The interpretation of radiocarbon dates from the upper surface of late Holocene peat layers in coastal lowlands

Martyn P. Waller, Antony J. Long, James Edward Schofield

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

18 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Marine/brackish elastic sediments replace freshwater peals in the stratigraphic column of many coastal lowland areas bordering the North Sea during the late Holocene. Radiocarbon dates are routinely used to provide a chronology for this shift. We examine the assumptions underpinning this approach. The results of investigations from 13 sites in the Rye area of Romney Marsh, southeast England, are reported. Dates from apparently gradational contacts of a highly humified, laterally persistent, peat layer range from 3170-2840 cal. yr BP to 1290-1050 cal. yr BP. Multiple inundations or prolonged gradual inundation are nevertheless rejected, as discrete post-peat bodies of sediment are absent and because peat growth appears to have slowed-down or ceased at many sites in advance of inundation. Additionally in the Rye area, sharp contacts are widespread and the pollen assemblages rarely indicate the occurrence of transitional plant communities. A review of the dating evidence from other coastal lowland regions reveals that multiple dating of the upper surface of peat beds invariably produces diachronous results. As a consequence time-transgressive processes feature prominently as causal mechanisms underlying this shift. However. many of the dating difficulties recognized in the Rye area appear to apply to other regions. We conclude that radiocarbon dates from the upper surface of peat layers should in most instances only be regarded as limiting ages for the deposition of the overlying clastic sediments. New chronologies need to be built without a priori assumptions as to the underlying processes. ideally through the direct dating of the elastic sediments.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)51-61
Number of pages10
JournalThe Holocene
Volume16
Issue number1
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Jan 2006

Keywords

  • Late Holocene
  • coastal change
  • radiocarbon dating
  • peat accumulation
  • coastal lowlands
  • Romney Marsh
  • England

Cite this

The interpretation of radiocarbon dates from the upper surface of late Holocene peat layers in coastal lowlands. / Waller, Martyn P.; Long, Antony J.; Schofield, James Edward.

In: The Holocene, Vol. 16, No. 1, 01.2006, p. 51-61.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{960d6c8f253d4a5ca90533cb9dfaca03,
title = "The interpretation of radiocarbon dates from the upper surface of late Holocene peat layers in coastal lowlands",
abstract = "Marine/brackish elastic sediments replace freshwater peals in the stratigraphic column of many coastal lowland areas bordering the North Sea during the late Holocene. Radiocarbon dates are routinely used to provide a chronology for this shift. We examine the assumptions underpinning this approach. The results of investigations from 13 sites in the Rye area of Romney Marsh, southeast England, are reported. Dates from apparently gradational contacts of a highly humified, laterally persistent, peat layer range from 3170-2840 cal. yr BP to 1290-1050 cal. yr BP. Multiple inundations or prolonged gradual inundation are nevertheless rejected, as discrete post-peat bodies of sediment are absent and because peat growth appears to have slowed-down or ceased at many sites in advance of inundation. Additionally in the Rye area, sharp contacts are widespread and the pollen assemblages rarely indicate the occurrence of transitional plant communities. A review of the dating evidence from other coastal lowland regions reveals that multiple dating of the upper surface of peat beds invariably produces diachronous results. As a consequence time-transgressive processes feature prominently as causal mechanisms underlying this shift. However. many of the dating difficulties recognized in the Rye area appear to apply to other regions. We conclude that radiocarbon dates from the upper surface of peat layers should in most instances only be regarded as limiting ages for the deposition of the overlying clastic sediments. New chronologies need to be built without a priori assumptions as to the underlying processes. ideally through the direct dating of the elastic sediments.",
keywords = "Late Holocene, coastal change, radiocarbon dating, peat accumulation, coastal lowlands, Romney Marsh, England",
author = "Waller, {Martyn P.} and Long, {Antony J.} and Schofield, {James Edward}",
year = "2006",
month = "1",
doi = "10.1191/0959683606hl895ra",
language = "English",
volume = "16",
pages = "51--61",
journal = "The Holocene",
issn = "0959-6836",
publisher = "SAGE Publications Ltd",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - The interpretation of radiocarbon dates from the upper surface of late Holocene peat layers in coastal lowlands

AU - Waller, Martyn P.

AU - Long, Antony J.

AU - Schofield, James Edward

PY - 2006/1

Y1 - 2006/1

N2 - Marine/brackish elastic sediments replace freshwater peals in the stratigraphic column of many coastal lowland areas bordering the North Sea during the late Holocene. Radiocarbon dates are routinely used to provide a chronology for this shift. We examine the assumptions underpinning this approach. The results of investigations from 13 sites in the Rye area of Romney Marsh, southeast England, are reported. Dates from apparently gradational contacts of a highly humified, laterally persistent, peat layer range from 3170-2840 cal. yr BP to 1290-1050 cal. yr BP. Multiple inundations or prolonged gradual inundation are nevertheless rejected, as discrete post-peat bodies of sediment are absent and because peat growth appears to have slowed-down or ceased at many sites in advance of inundation. Additionally in the Rye area, sharp contacts are widespread and the pollen assemblages rarely indicate the occurrence of transitional plant communities. A review of the dating evidence from other coastal lowland regions reveals that multiple dating of the upper surface of peat beds invariably produces diachronous results. As a consequence time-transgressive processes feature prominently as causal mechanisms underlying this shift. However. many of the dating difficulties recognized in the Rye area appear to apply to other regions. We conclude that radiocarbon dates from the upper surface of peat layers should in most instances only be regarded as limiting ages for the deposition of the overlying clastic sediments. New chronologies need to be built without a priori assumptions as to the underlying processes. ideally through the direct dating of the elastic sediments.

AB - Marine/brackish elastic sediments replace freshwater peals in the stratigraphic column of many coastal lowland areas bordering the North Sea during the late Holocene. Radiocarbon dates are routinely used to provide a chronology for this shift. We examine the assumptions underpinning this approach. The results of investigations from 13 sites in the Rye area of Romney Marsh, southeast England, are reported. Dates from apparently gradational contacts of a highly humified, laterally persistent, peat layer range from 3170-2840 cal. yr BP to 1290-1050 cal. yr BP. Multiple inundations or prolonged gradual inundation are nevertheless rejected, as discrete post-peat bodies of sediment are absent and because peat growth appears to have slowed-down or ceased at many sites in advance of inundation. Additionally in the Rye area, sharp contacts are widespread and the pollen assemblages rarely indicate the occurrence of transitional plant communities. A review of the dating evidence from other coastal lowland regions reveals that multiple dating of the upper surface of peat beds invariably produces diachronous results. As a consequence time-transgressive processes feature prominently as causal mechanisms underlying this shift. However. many of the dating difficulties recognized in the Rye area appear to apply to other regions. We conclude that radiocarbon dates from the upper surface of peat layers should in most instances only be regarded as limiting ages for the deposition of the overlying clastic sediments. New chronologies need to be built without a priori assumptions as to the underlying processes. ideally through the direct dating of the elastic sediments.

KW - Late Holocene

KW - coastal change

KW - radiocarbon dating

KW - peat accumulation

KW - coastal lowlands

KW - Romney Marsh

KW - England

U2 - 10.1191/0959683606hl895ra

DO - 10.1191/0959683606hl895ra

M3 - Article

VL - 16

SP - 51

EP - 61

JO - The Holocene

JF - The Holocene

SN - 0959-6836

IS - 1

ER -