The validity of the Gammarus : Asellus ratio as an index of organic pollution

abiotic and biotic influences

Calum MacNeil, Jaimie T. A. Dick, Ewan Bigsby, Robert W. Elwood, W. Ian Montgommery, Chris N. Gibbins, David W. Kelly

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

41 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

In freshwaters, Gammarus spp. are more sensitive to organic pollution than Asellus spp. and the relative abundance of the two taxa has been proposed as a pollution index. We tested the validity of this by examining the relationship between the Gammarus : Asellus (G : A) ratio and (1) a suite of physico-chemical variables, (2) established biotic (average score per taxon, ASPT) and richness (species richness (S) and Ephemeroptera, Plecoptera and Trichoptera families richness (EPT family richness)) indices generated from the macroinvertebrate community. In addition, we investigated a suspected biotic interaction, predation, between Gammarus and Asellus. Both univariate and multivariate analyses showed that the G : A ratio was sometimes responsive to changes in parameters linked to organic pollution, such as BOD5 and nitrate levels. However, the G : A ratio also appeared responsive to variables not directly linked to organic pollution, such as conductivity and distance from source. There were significant positive correlations among the G : A ratio and the ASPT, S and EPT, indicating that changes in the relative abundances of Gammarus and Asellus were reflected in changes in the pollution sensitivity and richness of the wider macroinvertebrate community. A laboratory experiment revealed significant predation of Asellus aquaticus juveniles by Gammarus duebeni celticus adults, but no reciprocal predation. We propose that the G : A ratio may be useful as a crude measure of organic pollution that could supplement more complex indices in a multimetric approach to pollution monitoring or be used for monitoring individual sites, where a simple technique is required for monitoring purposes over a period of time. Also, we urge recognition of the possible role of biotic interactions among taxa used in the generation of pollution indices.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)75-84
Number of pages10
JournalWater research
Volume36
Issue number1
Early online date6 Nov 2001
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Jan 2002

Fingerprint

Pollution
predation
pollution
macroinvertebrate
relative abundance
pollution monitoring
monitoring
Monitoring
conductivity
species richness
nitrate
index
organic pollution
Nitrates
family
Experiments

Keywords

  • Gammarus : Asellus ratio
  • organic pollution
  • biotic indices
  • richness indices
  • predation
  • running-water sites
  • macroinvertebrate communities
  • performance
  • diversity
  • crustacea
  • quality
  • rivers

Cite this

MacNeil, C., Dick, J. T. A., Bigsby, E., Elwood, R. W., Montgommery, W. I., Gibbins, C. N., & Kelly, D. W. (2002). The validity of the Gammarus : Asellus ratio as an index of organic pollution: abiotic and biotic influences. Water research, 36(1), 75-84. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0043-1354(01)00218-4

The validity of the Gammarus : Asellus ratio as an index of organic pollution : abiotic and biotic influences. / MacNeil, Calum; Dick, Jaimie T. A.; Bigsby, Ewan; Elwood, Robert W.; Montgommery, W. Ian; Gibbins, Chris N.; Kelly, David W.

In: Water research, Vol. 36, No. 1, 01.2002, p. 75-84.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

MacNeil, C, Dick, JTA, Bigsby, E, Elwood, RW, Montgommery, WI, Gibbins, CN & Kelly, DW 2002, 'The validity of the Gammarus : Asellus ratio as an index of organic pollution: abiotic and biotic influences', Water research, vol. 36, no. 1, pp. 75-84. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0043-1354(01)00218-4
MacNeil, Calum ; Dick, Jaimie T. A. ; Bigsby, Ewan ; Elwood, Robert W. ; Montgommery, W. Ian ; Gibbins, Chris N. ; Kelly, David W. / The validity of the Gammarus : Asellus ratio as an index of organic pollution : abiotic and biotic influences. In: Water research. 2002 ; Vol. 36, No. 1. pp. 75-84.
@article{91304432b32644e2bb82aa3fd3e048ab,
title = "The validity of the Gammarus : Asellus ratio as an index of organic pollution: abiotic and biotic influences",
abstract = "In freshwaters, Gammarus spp. are more sensitive to organic pollution than Asellus spp. and the relative abundance of the two taxa has been proposed as a pollution index. We tested the validity of this by examining the relationship between the Gammarus : Asellus (G : A) ratio and (1) a suite of physico-chemical variables, (2) established biotic (average score per taxon, ASPT) and richness (species richness (S) and Ephemeroptera, Plecoptera and Trichoptera families richness (EPT family richness)) indices generated from the macroinvertebrate community. In addition, we investigated a suspected biotic interaction, predation, between Gammarus and Asellus. Both univariate and multivariate analyses showed that the G : A ratio was sometimes responsive to changes in parameters linked to organic pollution, such as BOD5 and nitrate levels. However, the G : A ratio also appeared responsive to variables not directly linked to organic pollution, such as conductivity and distance from source. There were significant positive correlations among the G : A ratio and the ASPT, S and EPT, indicating that changes in the relative abundances of Gammarus and Asellus were reflected in changes in the pollution sensitivity and richness of the wider macroinvertebrate community. A laboratory experiment revealed significant predation of Asellus aquaticus juveniles by Gammarus duebeni celticus adults, but no reciprocal predation. We propose that the G : A ratio may be useful as a crude measure of organic pollution that could supplement more complex indices in a multimetric approach to pollution monitoring or be used for monitoring individual sites, where a simple technique is required for monitoring purposes over a period of time. Also, we urge recognition of the possible role of biotic interactions among taxa used in the generation of pollution indices.",
keywords = "Gammarus : Asellus ratio, organic pollution, biotic indices, richness indices, predation, running-water sites, macroinvertebrate communities, performance, diversity, crustacea, quality, rivers",
author = "Calum MacNeil and Dick, {Jaimie T. A.} and Ewan Bigsby and Elwood, {Robert W.} and Montgommery, {W. Ian} and Gibbins, {Chris N.} and Kelly, {David W.}",
note = "This study was undertaken during a Department of Education for Northern Ireland (DENI) Research Studentship awarded to C. MacNeil. Thanks to Z{\"o}e Ruiz, Jason Pickford, Mike Jeffries, David Turnbull, Robert Lee, John Berges, John Prenter, Gillian Bell, Mark Briffa and Nikos Dabitaz. We also thank Eamon Hagen and the Environment and Heritage Service for supplying chemical monitoring data. Thanks to J.F. Wright and an anonymous referee, whose comments greatly improved this manuscript.",
year = "2002",
month = "1",
doi = "10.1016/S0043-1354(01)00218-4",
language = "English",
volume = "36",
pages = "75--84",
journal = "Water research",
issn = "0043-1354",
publisher = "Elsevier Limited",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - The validity of the Gammarus : Asellus ratio as an index of organic pollution

T2 - abiotic and biotic influences

AU - MacNeil, Calum

AU - Dick, Jaimie T. A.

AU - Bigsby, Ewan

AU - Elwood, Robert W.

AU - Montgommery, W. Ian

AU - Gibbins, Chris N.

AU - Kelly, David W.

N1 - This study was undertaken during a Department of Education for Northern Ireland (DENI) Research Studentship awarded to C. MacNeil. Thanks to Zöe Ruiz, Jason Pickford, Mike Jeffries, David Turnbull, Robert Lee, John Berges, John Prenter, Gillian Bell, Mark Briffa and Nikos Dabitaz. We also thank Eamon Hagen and the Environment and Heritage Service for supplying chemical monitoring data. Thanks to J.F. Wright and an anonymous referee, whose comments greatly improved this manuscript.

PY - 2002/1

Y1 - 2002/1

N2 - In freshwaters, Gammarus spp. are more sensitive to organic pollution than Asellus spp. and the relative abundance of the two taxa has been proposed as a pollution index. We tested the validity of this by examining the relationship between the Gammarus : Asellus (G : A) ratio and (1) a suite of physico-chemical variables, (2) established biotic (average score per taxon, ASPT) and richness (species richness (S) and Ephemeroptera, Plecoptera and Trichoptera families richness (EPT family richness)) indices generated from the macroinvertebrate community. In addition, we investigated a suspected biotic interaction, predation, between Gammarus and Asellus. Both univariate and multivariate analyses showed that the G : A ratio was sometimes responsive to changes in parameters linked to organic pollution, such as BOD5 and nitrate levels. However, the G : A ratio also appeared responsive to variables not directly linked to organic pollution, such as conductivity and distance from source. There were significant positive correlations among the G : A ratio and the ASPT, S and EPT, indicating that changes in the relative abundances of Gammarus and Asellus were reflected in changes in the pollution sensitivity and richness of the wider macroinvertebrate community. A laboratory experiment revealed significant predation of Asellus aquaticus juveniles by Gammarus duebeni celticus adults, but no reciprocal predation. We propose that the G : A ratio may be useful as a crude measure of organic pollution that could supplement more complex indices in a multimetric approach to pollution monitoring or be used for monitoring individual sites, where a simple technique is required for monitoring purposes over a period of time. Also, we urge recognition of the possible role of biotic interactions among taxa used in the generation of pollution indices.

AB - In freshwaters, Gammarus spp. are more sensitive to organic pollution than Asellus spp. and the relative abundance of the two taxa has been proposed as a pollution index. We tested the validity of this by examining the relationship between the Gammarus : Asellus (G : A) ratio and (1) a suite of physico-chemical variables, (2) established biotic (average score per taxon, ASPT) and richness (species richness (S) and Ephemeroptera, Plecoptera and Trichoptera families richness (EPT family richness)) indices generated from the macroinvertebrate community. In addition, we investigated a suspected biotic interaction, predation, between Gammarus and Asellus. Both univariate and multivariate analyses showed that the G : A ratio was sometimes responsive to changes in parameters linked to organic pollution, such as BOD5 and nitrate levels. However, the G : A ratio also appeared responsive to variables not directly linked to organic pollution, such as conductivity and distance from source. There were significant positive correlations among the G : A ratio and the ASPT, S and EPT, indicating that changes in the relative abundances of Gammarus and Asellus were reflected in changes in the pollution sensitivity and richness of the wider macroinvertebrate community. A laboratory experiment revealed significant predation of Asellus aquaticus juveniles by Gammarus duebeni celticus adults, but no reciprocal predation. We propose that the G : A ratio may be useful as a crude measure of organic pollution that could supplement more complex indices in a multimetric approach to pollution monitoring or be used for monitoring individual sites, where a simple technique is required for monitoring purposes over a period of time. Also, we urge recognition of the possible role of biotic interactions among taxa used in the generation of pollution indices.

KW - Gammarus : Asellus ratio

KW - organic pollution

KW - biotic indices

KW - richness indices

KW - predation

KW - running-water sites

KW - macroinvertebrate communities

KW - performance

KW - diversity

KW - crustacea

KW - quality

KW - rivers

U2 - 10.1016/S0043-1354(01)00218-4

DO - 10.1016/S0043-1354(01)00218-4

M3 - Article

VL - 36

SP - 75

EP - 84

JO - Water research

JF - Water research

SN - 0043-1354

IS - 1

ER -