Value of severity scales in predicting mortality from community-acquired pneumonia: systematic review and meta-analysis

Yoon K Loke, Chun Shing Kwok, Alagaratnam Niruban, Phyo K Myint

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

121 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

BACKGROUND: Several scoring systems have been used to predict mortality in patients with community-acquired pneumonia. The properties of commonly used risk stratification scales were systematically reviewed.

METHODS: MEDLINE and EMBASE (January 1999-October 2009) were searched for prospective studies that reported mortality at 4-8 weeks in patients with radiographically-confirmed community-acquired pneumonia. The search focused on the Pneumonia Severity Index (PSI) and the three main iterations of the CURB (confusion, urea nitrogen, respiratory rate, blood pressure) scale (CURB-65, CURB, CRB-65), and test performance was evaluated based on 'higher risk' categories as follows: PSI class IV/V, CURB-65 (score ≥ 3), CURB (score ≥ 2) and CRB-65 (score ≥ 2). Random effects meta-analysis was used to generate summary statistics of test performance and receiver operating characteristic curves were used for predicting mortality.

RESULTS: 402 articles were screened and 23 studies involving 22,753 participants (average mortality 7.4%) were retrieved. The respective diagnostic odds ratios for mortality were 10.77 (PSI), 6.40 (CURB-65), 5.97 (CRB-65) and 5.75 (CURB). Overall, PSI had the highest sensitivity and lowest specificity for mortality, CRB-65 was the most specific (but least sensitive) test and CURB-65/CURB were between the two. Negative predictive values for mortality were similar among the tests, ranging from 0.94 (CRB-65) to 0.98 (PSI), whereas positive predictive values ranged from 0.14 (PSI) to 0.28 (CRB-65).

CONCLUSIONS: The current risk stratification scales (PSI, CURB-65, CRB-65 and CURB) have different strengths and weaknesses. All four scales had good negative predictive values for mortality in populations with a low prevalence of death but were less useful with regard to positive predictive values.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)884-890
Number of pages7
JournalThorax
Volume65
Issue number10
Early online date20 Aug 2010
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Oct 2010

Fingerprint

Meta-Analysis
Pneumonia
Mortality
Respiratory Rate
MEDLINE
ROC Curve
Urea
Nitrogen
Odds Ratio
Prospective Studies
Blood Pressure
Sensitivity and Specificity
Population

Keywords

  • community-acquired infections
  • humans
  • pneumonia
  • predictive value of tests
  • severity of illness index

Cite this

Value of severity scales in predicting mortality from community-acquired pneumonia : systematic review and meta-analysis. / Loke, Yoon K; Kwok, Chun Shing; Niruban, Alagaratnam; Myint, Phyo K.

In: Thorax, Vol. 65, No. 10, 10.2010, p. 884-890.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Loke, Yoon K ; Kwok, Chun Shing ; Niruban, Alagaratnam ; Myint, Phyo K. / Value of severity scales in predicting mortality from community-acquired pneumonia : systematic review and meta-analysis. In: Thorax. 2010 ; Vol. 65, No. 10. pp. 884-890.
@article{21c5e7dfe24b446b9b490493781ba0eb,
title = "Value of severity scales in predicting mortality from community-acquired pneumonia: systematic review and meta-analysis",
abstract = "BACKGROUND: Several scoring systems have been used to predict mortality in patients with community-acquired pneumonia. The properties of commonly used risk stratification scales were systematically reviewed.METHODS: MEDLINE and EMBASE (January 1999-October 2009) were searched for prospective studies that reported mortality at 4-8 weeks in patients with radiographically-confirmed community-acquired pneumonia. The search focused on the Pneumonia Severity Index (PSI) and the three main iterations of the CURB (confusion, urea nitrogen, respiratory rate, blood pressure) scale (CURB-65, CURB, CRB-65), and test performance was evaluated based on 'higher risk' categories as follows: PSI class IV/V, CURB-65 (score ≥ 3), CURB (score ≥ 2) and CRB-65 (score ≥ 2). Random effects meta-analysis was used to generate summary statistics of test performance and receiver operating characteristic curves were used for predicting mortality.RESULTS: 402 articles were screened and 23 studies involving 22,753 participants (average mortality 7.4{\%}) were retrieved. The respective diagnostic odds ratios for mortality were 10.77 (PSI), 6.40 (CURB-65), 5.97 (CRB-65) and 5.75 (CURB). Overall, PSI had the highest sensitivity and lowest specificity for mortality, CRB-65 was the most specific (but least sensitive) test and CURB-65/CURB were between the two. Negative predictive values for mortality were similar among the tests, ranging from 0.94 (CRB-65) to 0.98 (PSI), whereas positive predictive values ranged from 0.14 (PSI) to 0.28 (CRB-65).CONCLUSIONS: The current risk stratification scales (PSI, CURB-65, CRB-65 and CURB) have different strengths and weaknesses. All four scales had good negative predictive values for mortality in populations with a low prevalence of death but were less useful with regard to positive predictive values.",
keywords = "community-acquired infections, humans, pneumonia, predictive value of tests, severity of illness index",
author = "Loke, {Yoon K} and Kwok, {Chun Shing} and Alagaratnam Niruban and Myint, {Phyo K}",
year = "2010",
month = "10",
doi = "10.1136/thx.2009.134072",
language = "English",
volume = "65",
pages = "884--890",
journal = "Thorax",
issn = "0040-6376",
publisher = "BMJ Publishing Group Ltd",
number = "10",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Value of severity scales in predicting mortality from community-acquired pneumonia

T2 - systematic review and meta-analysis

AU - Loke, Yoon K

AU - Kwok, Chun Shing

AU - Niruban, Alagaratnam

AU - Myint, Phyo K

PY - 2010/10

Y1 - 2010/10

N2 - BACKGROUND: Several scoring systems have been used to predict mortality in patients with community-acquired pneumonia. The properties of commonly used risk stratification scales were systematically reviewed.METHODS: MEDLINE and EMBASE (January 1999-October 2009) were searched for prospective studies that reported mortality at 4-8 weeks in patients with radiographically-confirmed community-acquired pneumonia. The search focused on the Pneumonia Severity Index (PSI) and the three main iterations of the CURB (confusion, urea nitrogen, respiratory rate, blood pressure) scale (CURB-65, CURB, CRB-65), and test performance was evaluated based on 'higher risk' categories as follows: PSI class IV/V, CURB-65 (score ≥ 3), CURB (score ≥ 2) and CRB-65 (score ≥ 2). Random effects meta-analysis was used to generate summary statistics of test performance and receiver operating characteristic curves were used for predicting mortality.RESULTS: 402 articles were screened and 23 studies involving 22,753 participants (average mortality 7.4%) were retrieved. The respective diagnostic odds ratios for mortality were 10.77 (PSI), 6.40 (CURB-65), 5.97 (CRB-65) and 5.75 (CURB). Overall, PSI had the highest sensitivity and lowest specificity for mortality, CRB-65 was the most specific (but least sensitive) test and CURB-65/CURB were between the two. Negative predictive values for mortality were similar among the tests, ranging from 0.94 (CRB-65) to 0.98 (PSI), whereas positive predictive values ranged from 0.14 (PSI) to 0.28 (CRB-65).CONCLUSIONS: The current risk stratification scales (PSI, CURB-65, CRB-65 and CURB) have different strengths and weaknesses. All four scales had good negative predictive values for mortality in populations with a low prevalence of death but were less useful with regard to positive predictive values.

AB - BACKGROUND: Several scoring systems have been used to predict mortality in patients with community-acquired pneumonia. The properties of commonly used risk stratification scales were systematically reviewed.METHODS: MEDLINE and EMBASE (January 1999-October 2009) were searched for prospective studies that reported mortality at 4-8 weeks in patients with radiographically-confirmed community-acquired pneumonia. The search focused on the Pneumonia Severity Index (PSI) and the three main iterations of the CURB (confusion, urea nitrogen, respiratory rate, blood pressure) scale (CURB-65, CURB, CRB-65), and test performance was evaluated based on 'higher risk' categories as follows: PSI class IV/V, CURB-65 (score ≥ 3), CURB (score ≥ 2) and CRB-65 (score ≥ 2). Random effects meta-analysis was used to generate summary statistics of test performance and receiver operating characteristic curves were used for predicting mortality.RESULTS: 402 articles were screened and 23 studies involving 22,753 participants (average mortality 7.4%) were retrieved. The respective diagnostic odds ratios for mortality were 10.77 (PSI), 6.40 (CURB-65), 5.97 (CRB-65) and 5.75 (CURB). Overall, PSI had the highest sensitivity and lowest specificity for mortality, CRB-65 was the most specific (but least sensitive) test and CURB-65/CURB were between the two. Negative predictive values for mortality were similar among the tests, ranging from 0.94 (CRB-65) to 0.98 (PSI), whereas positive predictive values ranged from 0.14 (PSI) to 0.28 (CRB-65).CONCLUSIONS: The current risk stratification scales (PSI, CURB-65, CRB-65 and CURB) have different strengths and weaknesses. All four scales had good negative predictive values for mortality in populations with a low prevalence of death but were less useful with regard to positive predictive values.

KW - community-acquired infections

KW - humans

KW - pneumonia

KW - predictive value of tests

KW - severity of illness index

U2 - 10.1136/thx.2009.134072

DO - 10.1136/thx.2009.134072

M3 - Article

C2 - 20729235

VL - 65

SP - 884

EP - 890

JO - Thorax

JF - Thorax

SN - 0040-6376

IS - 10

ER -