26% The transient heat stress reduced respiration rates in the grassland soils by up to 45%. Grassland soils are less likely to have been subjected to heat stress in the field since they carry a greater vegetation covering than arable soils. The more persistent Cu stress reduced respiration rates in arable soils by up to 85% but only up to 30% in grassland soils. The difference was ascribed to the greater microbial biomass and diversity in grassland soils and buffering by the OM. We defined resistance and resilience indices as the absolute value of the measured soil functions at maximum stress and after the recovery period respectively. Reasonable linear regressions (adjusted R(2) up to 0.68) were established for resistance or resilience as a function of soil OM content used as a proxy index of soil management Expressed in this way, grassland soils were more resistant and resilient to the physical and biological stresses than the arable soils. Linear relationships were also found to link physical and biological resistance and resilience (adjusted R(2) up to 0.96). An arable soil with 65% clay was found to be highly resilient also. We found large differences in physical and biological resilience to stress between arable and grassland soils. We attributed this primarily to the effect of soil management on the OM content although we recognised the importance of clay content. (C) 2009 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)172-185
Number of pages14
JournalGeoderma
Volume153
Issue number1-2
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 15 Oct 2009

Keywords

  • organic-matter
  • functional resilience
  • microbial community
  • tillage
  • biodiversity
  • diversity
  • physical resilience
  • compaction
  • ecosystem function relationship
  • soil management
  • stability
  • long-term experiments
  • soil organic matter
  • self-mulching behavior
  • biological resilience

Cite this

The effect of long-term soil management on the physical and biological resilience of a range of arable and grassland soils in England. / Gregory, Andrew S.; Watts, Chris W.; Griffiths, Bryan S.; Hallett, Paul D.; Kuan, Hsueh L.; Whitmore, Andrew P.

In: Geoderma, Vol. 153, No. 1-2, 15.10.2009, p. 172-185.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Gregory, Andrew S. ; Watts, Chris W. ; Griffiths, Bryan S. ; Hallett, Paul D. ; Kuan, Hsueh L. ; Whitmore, Andrew P. / The effect of long-term soil management on the physical and biological resilience of a range of arable and grassland soils in England. In: Geoderma. 2009 ; Vol. 153, No. 1-2. pp. 172-185.
@article{36a7604c96f04964b7b4cd5d21229d00,
title = "The effect of long-term soil management on the physical and biological resilience of a range of arable and grassland soils in England",
abstract = "In agricultural systems, soils are subjected to a range of stresses which may affect soil physical and biological properties and compromise the ability of the soil to function. How the soil responds to stress both initially and over time defines resistance and resilience respectively and is key to sustainable soil management. As soil organic matter (OM) is a fundamental soil property, we hypothesised that resilience would be controlled, in part, by this. As soil OM is itself affected by long-term soil management, we therefore sought to establish a direct link between this and resilience to physical and biological stresses.Fifteen soils were taken from a range of arable and grassland sites in England, including the Broadbalk and Highfield long-term experiments at Rothamsted. The soils were subjected to physical (uniaxial compaction stress) or biological (transient heat stress or persistent Cu stress) stresses in the laboratory and the effects on general physical (void ratio) and biological (substrate-induced respiration) functions were monitored over a recovery period of up to 28 days. Wet-dry and freeze-thaw cycles were also imposed on the soils following the initial recovery after compression.The initial recovery of void ratio following compression was greater in grassland soils (0.28-0.80) than arable soils (0.16-0.58) which was probably related to the elastic effect of particulate OM and the redistribution of the greater water content in the former soils. Wet-dry and freeze-thaw cycles had an additional effect in soils with clay contents greater than 26{\%} The transient heat stress reduced respiration rates in the grassland soils by up to 45{\%}. Grassland soils are less likely to have been subjected to heat stress in the field since they carry a greater vegetation covering than arable soils. The more persistent Cu stress reduced respiration rates in arable soils by up to 85{\%} but only up to 30{\%} in grassland soils. The difference was ascribed to the greater microbial biomass and diversity in grassland soils and buffering by the OM. We defined resistance and resilience indices as the absolute value of the measured soil functions at maximum stress and after the recovery period respectively. Reasonable linear regressions (adjusted R(2) up to 0.68) were established for resistance or resilience as a function of soil OM content used as a proxy index of soil management Expressed in this way, grassland soils were more resistant and resilient to the physical and biological stresses than the arable soils. Linear relationships were also found to link physical and biological resistance and resilience (adjusted R(2) up to 0.96). An arable soil with 65{\%} clay was found to be highly resilient also. We found large differences in physical and biological resilience to stress between arable and grassland soils. We attributed this primarily to the effect of soil management on the OM content although we recognised the importance of clay content. (C) 2009 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.",
keywords = "organic-matter, functional resilience, microbial community, tillage, biodiversity, diversity, physical resilience, compaction, ecosystem function relationship, soil management, stability, long-term experiments, soil organic matter, self-mulching behavior, biological resilience",
author = "Gregory, {Andrew S.} and Watts, {Chris W.} and Griffiths, {Bryan S.} and Hallett, {Paul D.} and Kuan, {Hsueh L.} and Whitmore, {Andrew P.}",
year = "2009",
month = "10",
day = "15",
doi = "10.1016/j.geoderma.2009.08.002",
language = "English",
volume = "153",
pages = "172--185",
journal = "Geoderma",
issn = "0016-7061",
publisher = "Elsevier",
number = "1-2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - The effect of long-term soil management on the physical and biological resilience of a range of arable and grassland soils in England

AU - Gregory, Andrew S.

AU - Watts, Chris W.

AU - Griffiths, Bryan S.

AU - Hallett, Paul D.

AU - Kuan, Hsueh L.

AU - Whitmore, Andrew P.

PY - 2009/10/15

Y1 - 2009/10/15

N2 - In agricultural systems, soils are subjected to a range of stresses which may affect soil physical and biological properties and compromise the ability of the soil to function. How the soil responds to stress both initially and over time defines resistance and resilience respectively and is key to sustainable soil management. As soil organic matter (OM) is a fundamental soil property, we hypothesised that resilience would be controlled, in part, by this. As soil OM is itself affected by long-term soil management, we therefore sought to establish a direct link between this and resilience to physical and biological stresses.Fifteen soils were taken from a range of arable and grassland sites in England, including the Broadbalk and Highfield long-term experiments at Rothamsted. The soils were subjected to physical (uniaxial compaction stress) or biological (transient heat stress or persistent Cu stress) stresses in the laboratory and the effects on general physical (void ratio) and biological (substrate-induced respiration) functions were monitored over a recovery period of up to 28 days. Wet-dry and freeze-thaw cycles were also imposed on the soils following the initial recovery after compression.The initial recovery of void ratio following compression was greater in grassland soils (0.28-0.80) than arable soils (0.16-0.58) which was probably related to the elastic effect of particulate OM and the redistribution of the greater water content in the former soils. Wet-dry and freeze-thaw cycles had an additional effect in soils with clay contents greater than 26% The transient heat stress reduced respiration rates in the grassland soils by up to 45%. Grassland soils are less likely to have been subjected to heat stress in the field since they carry a greater vegetation covering than arable soils. The more persistent Cu stress reduced respiration rates in arable soils by up to 85% but only up to 30% in grassland soils. The difference was ascribed to the greater microbial biomass and diversity in grassland soils and buffering by the OM. We defined resistance and resilience indices as the absolute value of the measured soil functions at maximum stress and after the recovery period respectively. Reasonable linear regressions (adjusted R(2) up to 0.68) were established for resistance or resilience as a function of soil OM content used as a proxy index of soil management Expressed in this way, grassland soils were more resistant and resilient to the physical and biological stresses than the arable soils. Linear relationships were also found to link physical and biological resistance and resilience (adjusted R(2) up to 0.96). An arable soil with 65% clay was found to be highly resilient also. We found large differences in physical and biological resilience to stress between arable and grassland soils. We attributed this primarily to the effect of soil management on the OM content although we recognised the importance of clay content. (C) 2009 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.

AB - In agricultural systems, soils are subjected to a range of stresses which may affect soil physical and biological properties and compromise the ability of the soil to function. How the soil responds to stress both initially and over time defines resistance and resilience respectively and is key to sustainable soil management. As soil organic matter (OM) is a fundamental soil property, we hypothesised that resilience would be controlled, in part, by this. As soil OM is itself affected by long-term soil management, we therefore sought to establish a direct link between this and resilience to physical and biological stresses.Fifteen soils were taken from a range of arable and grassland sites in England, including the Broadbalk and Highfield long-term experiments at Rothamsted. The soils were subjected to physical (uniaxial compaction stress) or biological (transient heat stress or persistent Cu stress) stresses in the laboratory and the effects on general physical (void ratio) and biological (substrate-induced respiration) functions were monitored over a recovery period of up to 28 days. Wet-dry and freeze-thaw cycles were also imposed on the soils following the initial recovery after compression.The initial recovery of void ratio following compression was greater in grassland soils (0.28-0.80) than arable soils (0.16-0.58) which was probably related to the elastic effect of particulate OM and the redistribution of the greater water content in the former soils. Wet-dry and freeze-thaw cycles had an additional effect in soils with clay contents greater than 26% The transient heat stress reduced respiration rates in the grassland soils by up to 45%. Grassland soils are less likely to have been subjected to heat stress in the field since they carry a greater vegetation covering than arable soils. The more persistent Cu stress reduced respiration rates in arable soils by up to 85% but only up to 30% in grassland soils. The difference was ascribed to the greater microbial biomass and diversity in grassland soils and buffering by the OM. We defined resistance and resilience indices as the absolute value of the measured soil functions at maximum stress and after the recovery period respectively. Reasonable linear regressions (adjusted R(2) up to 0.68) were established for resistance or resilience as a function of soil OM content used as a proxy index of soil management Expressed in this way, grassland soils were more resistant and resilient to the physical and biological stresses than the arable soils. Linear relationships were also found to link physical and biological resistance and resilience (adjusted R(2) up to 0.96). An arable soil with 65% clay was found to be highly resilient also. We found large differences in physical and biological resilience to stress between arable and grassland soils. We attributed this primarily to the effect of soil management on the OM content although we recognised the importance of clay content. (C) 2009 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.

KW - organic-matter

KW - functional resilience

KW - microbial community

KW - tillage

KW - biodiversity

KW - diversity

KW - physical resilience

KW - compaction

KW - ecosystem function relationship

KW - soil management

KW - stability

KW - long-term experiments

KW - soil organic matter

KW - self-mulching behavior

KW - biological resilience

U2 - 10.1016/j.geoderma.2009.08.002

DO - 10.1016/j.geoderma.2009.08.002

M3 - Article

VL - 153

SP - 172

EP - 185

JO - Geoderma

JF - Geoderma

SN - 0016-7061

IS - 1-2

ER -