Tropical forest wood production

A cross-continental comparison

Lindsay Banin*, Simon L. Lewis, Gabriela Lopez-Gonzalez, Timothy R. Baker, Carlos A. Quesada, Kuo Jung Chao, David F R P Burslem, Reuben Nilus, Kamariah Abu Salim, Helen C. Keeling, Sylvester Tan, Stuart J. Davies, Abel Monteagudo Mendoza, Rodolfo Vásquez, Jon Lloyd, David A. Neill, Nigel Pitman, Oliver L. Phillips

*Corresponding author for this work

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

46 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

1. Tropical forest above-ground wood production (AGWP) varies substantially along environmental gradi-ents. Some evidence suggests that AGWP may vary between regions and speci fically that Asian forests haveparticularly high AGWP. However, comparisons across biogeog raphic regions using standard ized methodsare lacking, limiting our assessment of pan-tropical variation in AGWP and potential causes.

2. We sampled AGWP in NW Amazon (17 long-term forest plots) and N Borneo (11 plots), bothwith abundant year-r ound precipitation. Within each region, forests growing on a broad range ofedaphic conditions were sampled using standardiz ed soil and forest measurement techniques.

3. Plot-level AGWP was 49% greater in Borneo than in Amazonia (9.73  0.56 vs. 6.53  0.34 Mg drymass ha1a1, respective ly; regi onal me an  1 SE). AGWP was positively associated with soil fertility(PCA axes, sum of bases and total P). After controlling for the edaphic environment, AGWP remained signifi-cantly higher in Bornean plots. Differences in AGWP were largely attributable to differing height –diameterallometry in the two regions and the abundance of large trees in Borneo. This may be explained, in part, bythe greater solar radiation in Borneo compared with NW Amazonia.

4. Trees belonging to the dominant SE Asian family, Dipterocarpacea e, gained woody biomass faster thanotherwise equivalent, neighbouring non-dipterocarps, implying that the exceptional production of Borneanforests may be driven by floristic elements. This dominant SE Asian family may partition biomass differentlyor be more efficient at harvesting resources and in converting them to woody biomass.

5. Synthesis. N Bornean forests have much greater AGWP rates than those in NW Amazon when soil condi-tions and rainfall are controlled for. Greater resource availability and the highly productive dipterocarps may, incombination, explain why Asian forests produce wood half as fast again as comparable forests in the Amazon.Our results also suggest that taxonomic groups differ in their fundamental ability to capture carbon and that dif-ferent tropical regions may therefore have different carbon uptake capacities due to biogeographic history.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)1025-1037
Number of pages13
JournalJournal of Ecology
Volume102
Issue number4
Early online date23 Jun 2014
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Jul 2014

Fingerprint

tropical forests
tropical forest
Borneo
forest mensuration
Dipterocarpaceae
carbon
forest products
biomass
Amazonia
soil fertility
soil
tropics
solar radiation
comparison
rain
history
synthesis
resource availability
tropical region
rainfall

Keywords

  • Amazon
  • Asia
  • Carbon
  • Dipterocarpaceae
  • Dynamics
  • Growth
  • Plant-soil interactions
  • Productivity
  • Soil nutrients
  • Tropical forest

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Ecology, Evolution, Behavior and Systematics
  • Ecology
  • Plant Science

Cite this

Banin, L., Lewis, S. L., Lopez-Gonzalez, G., Baker, T. R., Quesada, C. A., Chao, K. J., ... Phillips, O. L. (2014). Tropical forest wood production: A cross-continental comparison. Journal of Ecology, 102(4), 1025-1037. https://doi.org/10.1111/1365-2745.12263

Tropical forest wood production : A cross-continental comparison. / Banin, Lindsay; Lewis, Simon L.; Lopez-Gonzalez, Gabriela; Baker, Timothy R.; Quesada, Carlos A.; Chao, Kuo Jung; Burslem, David F R P; Nilus, Reuben; Abu Salim, Kamariah; Keeling, Helen C.; Tan, Sylvester; Davies, Stuart J.; Monteagudo Mendoza, Abel; Vásquez, Rodolfo; Lloyd, Jon; Neill, David A.; Pitman, Nigel; Phillips, Oliver L.

In: Journal of Ecology, Vol. 102, No. 4, 07.2014, p. 1025-1037.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Banin, L, Lewis, SL, Lopez-Gonzalez, G, Baker, TR, Quesada, CA, Chao, KJ, Burslem, DFRP, Nilus, R, Abu Salim, K, Keeling, HC, Tan, S, Davies, SJ, Monteagudo Mendoza, A, Vásquez, R, Lloyd, J, Neill, DA, Pitman, N & Phillips, OL 2014, 'Tropical forest wood production: A cross-continental comparison', Journal of Ecology, vol. 102, no. 4, pp. 1025-1037. https://doi.org/10.1111/1365-2745.12263
Banin L, Lewis SL, Lopez-Gonzalez G, Baker TR, Quesada CA, Chao KJ et al. Tropical forest wood production: A cross-continental comparison. Journal of Ecology. 2014 Jul;102(4):1025-1037. https://doi.org/10.1111/1365-2745.12263
Banin, Lindsay ; Lewis, Simon L. ; Lopez-Gonzalez, Gabriela ; Baker, Timothy R. ; Quesada, Carlos A. ; Chao, Kuo Jung ; Burslem, David F R P ; Nilus, Reuben ; Abu Salim, Kamariah ; Keeling, Helen C. ; Tan, Sylvester ; Davies, Stuart J. ; Monteagudo Mendoza, Abel ; Vásquez, Rodolfo ; Lloyd, Jon ; Neill, David A. ; Pitman, Nigel ; Phillips, Oliver L. / Tropical forest wood production : A cross-continental comparison. In: Journal of Ecology. 2014 ; Vol. 102, No. 4. pp. 1025-1037.
@article{172b0fcbc8de42aab43a15be10137a53,
title = "Tropical forest wood production: A cross-continental comparison",
abstract = "1. Tropical forest above-ground wood production (AGWP) varies substantially along environmental gradi-ents. Some evidence suggests that AGWP may vary between regions and speci fically that Asian forests haveparticularly high AGWP. However, comparisons across biogeog raphic regions using standard ized methodsare lacking, limiting our assessment of pan-tropical variation in AGWP and potential causes.2. We sampled AGWP in NW Amazon (17 long-term forest plots) and N Borneo (11 plots), bothwith abundant year-r ound precipitation. Within each region, forests growing on a broad range ofedaphic conditions were sampled using standardiz ed soil and forest measurement techniques.3. Plot-level AGWP was 49{\%} greater in Borneo than in Amazonia (9.73  0.56 vs. 6.53  0.34 Mg drymass ha1a1, respective ly; regi onal me an  1 SE). AGWP was positively associated with soil fertility(PCA axes, sum of bases and total P). After controlling for the edaphic environment, AGWP remained signifi-cantly higher in Bornean plots. Differences in AGWP were largely attributable to differing height –diameterallometry in the two regions and the abundance of large trees in Borneo. This may be explained, in part, bythe greater solar radiation in Borneo compared with NW Amazonia.4. Trees belonging to the dominant SE Asian family, Dipterocarpacea e, gained woody biomass faster thanotherwise equivalent, neighbouring non-dipterocarps, implying that the exceptional production of Borneanforests may be driven by floristic elements. This dominant SE Asian family may partition biomass differentlyor be more efficient at harvesting resources and in converting them to woody biomass.5. Synthesis. N Bornean forests have much greater AGWP rates than those in NW Amazon when soil condi-tions and rainfall are controlled for. Greater resource availability and the highly productive dipterocarps may, incombination, explain why Asian forests produce wood half as fast again as comparable forests in the Amazon.Our results also suggest that taxonomic groups differ in their fundamental ability to capture carbon and that dif-ferent tropical regions may therefore have different carbon uptake capacities due to biogeographic history.",
keywords = "Amazon, Asia, Carbon, Dipterocarpaceae, Dynamics, Growth, Plant-soil interactions, Productivity, Soil nutrients, Tropical forest",
author = "Lindsay Banin and Lewis, {Simon L.} and Gabriela Lopez-Gonzalez and Baker, {Timothy R.} and Quesada, {Carlos A.} and Chao, {Kuo Jung} and Burslem, {David F R P} and Reuben Nilus and {Abu Salim}, Kamariah and Keeling, {Helen C.} and Sylvester Tan and Davies, {Stuart J.} and {Monteagudo Mendoza}, Abel and Rodolfo V{\'a}squez and Jon Lloyd and Neill, {David A.} and Nigel Pitman and Phillips, {Oliver L.}",
note = "This work was supported by the RAINFOR network, the AMAZONICA project and funding from NERC and the Gordon and Betty Moore Foundation.L.B. was supported by a NERC studentship with additional funding from Henrietta Hutton Grant (RGS-IBG) and Dudley Stamp Award (Royal Society).S.L.L. was supported by a Royal Society University Research Fellowship.O.L.P. and S.L.L. were supported by a European Research Council Advanced Grant and O.L.P. by a Royal Society Wolfson Research Merit Award. For help in collecting data, we thank J.H. Ovalle, M.M. Solorzano and Antonio Pe~naCruz (Peru); R. Sukri and M. Salleh A. B. (Brunei); C. Maycock (Sabah); and L. Chong, R. Shutine and L. K. Kho (Sarawak); for logistical aid and access to the forest plots of Lambir Hills National Park, Sarawak, Malaysia, we thankthe Sarawak Forestry Corporation, Malaysia, the Center for Tropical Forest Sci-ence – Arnold Arboretum Asia Program of the Smithsonian Tropical ResearchInstitute and Harvard University, USA, and their funding agencies. Additionalthanks go to the Economic Planning Unit, Malaysia, for granting L.B. access toconduct research and Rachel Gasior, Martin Gilpin and David Ashley for laboratory assistance. We thank Patrick Meir, Stephen Sitch, Alan Grainger, Geertjevan der Heijden, Ron Smith, Joe Wright and an anonymous reviewer for their helpful comments on earlier versions of the manuscript.",
year = "2014",
month = "7",
doi = "10.1111/1365-2745.12263",
language = "English",
volume = "102",
pages = "1025--1037",
journal = "Journal of Ecology",
issn = "0022-0477",
publisher = "Wiley/Blackwell (10.1111)",
number = "4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Tropical forest wood production

T2 - A cross-continental comparison

AU - Banin, Lindsay

AU - Lewis, Simon L.

AU - Lopez-Gonzalez, Gabriela

AU - Baker, Timothy R.

AU - Quesada, Carlos A.

AU - Chao, Kuo Jung

AU - Burslem, David F R P

AU - Nilus, Reuben

AU - Abu Salim, Kamariah

AU - Keeling, Helen C.

AU - Tan, Sylvester

AU - Davies, Stuart J.

AU - Monteagudo Mendoza, Abel

AU - Vásquez, Rodolfo

AU - Lloyd, Jon

AU - Neill, David A.

AU - Pitman, Nigel

AU - Phillips, Oliver L.

N1 - This work was supported by the RAINFOR network, the AMAZONICA project and funding from NERC and the Gordon and Betty Moore Foundation.L.B. was supported by a NERC studentship with additional funding from Henrietta Hutton Grant (RGS-IBG) and Dudley Stamp Award (Royal Society).S.L.L. was supported by a Royal Society University Research Fellowship.O.L.P. and S.L.L. were supported by a European Research Council Advanced Grant and O.L.P. by a Royal Society Wolfson Research Merit Award. For help in collecting data, we thank J.H. Ovalle, M.M. Solorzano and Antonio Pe~naCruz (Peru); R. Sukri and M. Salleh A. B. (Brunei); C. Maycock (Sabah); and L. Chong, R. Shutine and L. K. Kho (Sarawak); for logistical aid and access to the forest plots of Lambir Hills National Park, Sarawak, Malaysia, we thankthe Sarawak Forestry Corporation, Malaysia, the Center for Tropical Forest Sci-ence – Arnold Arboretum Asia Program of the Smithsonian Tropical ResearchInstitute and Harvard University, USA, and their funding agencies. Additionalthanks go to the Economic Planning Unit, Malaysia, for granting L.B. access toconduct research and Rachel Gasior, Martin Gilpin and David Ashley for laboratory assistance. We thank Patrick Meir, Stephen Sitch, Alan Grainger, Geertjevan der Heijden, Ron Smith, Joe Wright and an anonymous reviewer for their helpful comments on earlier versions of the manuscript.

PY - 2014/7

Y1 - 2014/7

N2 - 1. Tropical forest above-ground wood production (AGWP) varies substantially along environmental gradi-ents. Some evidence suggests that AGWP may vary between regions and speci fically that Asian forests haveparticularly high AGWP. However, comparisons across biogeog raphic regions using standard ized methodsare lacking, limiting our assessment of pan-tropical variation in AGWP and potential causes.2. We sampled AGWP in NW Amazon (17 long-term forest plots) and N Borneo (11 plots), bothwith abundant year-r ound precipitation. Within each region, forests growing on a broad range ofedaphic conditions were sampled using standardiz ed soil and forest measurement techniques.3. Plot-level AGWP was 49% greater in Borneo than in Amazonia (9.73  0.56 vs. 6.53  0.34 Mg drymass ha1a1, respective ly; regi onal me an  1 SE). AGWP was positively associated with soil fertility(PCA axes, sum of bases and total P). After controlling for the edaphic environment, AGWP remained signifi-cantly higher in Bornean plots. Differences in AGWP were largely attributable to differing height –diameterallometry in the two regions and the abundance of large trees in Borneo. This may be explained, in part, bythe greater solar radiation in Borneo compared with NW Amazonia.4. Trees belonging to the dominant SE Asian family, Dipterocarpacea e, gained woody biomass faster thanotherwise equivalent, neighbouring non-dipterocarps, implying that the exceptional production of Borneanforests may be driven by floristic elements. This dominant SE Asian family may partition biomass differentlyor be more efficient at harvesting resources and in converting them to woody biomass.5. Synthesis. N Bornean forests have much greater AGWP rates than those in NW Amazon when soil condi-tions and rainfall are controlled for. Greater resource availability and the highly productive dipterocarps may, incombination, explain why Asian forests produce wood half as fast again as comparable forests in the Amazon.Our results also suggest that taxonomic groups differ in their fundamental ability to capture carbon and that dif-ferent tropical regions may therefore have different carbon uptake capacities due to biogeographic history.

AB - 1. Tropical forest above-ground wood production (AGWP) varies substantially along environmental gradi-ents. Some evidence suggests that AGWP may vary between regions and speci fically that Asian forests haveparticularly high AGWP. However, comparisons across biogeog raphic regions using standard ized methodsare lacking, limiting our assessment of pan-tropical variation in AGWP and potential causes.2. We sampled AGWP in NW Amazon (17 long-term forest plots) and N Borneo (11 plots), bothwith abundant year-r ound precipitation. Within each region, forests growing on a broad range ofedaphic conditions were sampled using standardiz ed soil and forest measurement techniques.3. Plot-level AGWP was 49% greater in Borneo than in Amazonia (9.73  0.56 vs. 6.53  0.34 Mg drymass ha1a1, respective ly; regi onal me an  1 SE). AGWP was positively associated with soil fertility(PCA axes, sum of bases and total P). After controlling for the edaphic environment, AGWP remained signifi-cantly higher in Bornean plots. Differences in AGWP were largely attributable to differing height –diameterallometry in the two regions and the abundance of large trees in Borneo. This may be explained, in part, bythe greater solar radiation in Borneo compared with NW Amazonia.4. Trees belonging to the dominant SE Asian family, Dipterocarpacea e, gained woody biomass faster thanotherwise equivalent, neighbouring non-dipterocarps, implying that the exceptional production of Borneanforests may be driven by floristic elements. This dominant SE Asian family may partition biomass differentlyor be more efficient at harvesting resources and in converting them to woody biomass.5. Synthesis. N Bornean forests have much greater AGWP rates than those in NW Amazon when soil condi-tions and rainfall are controlled for. Greater resource availability and the highly productive dipterocarps may, incombination, explain why Asian forests produce wood half as fast again as comparable forests in the Amazon.Our results also suggest that taxonomic groups differ in their fundamental ability to capture carbon and that dif-ferent tropical regions may therefore have different carbon uptake capacities due to biogeographic history.

KW - Amazon

KW - Asia

KW - Carbon

KW - Dipterocarpaceae

KW - Dynamics

KW - Growth

KW - Plant-soil interactions

KW - Productivity

KW - Soil nutrients

KW - Tropical forest

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84902985562&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1111/1365-2745.12263

DO - 10.1111/1365-2745.12263

M3 - Article

VL - 102

SP - 1025

EP - 1037

JO - Journal of Ecology

JF - Journal of Ecology

SN - 0022-0477

IS - 4

ER -