Trumping Assessments and the Aristotelian Future

Sebastiano Moruzzi, Crispin Wright

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

6 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

In the paper we argue that truth-relativism is potentially hostage to a problem of exhibiting witnesses of its own truth. The problem for the relativist stems from acceptance of a trumping principle according to which there is a dependency
between ascriptions of truth of an utterance and ascriptions of truth to other ascriptions of truth of that utterance. We argue that such a dependency indeed holds in the case of future contingents and the case of epistemic modals and that, consequently, the relativist about these domains cannot exhibit witnesses to his relativism. In the appendix we provide some results on the relation between trumping and multi-order relativism.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)309-331
Number of pages23
JournalSynthese
Volume166
Issue number2
Early online date7 May 2008
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Jan 2009

Fingerprint

relativism
witness
acceptance
Aristotelian
Relativism
Relativist
Witness
Utterance

Keywords

  • truth-relativism
  • future contingents
  • epistemic modals
  • multi-order relativism
  • trumping

Cite this

Trumping Assessments and the Aristotelian Future. / Moruzzi, Sebastiano; Wright, Crispin.

In: Synthese, Vol. 166, No. 2, 01.2009, p. 309-331.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Moruzzi, S & Wright, C 2009, 'Trumping Assessments and the Aristotelian Future', Synthese, vol. 166, no. 2, pp. 309-331. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11229-007-9282-6
Moruzzi, Sebastiano ; Wright, Crispin. / Trumping Assessments and the Aristotelian Future. In: Synthese. 2009 ; Vol. 166, No. 2. pp. 309-331.
@article{9e6e3f4c93b54eb894601e3a32602e9d,
title = "Trumping Assessments and the Aristotelian Future",
abstract = "In the paper we argue that truth-relativism is potentially hostage to a problem of exhibiting witnesses of its own truth. The problem for the relativist stems from acceptance of a trumping principle according to which there is a dependency between ascriptions of truth of an utterance and ascriptions of truth to other ascriptions of truth of that utterance. We argue that such a dependency indeed holds in the case of future contingents and the case of epistemic modals and that, consequently, the relativist about these domains cannot exhibit witnesses to his relativism. In the appendix we provide some results on the relation between trumping and multi-order relativism.",
keywords = "truth-relativism, future contingents, epistemic modals, multi-order relativism, trumping",
author = "Sebastiano Moruzzi and Crispin Wright",
year = "2009",
month = "1",
doi = "10.1007/s11229-007-9282-6",
language = "English",
volume = "166",
pages = "309--331",
journal = "Synthese",
issn = "0039-7857",
publisher = "Springer Netherlands",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Trumping Assessments and the Aristotelian Future

AU - Moruzzi, Sebastiano

AU - Wright, Crispin

PY - 2009/1

Y1 - 2009/1

N2 - In the paper we argue that truth-relativism is potentially hostage to a problem of exhibiting witnesses of its own truth. The problem for the relativist stems from acceptance of a trumping principle according to which there is a dependency between ascriptions of truth of an utterance and ascriptions of truth to other ascriptions of truth of that utterance. We argue that such a dependency indeed holds in the case of future contingents and the case of epistemic modals and that, consequently, the relativist about these domains cannot exhibit witnesses to his relativism. In the appendix we provide some results on the relation between trumping and multi-order relativism.

AB - In the paper we argue that truth-relativism is potentially hostage to a problem of exhibiting witnesses of its own truth. The problem for the relativist stems from acceptance of a trumping principle according to which there is a dependency between ascriptions of truth of an utterance and ascriptions of truth to other ascriptions of truth of that utterance. We argue that such a dependency indeed holds in the case of future contingents and the case of epistemic modals and that, consequently, the relativist about these domains cannot exhibit witnesses to his relativism. In the appendix we provide some results on the relation between trumping and multi-order relativism.

KW - truth-relativism

KW - future contingents

KW - epistemic modals

KW - multi-order relativism

KW - trumping

U2 - 10.1007/s11229-007-9282-6

DO - 10.1007/s11229-007-9282-6

M3 - Article

VL - 166

SP - 309

EP - 331

JO - Synthese

JF - Synthese

SN - 0039-7857

IS - 2

ER -