The Influence of Philosophical Perspectives in Integrative Research: a Conservation Case Study in the Cairngorms National Park

Anna C. Evely, Ioan Fazey, Michelle Pinard, Xavier Lambin

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

49 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The benefits of increasing the contribution of the social sciences in the fields of environmental and conservation science disciplines are increasingly recognized. However, integration between the social and natural sciences has been limited, in part because of the barrier caused by major philosophical differences in the perspectives between these research areas. This paper aims to contribute to more effective interdisciplinary integration by explaining some of the philosophical views underpinning social research and how these views influence research methods and outcomes. We use a project investigating the motivation of volunteers working in an adaptive co-management project to eradicate American Mink from the Cairngorms National Park in Scotland as a case study to illustrate the impact of philosophical perspectives on research. Consideration of different perspectives promoted explicit reflection of the contributing researcher's assumptions, and the implications of his or her perspectives on the outcomes of the research. We suggest a framework to assist conservation research projects by: ( 1) assisting formulation of research questions; ( 2) focusing dialogue between managers and researchers, making underlying worldviews explicit; and ( 3) helping researchers and managers improve longer-term strategies by helping identify overall goals and objectives and by identifying immediate research needs.

Original languageEnglish
Article number52
Number of pages16
JournalEcology and Society
Volume13
Issue number2
Publication statusPublished - Dec 2008

Keywords

  • adaptive co-management
  • interdisciplinarity
  • philosophy
  • social-ecological resilience
  • mink mustela-vison
  • critical realism
  • social-science
  • biology
  • biodiversity
  • values
  • nominalism
  • knowledge
  • attitudes
  • social–ecological resilience

Cite this

@article{2cc28d25d1414d9f9205f67ec6dc519b,
title = "The Influence of Philosophical Perspectives in Integrative Research: a Conservation Case Study in the Cairngorms National Park",
abstract = "The benefits of increasing the contribution of the social sciences in the fields of environmental and conservation science disciplines are increasingly recognized. However, integration between the social and natural sciences has been limited, in part because of the barrier caused by major philosophical differences in the perspectives between these research areas. This paper aims to contribute to more effective interdisciplinary integration by explaining some of the philosophical views underpinning social research and how these views influence research methods and outcomes. We use a project investigating the motivation of volunteers working in an adaptive co-management project to eradicate American Mink from the Cairngorms National Park in Scotland as a case study to illustrate the impact of philosophical perspectives on research. Consideration of different perspectives promoted explicit reflection of the contributing researcher's assumptions, and the implications of his or her perspectives on the outcomes of the research. We suggest a framework to assist conservation research projects by: ( 1) assisting formulation of research questions; ( 2) focusing dialogue between managers and researchers, making underlying worldviews explicit; and ( 3) helping researchers and managers improve longer-term strategies by helping identify overall goals and objectives and by identifying immediate research needs.",
keywords = "adaptive co-management, interdisciplinarity, philosophy, social-ecological resilience, mink mustela-vison, critical realism, social-science, biology, biodiversity, values, nominalism, knowledge, attitudes, social–ecological resilience",
author = "Evely, {Anna C.} and Ioan Fazey and Michelle Pinard and Xavier Lambin",
year = "2008",
month = "12",
language = "English",
volume = "13",
journal = "Ecology and Society",
issn = "1708-3087",
publisher = "The Resilience Alliance",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - The Influence of Philosophical Perspectives in Integrative Research

T2 - a Conservation Case Study in the Cairngorms National Park

AU - Evely, Anna C.

AU - Fazey, Ioan

AU - Pinard, Michelle

AU - Lambin, Xavier

PY - 2008/12

Y1 - 2008/12

N2 - The benefits of increasing the contribution of the social sciences in the fields of environmental and conservation science disciplines are increasingly recognized. However, integration between the social and natural sciences has been limited, in part because of the barrier caused by major philosophical differences in the perspectives between these research areas. This paper aims to contribute to more effective interdisciplinary integration by explaining some of the philosophical views underpinning social research and how these views influence research methods and outcomes. We use a project investigating the motivation of volunteers working in an adaptive co-management project to eradicate American Mink from the Cairngorms National Park in Scotland as a case study to illustrate the impact of philosophical perspectives on research. Consideration of different perspectives promoted explicit reflection of the contributing researcher's assumptions, and the implications of his or her perspectives on the outcomes of the research. We suggest a framework to assist conservation research projects by: ( 1) assisting formulation of research questions; ( 2) focusing dialogue between managers and researchers, making underlying worldviews explicit; and ( 3) helping researchers and managers improve longer-term strategies by helping identify overall goals and objectives and by identifying immediate research needs.

AB - The benefits of increasing the contribution of the social sciences in the fields of environmental and conservation science disciplines are increasingly recognized. However, integration between the social and natural sciences has been limited, in part because of the barrier caused by major philosophical differences in the perspectives between these research areas. This paper aims to contribute to more effective interdisciplinary integration by explaining some of the philosophical views underpinning social research and how these views influence research methods and outcomes. We use a project investigating the motivation of volunteers working in an adaptive co-management project to eradicate American Mink from the Cairngorms National Park in Scotland as a case study to illustrate the impact of philosophical perspectives on research. Consideration of different perspectives promoted explicit reflection of the contributing researcher's assumptions, and the implications of his or her perspectives on the outcomes of the research. We suggest a framework to assist conservation research projects by: ( 1) assisting formulation of research questions; ( 2) focusing dialogue between managers and researchers, making underlying worldviews explicit; and ( 3) helping researchers and managers improve longer-term strategies by helping identify overall goals and objectives and by identifying immediate research needs.

KW - adaptive co-management

KW - interdisciplinarity

KW - philosophy

KW - social-ecological resilience

KW - mink mustela-vison

KW - critical realism

KW - social-science

KW - biology

KW - biodiversity

KW - values

KW - nominalism

KW - knowledge

KW - attitudes

KW - social–ecological resilience

M3 - Article

VL - 13

JO - Ecology and Society

JF - Ecology and Society

SN - 1708-3087

IS - 2

M1 - 52

ER -