The uses and abuses of the past

cultural rhetoric and the unmaking of a moral universe

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

It is well established ethnographically that history is a particularly important and celebrated
aspect of Icelandic identity. Paraphrasing Hastrup, it could be argued that Icelandic culture
is a culture of the past. The collapse in Iceland in 2008 problematised this valorisation
of history. In this paper we draw on Carrithers’ ideas of cultural rhetoric to analyse how
Icelanders made sense of the collapse particularly in relation to their understanding of
their own history. Following Johnson, we look at the play of agency, intention and responsibility
evident in the accounts offered for the collapse. Through that we seek to highlight
how these accounts, even when highly critical of Icelandic political and cultural practices,
tend to allow for and even encourage the on-going identification with the nation-form.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)15-32
Number of pages17
JournalMiscellanea Anthropologica et Sociologica
Volume15
Issue number2
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2014

Fingerprint

Icelandic
Rhetoric
History
Universe
Abuse
Iceland
Cultural Practices
Paraphrasing
Intentions

Keywords

  • cultural rhetoric
  • memory
  • collapse
  • culture of history
  • Iceland

Cite this

@article{3b38c823d5614e8d90ec6137d6986c04,
title = "The uses and abuses of the past: cultural rhetoric and the unmaking of a moral universe",
abstract = "It is well established ethnographically that history is a particularly important and celebratedaspect of Icelandic identity. Paraphrasing Hastrup, it could be argued that Icelandic cultureis a culture of the past. The collapse in Iceland in 2008 problematised this valorisationof history. In this paper we draw on Carrithers’ ideas of cultural rhetoric to analyse howIcelanders made sense of the collapse particularly in relation to their understanding oftheir own history. Following Johnson, we look at the play of agency, intention and responsibilityevident in the accounts offered for the collapse. Through that we seek to highlighthow these accounts, even when highly critical of Icelandic political and cultural practices,tend to allow for and even encourage the on-going identification with the nation-form.",
keywords = "cultural rhetoric, memory, collapse , culture of history , Iceland",
author = "Arnar Arnason",
year = "2014",
doi = "10.5604/20842937.1131971",
language = "English",
volume = "15",
pages = "15--32",
journal = "Miscellanea Anthropologica et Sociologica",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - The uses and abuses of the past

T2 - cultural rhetoric and the unmaking of a moral universe

AU - Arnason, Arnar

PY - 2014

Y1 - 2014

N2 - It is well established ethnographically that history is a particularly important and celebratedaspect of Icelandic identity. Paraphrasing Hastrup, it could be argued that Icelandic cultureis a culture of the past. The collapse in Iceland in 2008 problematised this valorisationof history. In this paper we draw on Carrithers’ ideas of cultural rhetoric to analyse howIcelanders made sense of the collapse particularly in relation to their understanding oftheir own history. Following Johnson, we look at the play of agency, intention and responsibilityevident in the accounts offered for the collapse. Through that we seek to highlighthow these accounts, even when highly critical of Icelandic political and cultural practices,tend to allow for and even encourage the on-going identification with the nation-form.

AB - It is well established ethnographically that history is a particularly important and celebratedaspect of Icelandic identity. Paraphrasing Hastrup, it could be argued that Icelandic cultureis a culture of the past. The collapse in Iceland in 2008 problematised this valorisationof history. In this paper we draw on Carrithers’ ideas of cultural rhetoric to analyse howIcelanders made sense of the collapse particularly in relation to their understanding oftheir own history. Following Johnson, we look at the play of agency, intention and responsibilityevident in the accounts offered for the collapse. Through that we seek to highlighthow these accounts, even when highly critical of Icelandic political and cultural practices,tend to allow for and even encourage the on-going identification with the nation-form.

KW - cultural rhetoric

KW - memory

KW - collapse

KW - culture of history

KW - Iceland

U2 - 10.5604/20842937.1131971

DO - 10.5604/20842937.1131971

M3 - Article

VL - 15

SP - 15

EP - 32

JO - Miscellanea Anthropologica et Sociologica

JF - Miscellanea Anthropologica et Sociologica

IS - 2

ER -