Using stable isotopes to estimate travel times in a data-sparse arctic catchment

challenges and possible solutions

Doerthe Tetzlaff, Thea Piovano, Pertti Ala-Aho, Aaron Smith, Sean Carey, Philip Marsh, Philip Wookey, Lorna E. Street, Chris Soulsby

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

4 Citations (Scopus)
4 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Use of isotopes to quantify the temporal dynamics of the transformation of precipitation into runoff has revealed fundamental new insights into catchment flow paths and mixing processes that influence biogeochemical transport. However, catchments underlain by permafrost have received little attention in isotope based studies, despite their global importance in terms of rapid environmental change. These high-latitude regions offer limited access for data collection during critical periods (e.g. early phases of snowmelt). Additionally, spatio-temporal variable freeze-thaw cycles, together with the development of an active layer, have a time variant influence on catchment hydrology. All of these characteristics make the application of traditional transit time estimation approaches challenging. We describe an isotope-based study undertaken to provide a preliminary assessment of travel times at Siksik Creek in the western Canadian Arctic. We adopted a model-data fusion approach to estimate the volumes and isotopic characteristics of snowpack and meltwater. Using samples collected in the spring/summer we characterise the isotopic composition of summer rainfall, melt from snow, soil water and stream water. In addition, soil moisture dynamics and the temporal evolution of the active layer profile were monitored. First approximations of transit times were estimated for soil and stream water compositions using lumped convolution integral models and temporally variable inputs including snowmelt, ice thaw, and summer rainfall. Comparing transit time estimates using a variety of inputs revealed that transit time was best estimated using all available inflows (i.e. snowmelt, soil ice thaw, and rainfall). Early spring transit times were short, dominated by snowmelt and soil ice thaw and limited catchment storage when soils are predominantly frozen. However, significant and increasing mixing with water in the active layer during the summer resulted in more damped steam water variation, and longer mean travel times (~1.5 years). The study has also highlighted key data needs to better constrain travel time estimates in permafrost catchments.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)1936-1952
Number of pages17
JournalHydrological Processes
Volume32
Issue number12
Early online date29 May 2018
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 15 Jun 2018

Fingerprint

travel time
stable isotope
catchment
snowmelt
active layer
summer
isotope
ice
permafrost
rainfall
soil
water
freeze-thaw cycle
snowpack
temporal evolution
meltwater
environmental change
hydrology
inflow
isotopic composition

Keywords

  • arctic headwaters
  • active layer
  • isotopes
  • transit times
  • permafrost

Cite this

Using stable isotopes to estimate travel times in a data-sparse arctic catchment : challenges and possible solutions. / Tetzlaff, Doerthe; Piovano, Thea; Ala-Aho, Pertti; Smith, Aaron; Carey, Sean; Marsh, Philip ; Wookey, Philip; Street, Lorna E.; Soulsby, Chris.

In: Hydrological Processes, Vol. 32, No. 12, 15.06.2018, p. 1936-1952.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Tetzlaff, Doerthe ; Piovano, Thea ; Ala-Aho, Pertti ; Smith, Aaron ; Carey, Sean ; Marsh, Philip ; Wookey, Philip ; Street, Lorna E. ; Soulsby, Chris. / Using stable isotopes to estimate travel times in a data-sparse arctic catchment : challenges and possible solutions. In: Hydrological Processes. 2018 ; Vol. 32, No. 12. pp. 1936-1952.
@article{92c070c67d0141cbb3f0f34613da3632,
title = "Using stable isotopes to estimate travel times in a data-sparse arctic catchment: challenges and possible solutions",
abstract = "Use of isotopes to quantify the temporal dynamics of the transformation of precipitation into runoff has revealed fundamental new insights into catchment flow paths and mixing processes that influence biogeochemical transport. However, catchments underlain by permafrost have received little attention in isotope based studies, despite their global importance in terms of rapid environmental change. These high-latitude regions offer limited access for data collection during critical periods (e.g. early phases of snowmelt). Additionally, spatio-temporal variable freeze-thaw cycles, together with the development of an active layer, have a time variant influence on catchment hydrology. All of these characteristics make the application of traditional transit time estimation approaches challenging. We describe an isotope-based study undertaken to provide a preliminary assessment of travel times at Siksik Creek in the western Canadian Arctic. We adopted a model-data fusion approach to estimate the volumes and isotopic characteristics of snowpack and meltwater. Using samples collected in the spring/summer we characterise the isotopic composition of summer rainfall, melt from snow, soil water and stream water. In addition, soil moisture dynamics and the temporal evolution of the active layer profile were monitored. First approximations of transit times were estimated for soil and stream water compositions using lumped convolution integral models and temporally variable inputs including snowmelt, ice thaw, and summer rainfall. Comparing transit time estimates using a variety of inputs revealed that transit time was best estimated using all available inflows (i.e. snowmelt, soil ice thaw, and rainfall). Early spring transit times were short, dominated by snowmelt and soil ice thaw and limited catchment storage when soils are predominantly frozen. However, significant and increasing mixing with water in the active layer during the summer resulted in more damped steam water variation, and longer mean travel times (~1.5 years). The study has also highlighted key data needs to better constrain travel time estimates in permafrost catchments.",
keywords = "arctic headwaters, active layer, isotopes, transit times, permafrost",
author = "Doerthe Tetzlaff and Thea Piovano and Pertti Ala-Aho and Aaron Smith and Sean Carey and Philip Marsh and Philip Wookey and Street, {Lorna E.} and Chris Soulsby",
note = "We thank the Natural Environment Research Council NERC (HYDRA project NE/K000268/1 and NE/K000284/1) and the European Research Council ERC for funding (VeWa project GA 335910). We also are grateful to Dr Jason Lessels and HYDRA team members for field work and sample collection. We further thank Dr. Jonathan Dick for running the isotope analysis.",
year = "2018",
month = "6",
day = "15",
doi = "10.1002/hyp.13146",
language = "English",
volume = "32",
pages = "1936--1952",
journal = "Hydrological Processes",
issn = "0885-6087",
publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",
number = "12",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Using stable isotopes to estimate travel times in a data-sparse arctic catchment

T2 - challenges and possible solutions

AU - Tetzlaff, Doerthe

AU - Piovano, Thea

AU - Ala-Aho, Pertti

AU - Smith, Aaron

AU - Carey, Sean

AU - Marsh, Philip

AU - Wookey, Philip

AU - Street, Lorna E.

AU - Soulsby, Chris

N1 - We thank the Natural Environment Research Council NERC (HYDRA project NE/K000268/1 and NE/K000284/1) and the European Research Council ERC for funding (VeWa project GA 335910). We also are grateful to Dr Jason Lessels and HYDRA team members for field work and sample collection. We further thank Dr. Jonathan Dick for running the isotope analysis.

PY - 2018/6/15

Y1 - 2018/6/15

N2 - Use of isotopes to quantify the temporal dynamics of the transformation of precipitation into runoff has revealed fundamental new insights into catchment flow paths and mixing processes that influence biogeochemical transport. However, catchments underlain by permafrost have received little attention in isotope based studies, despite their global importance in terms of rapid environmental change. These high-latitude regions offer limited access for data collection during critical periods (e.g. early phases of snowmelt). Additionally, spatio-temporal variable freeze-thaw cycles, together with the development of an active layer, have a time variant influence on catchment hydrology. All of these characteristics make the application of traditional transit time estimation approaches challenging. We describe an isotope-based study undertaken to provide a preliminary assessment of travel times at Siksik Creek in the western Canadian Arctic. We adopted a model-data fusion approach to estimate the volumes and isotopic characteristics of snowpack and meltwater. Using samples collected in the spring/summer we characterise the isotopic composition of summer rainfall, melt from snow, soil water and stream water. In addition, soil moisture dynamics and the temporal evolution of the active layer profile were monitored. First approximations of transit times were estimated for soil and stream water compositions using lumped convolution integral models and temporally variable inputs including snowmelt, ice thaw, and summer rainfall. Comparing transit time estimates using a variety of inputs revealed that transit time was best estimated using all available inflows (i.e. snowmelt, soil ice thaw, and rainfall). Early spring transit times were short, dominated by snowmelt and soil ice thaw and limited catchment storage when soils are predominantly frozen. However, significant and increasing mixing with water in the active layer during the summer resulted in more damped steam water variation, and longer mean travel times (~1.5 years). The study has also highlighted key data needs to better constrain travel time estimates in permafrost catchments.

AB - Use of isotopes to quantify the temporal dynamics of the transformation of precipitation into runoff has revealed fundamental new insights into catchment flow paths and mixing processes that influence biogeochemical transport. However, catchments underlain by permafrost have received little attention in isotope based studies, despite their global importance in terms of rapid environmental change. These high-latitude regions offer limited access for data collection during critical periods (e.g. early phases of snowmelt). Additionally, spatio-temporal variable freeze-thaw cycles, together with the development of an active layer, have a time variant influence on catchment hydrology. All of these characteristics make the application of traditional transit time estimation approaches challenging. We describe an isotope-based study undertaken to provide a preliminary assessment of travel times at Siksik Creek in the western Canadian Arctic. We adopted a model-data fusion approach to estimate the volumes and isotopic characteristics of snowpack and meltwater. Using samples collected in the spring/summer we characterise the isotopic composition of summer rainfall, melt from snow, soil water and stream water. In addition, soil moisture dynamics and the temporal evolution of the active layer profile were monitored. First approximations of transit times were estimated for soil and stream water compositions using lumped convolution integral models and temporally variable inputs including snowmelt, ice thaw, and summer rainfall. Comparing transit time estimates using a variety of inputs revealed that transit time was best estimated using all available inflows (i.e. snowmelt, soil ice thaw, and rainfall). Early spring transit times were short, dominated by snowmelt and soil ice thaw and limited catchment storage when soils are predominantly frozen. However, significant and increasing mixing with water in the active layer during the summer resulted in more damped steam water variation, and longer mean travel times (~1.5 years). The study has also highlighted key data needs to better constrain travel time estimates in permafrost catchments.

KW - arctic headwaters

KW - active layer

KW - isotopes

KW - transit times

KW - permafrost

U2 - 10.1002/hyp.13146

DO - 10.1002/hyp.13146

M3 - Article

VL - 32

SP - 1936

EP - 1952

JO - Hydrological Processes

JF - Hydrological Processes

SN - 0885-6087

IS - 12

ER -