Unity or diversity?

Recent developments in the organisation of out of hours general medical services in Scotland

H. Thomson, C. O'Donnell, David James Heaney, K. Moffat, S. Ross, Anthony Scott, N. Drummond

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

1 Citation (Scopus)

Abstract

The objective of this paper is to describe variations in the different models of out of hours general medical services and identify explanations for variation and the possible influence on patient satisfaction and service costs. A cross-sectional survey of all models of out of hours care was undertaken, including co-operatives, deputizing services, practice rotas and rural general practitioners doing their own cover. Fifteen sites were chosen representing 10 models of care, for more detailed case study; 65 semistructured interviews with key informants were conducted within the case study sites. A postal patient satisfaction questionnaire and an economic analysis were also carried out. Out of hours organizations have developed in response to a complex mix of the population served, geography, resources available and political expediency, leading to considerable structural heterogeneity, even within co-operatives. There was little evidence of formal integration with other services. Only the largest co-operatives showed any evidence of utilizing guidelines/protocols or of providing formal staff training. There were clear differences in the structure of out of hours care in urban and rural areas. Increasing the use of centralized call handling and triage will not address the needs of rural GPs, who would still be required to be available for work. Neither patient satisfaction nor costs varied bymodel of service provision. The English out of hours reviewhas outlined an integrated model of service provision with consistent standards within an accountability framework. It would appear that only the largest organizations will be in a position to address these standards and that they are likely to be inappropriate to the needs of GPs in rural areas.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)193-205
Number of pages12
JournalPrimary Health Care Research and Development
Volume4
Issue number3
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2003

Fingerprint

medical services
rural area
general practitioner
costs
evidence
urban area
geography
staff
responsibility
questionnaire
interview
resources
economics

Keywords

  • out of hours care
  • patient satisfaction
  • service delivery
  • service organization

Cite this

Unity or diversity? Recent developments in the organisation of out of hours general medical services in Scotland. / Thomson, H.; O'Donnell, C.; Heaney, David James; Moffat, K.; Ross, S.; Scott, Anthony; Drummond, N.

In: Primary Health Care Research and Development, Vol. 4, No. 3, 2003, p. 193-205.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Thomson, H. ; O'Donnell, C. ; Heaney, David James ; Moffat, K. ; Ross, S. ; Scott, Anthony ; Drummond, N. / Unity or diversity? Recent developments in the organisation of out of hours general medical services in Scotland. In: Primary Health Care Research and Development. 2003 ; Vol. 4, No. 3. pp. 193-205.
@article{f8a12bdba2a740daa631dfbb82997bb2,
title = "Unity or diversity?: Recent developments in the organisation of out of hours general medical services in Scotland",
abstract = "The objective of this paper is to describe variations in the different models of out of hours general medical services and identify explanations for variation and the possible influence on patient satisfaction and service costs. A cross-sectional survey of all models of out of hours care was undertaken, including co-operatives, deputizing services, practice rotas and rural general practitioners doing their own cover. Fifteen sites were chosen representing 10 models of care, for more detailed case study; 65 semistructured interviews with key informants were conducted within the case study sites. A postal patient satisfaction questionnaire and an economic analysis were also carried out. Out of hours organizations have developed in response to a complex mix of the population served, geography, resources available and political expediency, leading to considerable structural heterogeneity, even within co-operatives. There was little evidence of formal integration with other services. Only the largest co-operatives showed any evidence of utilizing guidelines/protocols or of providing formal staff training. There were clear differences in the structure of out of hours care in urban and rural areas. Increasing the use of centralized call handling and triage will not address the needs of rural GPs, who would still be required to be available for work. Neither patient satisfaction nor costs varied bymodel of service provision. The English out of hours reviewhas outlined an integrated model of service provision with consistent standards within an accountability framework. It would appear that only the largest organizations will be in a position to address these standards and that they are likely to be inappropriate to the needs of GPs in rural areas.",
keywords = "out of hours care, patient satisfaction, service delivery, service organization",
author = "H. Thomson and C. O'Donnell and Heaney, {David James} and K. Moffat and S. Ross and Anthony Scott and N. Drummond",
year = "2003",
doi = "10.1191/1463423603pc150oa",
language = "English",
volume = "4",
pages = "193--205",
journal = "Primary Health Care Research and Development",
issn = "1463-4236",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Unity or diversity?

T2 - Recent developments in the organisation of out of hours general medical services in Scotland

AU - Thomson, H.

AU - O'Donnell, C.

AU - Heaney, David James

AU - Moffat, K.

AU - Ross, S.

AU - Scott, Anthony

AU - Drummond, N.

PY - 2003

Y1 - 2003

N2 - The objective of this paper is to describe variations in the different models of out of hours general medical services and identify explanations for variation and the possible influence on patient satisfaction and service costs. A cross-sectional survey of all models of out of hours care was undertaken, including co-operatives, deputizing services, practice rotas and rural general practitioners doing their own cover. Fifteen sites were chosen representing 10 models of care, for more detailed case study; 65 semistructured interviews with key informants were conducted within the case study sites. A postal patient satisfaction questionnaire and an economic analysis were also carried out. Out of hours organizations have developed in response to a complex mix of the population served, geography, resources available and political expediency, leading to considerable structural heterogeneity, even within co-operatives. There was little evidence of formal integration with other services. Only the largest co-operatives showed any evidence of utilizing guidelines/protocols or of providing formal staff training. There were clear differences in the structure of out of hours care in urban and rural areas. Increasing the use of centralized call handling and triage will not address the needs of rural GPs, who would still be required to be available for work. Neither patient satisfaction nor costs varied bymodel of service provision. The English out of hours reviewhas outlined an integrated model of service provision with consistent standards within an accountability framework. It would appear that only the largest organizations will be in a position to address these standards and that they are likely to be inappropriate to the needs of GPs in rural areas.

AB - The objective of this paper is to describe variations in the different models of out of hours general medical services and identify explanations for variation and the possible influence on patient satisfaction and service costs. A cross-sectional survey of all models of out of hours care was undertaken, including co-operatives, deputizing services, practice rotas and rural general practitioners doing their own cover. Fifteen sites were chosen representing 10 models of care, for more detailed case study; 65 semistructured interviews with key informants were conducted within the case study sites. A postal patient satisfaction questionnaire and an economic analysis were also carried out. Out of hours organizations have developed in response to a complex mix of the population served, geography, resources available and political expediency, leading to considerable structural heterogeneity, even within co-operatives. There was little evidence of formal integration with other services. Only the largest co-operatives showed any evidence of utilizing guidelines/protocols or of providing formal staff training. There were clear differences in the structure of out of hours care in urban and rural areas. Increasing the use of centralized call handling and triage will not address the needs of rural GPs, who would still be required to be available for work. Neither patient satisfaction nor costs varied bymodel of service provision. The English out of hours reviewhas outlined an integrated model of service provision with consistent standards within an accountability framework. It would appear that only the largest organizations will be in a position to address these standards and that they are likely to be inappropriate to the needs of GPs in rural areas.

KW - out of hours care

KW - patient satisfaction

KW - service delivery

KW - service organization

U2 - 10.1191/1463423603pc150oa

DO - 10.1191/1463423603pc150oa

M3 - Article

VL - 4

SP - 193

EP - 205

JO - Primary Health Care Research and Development

JF - Primary Health Care Research and Development

SN - 1463-4236

IS - 3

ER -