Towards a multi-perspective study of reindeer agency, overlapping environments and human-animal relationships

Jukka Nyyssönen, Anna Kaisa Salmi

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

4 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

This paper discusses the applicability of theories about animal agency to studies of human–animal relationships in the academic disciplines of environmental history and archaeology. Both disciplines have a traditional epistemological stance that neglects the perceptual worlds of the animal. One example is presented of efforts to write from the other side of the epistemological chasm, on the environment of the animal, as well as Morten Tønnessen’s (2010) concepts of semiotic and ontological niches. There is also a critical discussion as to whether these concepts are applicable to the relationship between reindeer and humans. The second part of the text is devoted to an effort to recover the human presence in the scheme, with examples from sacrificial animals. It is argued that the human presence illuminates certain aspects of the animal agency, which theorizing on the animal Umwelt (environment) tends to neglect. In addition, these theories provide a heuristic foundation where species-specific environments, in all of which the reindeer dwells, provide a multiangled view of the limits of animal agency and the ways in which species, humans included, affect each other’s behavior in animal-to-animal and human–animal settings.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)40-51
Number of pages12
JournalArctic Anthropology
Volume50
Issue number2
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2013

Fingerprint

animal
neglect
semiotics
archaeology
heuristics
history

Cite this

Towards a multi-perspective study of reindeer agency, overlapping environments and human-animal relationships. / Nyyssönen, Jukka; Salmi, Anna Kaisa.

In: Arctic Anthropology, Vol. 50, No. 2, 2013, p. 40-51.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{f2e14662dd434e0cb8283581ab212a8e,
title = "Towards a multi-perspective study of reindeer agency, overlapping environments and human-animal relationships",
abstract = "This paper discusses the applicability of theories about animal agency to studies of human–animal relationships in the academic disciplines of environmental history and archaeology. Both disciplines have a traditional epistemological stance that neglects the perceptual worlds of the animal. One example is presented of efforts to write from the other side of the epistemological chasm, on the environment of the animal, as well as Morten T{\o}nnessen’s (2010) concepts of semiotic and ontological niches. There is also a critical discussion as to whether these concepts are applicable to the relationship between reindeer and humans. The second part of the text is devoted to an effort to recover the human presence in the scheme, with examples from sacrificial animals. It is argued that the human presence illuminates certain aspects of the animal agency, which theorizing on the animal Umwelt (environment) tends to neglect. In addition, these theories provide a heuristic foundation where species-specific environments, in all of which the reindeer dwells, provide a multiangled view of the limits of animal agency and the ways in which species, humans included, affect each other’s behavior in animal-to-animal and human–animal settings.",
author = "Jukka Nyyss{\"o}nen and Salmi, {Anna Kaisa}",
year = "2013",
doi = "10.1353/arc.2013.0012",
language = "English",
volume = "50",
pages = "40--51",
journal = "Arctic Anthropology",
issn = "0066-6939",
publisher = "University of Wisconsin Press",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Towards a multi-perspective study of reindeer agency, overlapping environments and human-animal relationships

AU - Nyyssönen, Jukka

AU - Salmi, Anna Kaisa

PY - 2013

Y1 - 2013

N2 - This paper discusses the applicability of theories about animal agency to studies of human–animal relationships in the academic disciplines of environmental history and archaeology. Both disciplines have a traditional epistemological stance that neglects the perceptual worlds of the animal. One example is presented of efforts to write from the other side of the epistemological chasm, on the environment of the animal, as well as Morten Tønnessen’s (2010) concepts of semiotic and ontological niches. There is also a critical discussion as to whether these concepts are applicable to the relationship between reindeer and humans. The second part of the text is devoted to an effort to recover the human presence in the scheme, with examples from sacrificial animals. It is argued that the human presence illuminates certain aspects of the animal agency, which theorizing on the animal Umwelt (environment) tends to neglect. In addition, these theories provide a heuristic foundation where species-specific environments, in all of which the reindeer dwells, provide a multiangled view of the limits of animal agency and the ways in which species, humans included, affect each other’s behavior in animal-to-animal and human–animal settings.

AB - This paper discusses the applicability of theories about animal agency to studies of human–animal relationships in the academic disciplines of environmental history and archaeology. Both disciplines have a traditional epistemological stance that neglects the perceptual worlds of the animal. One example is presented of efforts to write from the other side of the epistemological chasm, on the environment of the animal, as well as Morten Tønnessen’s (2010) concepts of semiotic and ontological niches. There is also a critical discussion as to whether these concepts are applicable to the relationship between reindeer and humans. The second part of the text is devoted to an effort to recover the human presence in the scheme, with examples from sacrificial animals. It is argued that the human presence illuminates certain aspects of the animal agency, which theorizing on the animal Umwelt (environment) tends to neglect. In addition, these theories provide a heuristic foundation where species-specific environments, in all of which the reindeer dwells, provide a multiangled view of the limits of animal agency and the ways in which species, humans included, affect each other’s behavior in animal-to-animal and human–animal settings.

U2 - 10.1353/arc.2013.0012

DO - 10.1353/arc.2013.0012

M3 - Article

VL - 50

SP - 40

EP - 51

JO - Arctic Anthropology

JF - Arctic Anthropology

SN - 0066-6939

IS - 2

ER -