The Impact of Treatment of Organic Manures on Future Soil Carbon Sequestration Under Different Tillage Systems in Pakistan

Khuram Shahzad, Ayub Khan, Mark Richards, Jo U. Smith

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

1 Citation (Scopus)
7 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Field experiments were conducted at Gujjar Seed and Nursery Farm, Haripur, Pakistan to investigate impact of incorporating differently treated of organic manures using different tillage systems on soil carbon. Maximum increase in soil carbon was observed when the required nitrogen was applied as bioslurry produced from cattle manure by anaerobic digestion. This was
significantly greater than when the required amount of nitrogen was applied as composted poultry manure or chemical fertilizer. Minimum tillage also resulted in a significant increase of soil carbon compared to conventional or deep tillage. These experimental measurements were used to evaluate a dynamic simulation model of soil organic matter turnover, RothC, which was then used to estimate future carbon sequestration. The correlation between experimental and simulated values was highly significant and the root mean square error was within experimental error, suggesting that RothC is providing an acceptable representation of the changes in soil carbon that is occurring in this experiment. The uncertainty in simulations was less than 3%. Simulations were done using future weather scenarios; these suggest that addition of the recommended rate of nitrogen in 8.4 t ha-1y-1 bioslurry every year increases soil carbon sequestration over 100 years (2012-2112) by 24.9±0.74 t ha-1 compared to the control where no organic manure was applied. This sequesters 7.5±0.24 t ha-1 more carbon than if the same amount of nitrogen is applied as poultry manure, requiring an application rate of 7.5 t ha-1 y-1. If the same amounts of bioslurry and poultry manure are applied, carbon sequestration is still significantly greater for bioslurry than for poultry manure (4.5±0.2 t ha-1). Losses of carbon with climate change were highest under climate scenario B2 (environmental protection with regionalization) and B1 (environmental protection with globalization), followed by A1B (economic growth with globalization), with minimum losses from A2 (economic growth with regionalization). These predicted losses are likely to be more than compensated for by application of organic fertilizers at the rates needed to supply sufficient nitrogen to the crops.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)277-286
Number of pages10
JournalPakistan Journal of Agricultural Sciences
Volume54
Issue number2
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Jun 2017

Fingerprint

Carbon Sequestration
Manure
Pakistan
soil carbon
carbon sequestration
animal manures
tillage
manure
Soil
poultry manure
Carbon
Poultry
poultry
carbon
Nitrogen
nitrogen
globalization
environmental protection
Internationality
Economic Development

Keywords

  • soil carbon sequestration
  • organic manures
  • bioslurry
  • poultry manure
  • nitrogen sources
  • RothC

Cite this

The Impact of Treatment of Organic Manures on Future Soil Carbon Sequestration Under Different Tillage Systems in Pakistan. / Shahzad, Khuram ; Khan, Ayub ; Richards, Mark; Smith, Jo U.

In: Pakistan Journal of Agricultural Sciences, Vol. 54, No. 2, 06.2017, p. 277-286.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{8d7f56191bc940ad88f11e5be8bfe3b0,
title = "The Impact of Treatment of Organic Manures on Future Soil Carbon Sequestration Under Different Tillage Systems in Pakistan",
abstract = "Field experiments were conducted at Gujjar Seed and Nursery Farm, Haripur, Pakistan to investigate impact of incorporating differently treated of organic manures using different tillage systems on soil carbon. Maximum increase in soil carbon was observed when the required nitrogen was applied as bioslurry produced from cattle manure by anaerobic digestion. This wassignificantly greater than when the required amount of nitrogen was applied as composted poultry manure or chemical fertilizer. Minimum tillage also resulted in a significant increase of soil carbon compared to conventional or deep tillage. These experimental measurements were used to evaluate a dynamic simulation model of soil organic matter turnover, RothC, which was then used to estimate future carbon sequestration. The correlation between experimental and simulated values was highly significant and the root mean square error was within experimental error, suggesting that RothC is providing an acceptable representation of the changes in soil carbon that is occurring in this experiment. The uncertainty in simulations was less than 3{\%}. Simulations were done using future weather scenarios; these suggest that addition of the recommended rate of nitrogen in 8.4 t ha-1y-1 bioslurry every year increases soil carbon sequestration over 100 years (2012-2112) by 24.9±0.74 t ha-1 compared to the control where no organic manure was applied. This sequesters 7.5±0.24 t ha-1 more carbon than if the same amount of nitrogen is applied as poultry manure, requiring an application rate of 7.5 t ha-1 y-1. If the same amounts of bioslurry and poultry manure are applied, carbon sequestration is still significantly greater for bioslurry than for poultry manure (4.5±0.2 t ha-1). Losses of carbon with climate change were highest under climate scenario B2 (environmental protection with regionalization) and B1 (environmental protection with globalization), followed by A1B (economic growth with globalization), with minimum losses from A2 (economic growth with regionalization). These predicted losses are likely to be more than compensated for by application of organic fertilizers at the rates needed to supply sufficient nitrogen to the crops.",
keywords = "soil carbon sequestration, organic manures, bioslurry, poultry manure, nitrogen sources, RothC",
author = "Khuram Shahzad and Ayub Khan and Mark Richards and Smith, {Jo U.}",
note = "Funds provided by Higher Education Commission (HEC) of Pakistan for carrying out this Ph.D. research work under “Indigenous 5000 Fellowship Program” and “International Research Support Initiative Program” are highly acknowledged.",
year = "2017",
month = "6",
doi = "10.21162/PAKJAS/17.4486",
language = "English",
volume = "54",
pages = "277--286",
journal = "Pakistan Journal of Agricultural Sciences",
issn = "2076-0906",
publisher = "Pakistan Association of Advancement in Agricultural Sciences",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - The Impact of Treatment of Organic Manures on Future Soil Carbon Sequestration Under Different Tillage Systems in Pakistan

AU - Shahzad, Khuram

AU - Khan, Ayub

AU - Richards, Mark

AU - Smith, Jo U.

N1 - Funds provided by Higher Education Commission (HEC) of Pakistan for carrying out this Ph.D. research work under “Indigenous 5000 Fellowship Program” and “International Research Support Initiative Program” are highly acknowledged.

PY - 2017/6

Y1 - 2017/6

N2 - Field experiments were conducted at Gujjar Seed and Nursery Farm, Haripur, Pakistan to investigate impact of incorporating differently treated of organic manures using different tillage systems on soil carbon. Maximum increase in soil carbon was observed when the required nitrogen was applied as bioslurry produced from cattle manure by anaerobic digestion. This wassignificantly greater than when the required amount of nitrogen was applied as composted poultry manure or chemical fertilizer. Minimum tillage also resulted in a significant increase of soil carbon compared to conventional or deep tillage. These experimental measurements were used to evaluate a dynamic simulation model of soil organic matter turnover, RothC, which was then used to estimate future carbon sequestration. The correlation between experimental and simulated values was highly significant and the root mean square error was within experimental error, suggesting that RothC is providing an acceptable representation of the changes in soil carbon that is occurring in this experiment. The uncertainty in simulations was less than 3%. Simulations were done using future weather scenarios; these suggest that addition of the recommended rate of nitrogen in 8.4 t ha-1y-1 bioslurry every year increases soil carbon sequestration over 100 years (2012-2112) by 24.9±0.74 t ha-1 compared to the control where no organic manure was applied. This sequesters 7.5±0.24 t ha-1 more carbon than if the same amount of nitrogen is applied as poultry manure, requiring an application rate of 7.5 t ha-1 y-1. If the same amounts of bioslurry and poultry manure are applied, carbon sequestration is still significantly greater for bioslurry than for poultry manure (4.5±0.2 t ha-1). Losses of carbon with climate change were highest under climate scenario B2 (environmental protection with regionalization) and B1 (environmental protection with globalization), followed by A1B (economic growth with globalization), with minimum losses from A2 (economic growth with regionalization). These predicted losses are likely to be more than compensated for by application of organic fertilizers at the rates needed to supply sufficient nitrogen to the crops.

AB - Field experiments were conducted at Gujjar Seed and Nursery Farm, Haripur, Pakistan to investigate impact of incorporating differently treated of organic manures using different tillage systems on soil carbon. Maximum increase in soil carbon was observed when the required nitrogen was applied as bioslurry produced from cattle manure by anaerobic digestion. This wassignificantly greater than when the required amount of nitrogen was applied as composted poultry manure or chemical fertilizer. Minimum tillage also resulted in a significant increase of soil carbon compared to conventional or deep tillage. These experimental measurements were used to evaluate a dynamic simulation model of soil organic matter turnover, RothC, which was then used to estimate future carbon sequestration. The correlation between experimental and simulated values was highly significant and the root mean square error was within experimental error, suggesting that RothC is providing an acceptable representation of the changes in soil carbon that is occurring in this experiment. The uncertainty in simulations was less than 3%. Simulations were done using future weather scenarios; these suggest that addition of the recommended rate of nitrogen in 8.4 t ha-1y-1 bioslurry every year increases soil carbon sequestration over 100 years (2012-2112) by 24.9±0.74 t ha-1 compared to the control where no organic manure was applied. This sequesters 7.5±0.24 t ha-1 more carbon than if the same amount of nitrogen is applied as poultry manure, requiring an application rate of 7.5 t ha-1 y-1. If the same amounts of bioslurry and poultry manure are applied, carbon sequestration is still significantly greater for bioslurry than for poultry manure (4.5±0.2 t ha-1). Losses of carbon with climate change were highest under climate scenario B2 (environmental protection with regionalization) and B1 (environmental protection with globalization), followed by A1B (economic growth with globalization), with minimum losses from A2 (economic growth with regionalization). These predicted losses are likely to be more than compensated for by application of organic fertilizers at the rates needed to supply sufficient nitrogen to the crops.

KW - soil carbon sequestration

KW - organic manures

KW - bioslurry

KW - poultry manure

KW - nitrogen sources

KW - RothC

U2 - 10.21162/PAKJAS/17.4486

DO - 10.21162/PAKJAS/17.4486

M3 - Article

VL - 54

SP - 277

EP - 286

JO - Pakistan Journal of Agricultural Sciences

JF - Pakistan Journal of Agricultural Sciences

SN - 2076-0906

IS - 2

ER -