The syndrome of proximal femur, fibula, and midline metatarsal long bone deficiencies

David R. Hootnick (Corresponding Author), Neil Vargesson

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

1 Citation (Scopus)

Abstract

Human lower extremity congenital long bone deficiencies cluster primarily at three distinct skeletal loci. Proximal femoral and fibular reductions are known phenomena. In contrast, midline metatarsal deficiencies have been misrepresented as lateral. The popular term, ‘fibular hemimelia’, is inaccurate and its use is discouraged.
All three loci correspond to discrete sites of evolving angiogenesis during transition from a single embryonic axial limb artery to the familiar and complex adult arterial pattern. Initiation of bone formation of cartilaginous primordia of the long bones at all three sites occurs in proximity to, and depends upon, successful invasion by mature nutrient vessels, formed during sixth and seventh weeks of embryonic development. The adult arterial pattern is fully established by eighth embryonic week.
Arterial transitions occur later in development, around the time of cessation of the molecular processes of patterning/specification of the embryonic limb. Evidence of flawed embryonic arterial transitions, involving missing, reduced and/or retained primitive vessels in association with congenital skeletal reductions have been demonstrated at all three loci.
Current molecular models of limb development do not explain the distribution of this triad of congenital skeletal reductions. Dysmorphologies are most accurately described as postspecification errors of limb development. Recognition of this distinctive model of limb maldevelopment demands further investigation to create a more exact taxonomy, one consistent with both clinical and molecular criteria. The established terminologies originated by Frantz and O’Rahilly should be abandoned. Designation of this clinical triad as a syndrome of proximal femur, fibula and midline metatarsal dystrophisms initiates that endeavor.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)1188-1193
Number of pages6
JournalBirth Defects Research
Volume110
Issue number15
Early online date27 Aug 2018
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Sep 2018

Fingerprint

Fibula
Metatarsal Bones
Femur
Bone
Extremities
Taxonomies
Terminology
Nutrients
Ectromelia
Bone and Bones
Association reactions
Molecular Models
Specifications
Thigh
Osteogenesis
Embryonic Development
Lower Extremity
Arteries
Food

Keywords

  • arterial transition
  • developmental growth failure
  • dystrophism
  • long bone deficiency
  • proximal femoral focal deficiency
  • fibular deficiency
  • midline metatarsal deficiency
  • post-specification errors

Cite this

The syndrome of proximal femur, fibula, and midline metatarsal long bone deficiencies. / Hootnick, David R. (Corresponding Author); Vargesson, Neil.

In: Birth Defects Research, Vol. 110, No. 15, 01.09.2018, p. 1188-1193.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{47a3f25661224e3593422e4571f37434,
title = "The syndrome of proximal femur, fibula, and midline metatarsal long bone deficiencies",
abstract = "Human lower extremity congenital long bone deficiencies cluster primarily at three distinct skeletal loci. Proximal femoral and fibular reductions are known phenomena. In contrast, midline metatarsal deficiencies have been misrepresented as lateral. The popular term, ‘fibular hemimelia’, is inaccurate and its use is discouraged.All three loci correspond to discrete sites of evolving angiogenesis during transition from a single embryonic axial limb artery to the familiar and complex adult arterial pattern. Initiation of bone formation of cartilaginous primordia of the long bones at all three sites occurs in proximity to, and depends upon, successful invasion by mature nutrient vessels, formed during sixth and seventh weeks of embryonic development. The adult arterial pattern is fully established by eighth embryonic week.Arterial transitions occur later in development, around the time of cessation of the molecular processes of patterning/specification of the embryonic limb. Evidence of flawed embryonic arterial transitions, involving missing, reduced and/or retained primitive vessels in association with congenital skeletal reductions have been demonstrated at all three loci.Current molecular models of limb development do not explain the distribution of this triad of congenital skeletal reductions. Dysmorphologies are most accurately described as postspecification errors of limb development. Recognition of this distinctive model of limb maldevelopment demands further investigation to create a more exact taxonomy, one consistent with both clinical and molecular criteria. The established terminologies originated by Frantz and O’Rahilly should be abandoned. Designation of this clinical triad as a syndrome of proximal femur, fibula and midline metatarsal dystrophisms initiates that endeavor.",
keywords = "arterial transition, developmental growth failure, dystrophism, long bone deficiency, proximal femoral focal deficiency, fibular deficiency, midline metatarsal deficiency, post-specification errors",
author = "Hootnick, {David R.} and Neil Vargesson",
note = "This paper is dedicated to the memory of our dear friend and colleague, David S. Packard, Jr, PhD, who originated the term ‘post-specification error of limb development’. The authors also wish to thank Amy R. Slutzky, Phd, for bibliographic assistance and E. Mark Levinsohn, MD for deciphering the embryonic arteries, as described by Senior.",
year = "2018",
month = "9",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1002/bdr2.1349",
language = "English",
volume = "110",
pages = "1188--1193",
journal = "Birth Defects Research",
issn = "2472-1727",
publisher = "Wiley",
number = "15",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - The syndrome of proximal femur, fibula, and midline metatarsal long bone deficiencies

AU - Hootnick, David R.

AU - Vargesson, Neil

N1 - This paper is dedicated to the memory of our dear friend and colleague, David S. Packard, Jr, PhD, who originated the term ‘post-specification error of limb development’. The authors also wish to thank Amy R. Slutzky, Phd, for bibliographic assistance and E. Mark Levinsohn, MD for deciphering the embryonic arteries, as described by Senior.

PY - 2018/9/1

Y1 - 2018/9/1

N2 - Human lower extremity congenital long bone deficiencies cluster primarily at three distinct skeletal loci. Proximal femoral and fibular reductions are known phenomena. In contrast, midline metatarsal deficiencies have been misrepresented as lateral. The popular term, ‘fibular hemimelia’, is inaccurate and its use is discouraged.All three loci correspond to discrete sites of evolving angiogenesis during transition from a single embryonic axial limb artery to the familiar and complex adult arterial pattern. Initiation of bone formation of cartilaginous primordia of the long bones at all three sites occurs in proximity to, and depends upon, successful invasion by mature nutrient vessels, formed during sixth and seventh weeks of embryonic development. The adult arterial pattern is fully established by eighth embryonic week.Arterial transitions occur later in development, around the time of cessation of the molecular processes of patterning/specification of the embryonic limb. Evidence of flawed embryonic arterial transitions, involving missing, reduced and/or retained primitive vessels in association with congenital skeletal reductions have been demonstrated at all three loci.Current molecular models of limb development do not explain the distribution of this triad of congenital skeletal reductions. Dysmorphologies are most accurately described as postspecification errors of limb development. Recognition of this distinctive model of limb maldevelopment demands further investigation to create a more exact taxonomy, one consistent with both clinical and molecular criteria. The established terminologies originated by Frantz and O’Rahilly should be abandoned. Designation of this clinical triad as a syndrome of proximal femur, fibula and midline metatarsal dystrophisms initiates that endeavor.

AB - Human lower extremity congenital long bone deficiencies cluster primarily at three distinct skeletal loci. Proximal femoral and fibular reductions are known phenomena. In contrast, midline metatarsal deficiencies have been misrepresented as lateral. The popular term, ‘fibular hemimelia’, is inaccurate and its use is discouraged.All three loci correspond to discrete sites of evolving angiogenesis during transition from a single embryonic axial limb artery to the familiar and complex adult arterial pattern. Initiation of bone formation of cartilaginous primordia of the long bones at all three sites occurs in proximity to, and depends upon, successful invasion by mature nutrient vessels, formed during sixth and seventh weeks of embryonic development. The adult arterial pattern is fully established by eighth embryonic week.Arterial transitions occur later in development, around the time of cessation of the molecular processes of patterning/specification of the embryonic limb. Evidence of flawed embryonic arterial transitions, involving missing, reduced and/or retained primitive vessels in association with congenital skeletal reductions have been demonstrated at all three loci.Current molecular models of limb development do not explain the distribution of this triad of congenital skeletal reductions. Dysmorphologies are most accurately described as postspecification errors of limb development. Recognition of this distinctive model of limb maldevelopment demands further investigation to create a more exact taxonomy, one consistent with both clinical and molecular criteria. The established terminologies originated by Frantz and O’Rahilly should be abandoned. Designation of this clinical triad as a syndrome of proximal femur, fibula and midline metatarsal dystrophisms initiates that endeavor.

KW - arterial transition

KW - developmental growth failure

KW - dystrophism

KW - long bone deficiency

KW - proximal femoral focal deficiency

KW - fibular deficiency

KW - midline metatarsal deficiency

KW - post-specification errors

UR - https://doi.org/10.1002/bdr2.1349

U2 - 10.1002/bdr2.1349

DO - 10.1002/bdr2.1349

M3 - Article

VL - 110

SP - 1188

EP - 1193

JO - Birth Defects Research

JF - Birth Defects Research

SN - 2472-1727

IS - 15

ER -