The repeatability of cognitive performance: a meta-analysis

M. Cauchoix, P. K. Y. Chow, J. O. van Horik, C. M. Atance, E. J. Barbeau, G. Barragon-Jason, Pierre Bize, A. Boussard, S. D. Beuchel, A. Cabirol, L. Cauchard, N. Claidière, S. Dalesman, J. M. Devaud, M. Didic, B. Doligez, J. Fagot, C. Fichtel, J. Henke-von der Malsburg, E. Hermer & 22 others L. Huber, F. Huebner, P. M. Kappeler, S. Klein, J. Langbein, E. J. G. Langley, S. E. G. Lea, M. Lihoreau, H. Lovlie, L. D. Matzel, S. Nakagawa, C. Nawroth, S. Oesterwind, B. Sauce, E. Smith, E. Sorato, S. Tebbich, L. J. Wallis, M. A. Whiteside, A. Wilkinson, A. S. Chaine, J. Morand-Ferron

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

15 Citations (Scopus)
4 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Selection acts on heritable individual variation in behaviours. Both behavioural and cognitive processes play important roles in mediating an individual's interactions with their environment. Yet, while there is a vast literature on repeatable individual differences in behaviour, relatively little is known about the repeatability of cognitive performance. To further our understanding of the evolution of cognition we gathered 44 datasets on individual performances of 25 species and used meta-analysis to evaluate whether cognitive performance is repeatable across six animal classes. We assessed repeatability (R) in performance (1) on the same task presented at different time intervals (temporal repeatability), and (2) on different tasks that measure the same putative cognitive ability (contextual repeatability). We also addressed whether R estimates are influenced by seven extrinsic factors (moderators): type of cognitive task, type of measurement, delay between tasks, origin of the subjects, experimental context, taxonomic class and if the R value was published or unpublished. We found support for both temporal and contextual repeatability of individual variation in cognitive performance, with significant mean R estimates ranging between 0.15 and 0.28. R estimates were mostly influenced by the type of cognitive performance measures and the fact that R values was published, none of the other moderators showed consistent and significant impacts on repeatability estimates. Our overall findings highlight the widespread occurrence of consistent inter-individual variation in cognition which, like behaviour, may have fitness implications.
Original languageEnglish
Article number20170281
JournalPhilosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences
Volume373
Issue number1756
Early online date13 Aug 2018
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 26 Sep 2018

Fingerprint

Moderators
individual variation
meta-analysis
cognition
repeatability
Meta-Analysis
Cognition
Animals
Aptitude
Individuality
fitness
animal
animals

Keywords

  • cognitive repeatability
  • consistency
  • evolutionary biology of cognition
  • individual differences
  • learning
  • memory
  • attention

Cite this

Cauchoix, M., Chow, P. K. Y., van Horik, J. O., Atance, C. M., Barbeau, E. J., Barragon-Jason, G., ... Morand-Ferron, J. (2018). The repeatability of cognitive performance: a meta-analysis. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences, 373(1756), [20170281]. https://doi.org/10.1098/rstb.2017.0281

The repeatability of cognitive performance : a meta-analysis. / Cauchoix, M.; Chow, P. K. Y.; van Horik, J. O.; Atance, C. M.; Barbeau, E. J.; Barragon-Jason, G.; Bize, Pierre; Boussard, A.; Beuchel, S. D.; Cabirol, A.; Cauchard, L.; Claidière, N.; Dalesman, S.; Devaud, J. M.; Didic, M.; Doligez, B.; Fagot, J.; Fichtel, C.; Henke-von der Malsburg, J.; Hermer, E.; Huber, L.; Huebner, F.; Kappeler, P. M.; Klein, S.; Langbein, J.; Langley, E. J. G.; Lea, S. E. G.; Lihoreau, M.; Lovlie, H.; Matzel, L. D.; Nakagawa, S.; Nawroth, C.; Oesterwind, S.; Sauce, B.; Smith, E.; Sorato, E.; Tebbich, S.; Wallis, L. J.; Whiteside, M. A.; Wilkinson, A.; Chaine, A. S.; Morand-Ferron, J.

In: Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences, Vol. 373, No. 1756, 20170281, 26.09.2018.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Cauchoix, M, Chow, PKY, van Horik, JO, Atance, CM, Barbeau, EJ, Barragon-Jason, G, Bize, P, Boussard, A, Beuchel, SD, Cabirol, A, Cauchard, L, Claidière, N, Dalesman, S, Devaud, JM, Didic, M, Doligez, B, Fagot, J, Fichtel, C, Henke-von der Malsburg, J, Hermer, E, Huber, L, Huebner, F, Kappeler, PM, Klein, S, Langbein, J, Langley, EJG, Lea, SEG, Lihoreau, M, Lovlie, H, Matzel, LD, Nakagawa, S, Nawroth, C, Oesterwind, S, Sauce, B, Smith, E, Sorato, E, Tebbich, S, Wallis, LJ, Whiteside, MA, Wilkinson, A, Chaine, AS & Morand-Ferron, J 2018, 'The repeatability of cognitive performance: a meta-analysis' Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences, vol. 373, no. 1756, 20170281. https://doi.org/10.1098/rstb.2017.0281
Cauchoix M, Chow PKY, van Horik JO, Atance CM, Barbeau EJ, Barragon-Jason G et al. The repeatability of cognitive performance: a meta-analysis. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences. 2018 Sep 26;373(1756). 20170281. https://doi.org/10.1098/rstb.2017.0281
Cauchoix, M. ; Chow, P. K. Y. ; van Horik, J. O. ; Atance, C. M. ; Barbeau, E. J. ; Barragon-Jason, G. ; Bize, Pierre ; Boussard, A. ; Beuchel, S. D. ; Cabirol, A. ; Cauchard, L. ; Claidière, N. ; Dalesman, S. ; Devaud, J. M. ; Didic, M. ; Doligez, B. ; Fagot, J. ; Fichtel, C. ; Henke-von der Malsburg, J. ; Hermer, E. ; Huber, L. ; Huebner, F. ; Kappeler, P. M. ; Klein, S. ; Langbein, J. ; Langley, E. J. G. ; Lea, S. E. G. ; Lihoreau, M. ; Lovlie, H. ; Matzel, L. D. ; Nakagawa, S. ; Nawroth, C. ; Oesterwind, S. ; Sauce, B. ; Smith, E. ; Sorato, E. ; Tebbich, S. ; Wallis, L. J. ; Whiteside, M. A. ; Wilkinson, A. ; Chaine, A. S. ; Morand-Ferron, J. / The repeatability of cognitive performance : a meta-analysis. In: Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences. 2018 ; Vol. 373, No. 1756.
@article{07a57156062c4ac4995609308d4dcf87,
title = "The repeatability of cognitive performance: a meta-analysis",
abstract = "Selection acts on heritable individual variation in behaviours. Both behavioural and cognitive processes play important roles in mediating an individual's interactions with their environment. Yet, while there is a vast literature on repeatable individual differences in behaviour, relatively little is known about the repeatability of cognitive performance. To further our understanding of the evolution of cognition we gathered 44 datasets on individual performances of 25 species and used meta-analysis to evaluate whether cognitive performance is repeatable across six animal classes. We assessed repeatability (R) in performance (1) on the same task presented at different time intervals (temporal repeatability), and (2) on different tasks that measure the same putative cognitive ability (contextual repeatability). We also addressed whether R estimates are influenced by seven extrinsic factors (moderators): type of cognitive task, type of measurement, delay between tasks, origin of the subjects, experimental context, taxonomic class and if the R value was published or unpublished. We found support for both temporal and contextual repeatability of individual variation in cognitive performance, with significant mean R estimates ranging between 0.15 and 0.28. R estimates were mostly influenced by the type of cognitive performance measures and the fact that R values was published, none of the other moderators showed consistent and significant impacts on repeatability estimates. Our overall findings highlight the widespread occurrence of consistent inter-individual variation in cognition which, like behaviour, may have fitness implications.",
keywords = "cognitive repeatability, consistency, evolutionary biology of cognition, individual differences, learning, memory, attention",
author = "M. Cauchoix and Chow, {P. K. Y.} and {van Horik}, {J. O.} and Atance, {C. M.} and Barbeau, {E. J.} and G. Barragon-Jason and Pierre Bize and A. Boussard and Beuchel, {S. D.} and A. Cabirol and L. Cauchard and N. Claidi{\`e}re and S. Dalesman and Devaud, {J. M.} and M. Didic and B. Doligez and J. Fagot and C. Fichtel and {Henke-von der Malsburg}, J. and E. Hermer and L. Huber and F. Huebner and Kappeler, {P. M.} and S. Klein and J. Langbein and Langley, {E. J. G.} and Lea, {S. E. G.} and M. Lihoreau and H. Lovlie and Matzel, {L. D.} and S. Nakagawa and C. Nawroth and S. Oesterwind and B. Sauce and E. Smith and E. Sorato and S. Tebbich and Wallis, {L. J.} and Whiteside, {M. A.} and A. Wilkinson and Chaine, {A. S.} and J. Morand-Ferron",
note = "P.K.Y.C. is supported by the Japan Society for the Promotion of Science (PE1801); J.O.v.H. was funded by an ERC consolidator grant to J. Madden (616474). M.C. as well as this research was supported by a grant from the Human Frontier Science Program to A.S.C. and J.M.-F. (RGP0006/2015) and a Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada Discovery Grant to J.M.F. (435596-2013).",
year = "2018",
month = "9",
day = "26",
doi = "10.1098/rstb.2017.0281",
language = "English",
volume = "373",
journal = "Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences",
issn = "0962-8436",
publisher = "ROYAL SOC CHEMISTRY",
number = "1756",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - The repeatability of cognitive performance

T2 - a meta-analysis

AU - Cauchoix, M.

AU - Chow, P. K. Y.

AU - van Horik, J. O.

AU - Atance, C. M.

AU - Barbeau, E. J.

AU - Barragon-Jason, G.

AU - Bize, Pierre

AU - Boussard, A.

AU - Beuchel, S. D.

AU - Cabirol, A.

AU - Cauchard, L.

AU - Claidière, N.

AU - Dalesman, S.

AU - Devaud, J. M.

AU - Didic, M.

AU - Doligez, B.

AU - Fagot, J.

AU - Fichtel, C.

AU - Henke-von der Malsburg, J.

AU - Hermer, E.

AU - Huber, L.

AU - Huebner, F.

AU - Kappeler, P. M.

AU - Klein, S.

AU - Langbein, J.

AU - Langley, E. J. G.

AU - Lea, S. E. G.

AU - Lihoreau, M.

AU - Lovlie, H.

AU - Matzel, L. D.

AU - Nakagawa, S.

AU - Nawroth, C.

AU - Oesterwind, S.

AU - Sauce, B.

AU - Smith, E.

AU - Sorato, E.

AU - Tebbich, S.

AU - Wallis, L. J.

AU - Whiteside, M. A.

AU - Wilkinson, A.

AU - Chaine, A. S.

AU - Morand-Ferron, J.

N1 - P.K.Y.C. is supported by the Japan Society for the Promotion of Science (PE1801); J.O.v.H. was funded by an ERC consolidator grant to J. Madden (616474). M.C. as well as this research was supported by a grant from the Human Frontier Science Program to A.S.C. and J.M.-F. (RGP0006/2015) and a Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada Discovery Grant to J.M.F. (435596-2013).

PY - 2018/9/26

Y1 - 2018/9/26

N2 - Selection acts on heritable individual variation in behaviours. Both behavioural and cognitive processes play important roles in mediating an individual's interactions with their environment. Yet, while there is a vast literature on repeatable individual differences in behaviour, relatively little is known about the repeatability of cognitive performance. To further our understanding of the evolution of cognition we gathered 44 datasets on individual performances of 25 species and used meta-analysis to evaluate whether cognitive performance is repeatable across six animal classes. We assessed repeatability (R) in performance (1) on the same task presented at different time intervals (temporal repeatability), and (2) on different tasks that measure the same putative cognitive ability (contextual repeatability). We also addressed whether R estimates are influenced by seven extrinsic factors (moderators): type of cognitive task, type of measurement, delay between tasks, origin of the subjects, experimental context, taxonomic class and if the R value was published or unpublished. We found support for both temporal and contextual repeatability of individual variation in cognitive performance, with significant mean R estimates ranging between 0.15 and 0.28. R estimates were mostly influenced by the type of cognitive performance measures and the fact that R values was published, none of the other moderators showed consistent and significant impacts on repeatability estimates. Our overall findings highlight the widespread occurrence of consistent inter-individual variation in cognition which, like behaviour, may have fitness implications.

AB - Selection acts on heritable individual variation in behaviours. Both behavioural and cognitive processes play important roles in mediating an individual's interactions with their environment. Yet, while there is a vast literature on repeatable individual differences in behaviour, relatively little is known about the repeatability of cognitive performance. To further our understanding of the evolution of cognition we gathered 44 datasets on individual performances of 25 species and used meta-analysis to evaluate whether cognitive performance is repeatable across six animal classes. We assessed repeatability (R) in performance (1) on the same task presented at different time intervals (temporal repeatability), and (2) on different tasks that measure the same putative cognitive ability (contextual repeatability). We also addressed whether R estimates are influenced by seven extrinsic factors (moderators): type of cognitive task, type of measurement, delay between tasks, origin of the subjects, experimental context, taxonomic class and if the R value was published or unpublished. We found support for both temporal and contextual repeatability of individual variation in cognitive performance, with significant mean R estimates ranging between 0.15 and 0.28. R estimates were mostly influenced by the type of cognitive performance measures and the fact that R values was published, none of the other moderators showed consistent and significant impacts on repeatability estimates. Our overall findings highlight the widespread occurrence of consistent inter-individual variation in cognition which, like behaviour, may have fitness implications.

KW - cognitive repeatability

KW - consistency

KW - evolutionary biology of cognition

KW - individual differences

KW - learning

KW - memory

KW - attention

U2 - 10.1098/rstb.2017.0281

DO - 10.1098/rstb.2017.0281

M3 - Article

VL - 373

JO - Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences

JF - Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences

SN - 0962-8436

IS - 1756

M1 - 20170281

ER -