Ways in which coherence is confirmation conducive

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

7 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Recent works in epistemology show that the claim that coherence is truth conducive – in the sense that, given suitable ceteris paribus conditions, more coherent sets of statements are always more probable – is dubious and possibly false. From this, it does not follows that coherence is a useless notion in epistemology and philosophy of science. Dietrich and Moretti (Philosophy of science 72(3): 403–424, 2005) have proposed a formal of account of how coherence is confirmation conducive—that is, of how the coherence of a set of statements facilitates the confirmation of such statements. This account is grounded in two confirmation transmission properties that are satisfied by some of the measures of coherence recently proposed in the literature. These properties explicate everyday and scientific uses of coherence. In his paper, I review the main findings of Dietrich and Moretti (2005) and define two evidence-gathering properties that are satisfied by the same measures of coherence and constitute further ways in which coherence is confirmation conducive. At least one of these properties vindicates important applications of the notion of coherence in everyday life and in science.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)309-319
Number of pages11
JournalSynthese
Volume157
Issue number3
Early online date25 Oct 2006
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Aug 2007

Fingerprint

philosophy of science
epistemology
coherence
everyday life
science
evidence
Philosophy of Science
Epistemology
literature
Everyday Life
Ceteris Paribus

Keywords

  • coherence
  • coherence measures
  • coherentism
  • confirmation
  • confirmation transmission
  • Dietrich
  • Fitelson
  • Moretti
  • Olsson
  • total evidence

Cite this

Ways in which coherence is confirmation conducive. / Moretti, Luca.

In: Synthese, Vol. 157, No. 3, 08.2007, p. 309-319.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Moretti, Luca. / Ways in which coherence is confirmation conducive. In: Synthese. 2007 ; Vol. 157, No. 3. pp. 309-319.
@article{2a8337fa54e04283acd28a5f51d5bfb2,
title = "Ways in which coherence is confirmation conducive",
abstract = "Recent works in epistemology show that the claim that coherence is truth conducive – in the sense that, given suitable ceteris paribus conditions, more coherent sets of statements are always more probable – is dubious and possibly false. From this, it does not follows that coherence is a useless notion in epistemology and philosophy of science. Dietrich and Moretti (Philosophy of science 72(3): 403–424, 2005) have proposed a formal of account of how coherence is confirmation conducive—that is, of how the coherence of a set of statements facilitates the confirmation of such statements. This account is grounded in two confirmation transmission properties that are satisfied by some of the measures of coherence recently proposed in the literature. These properties explicate everyday and scientific uses of coherence. In his paper, I review the main findings of Dietrich and Moretti (2005) and define two evidence-gathering properties that are satisfied by the same measures of coherence and constitute further ways in which coherence is confirmation conducive. At least one of these properties vindicates important applications of the notion of coherence in everyday life and in science.",
keywords = "coherence , coherence measures , coherentism , confirmation , confirmation transmission, Dietrich , Fitelson , Moretti , Olsson , total evidence",
author = "Luca Moretti",
year = "2007",
month = "8",
doi = "10.1007/s11229-006-9057-5",
language = "English",
volume = "157",
pages = "309--319",
journal = "Synthese",
issn = "0039-7857",
publisher = "Springer Netherlands",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Ways in which coherence is confirmation conducive

AU - Moretti, Luca

PY - 2007/8

Y1 - 2007/8

N2 - Recent works in epistemology show that the claim that coherence is truth conducive – in the sense that, given suitable ceteris paribus conditions, more coherent sets of statements are always more probable – is dubious and possibly false. From this, it does not follows that coherence is a useless notion in epistemology and philosophy of science. Dietrich and Moretti (Philosophy of science 72(3): 403–424, 2005) have proposed a formal of account of how coherence is confirmation conducive—that is, of how the coherence of a set of statements facilitates the confirmation of such statements. This account is grounded in two confirmation transmission properties that are satisfied by some of the measures of coherence recently proposed in the literature. These properties explicate everyday and scientific uses of coherence. In his paper, I review the main findings of Dietrich and Moretti (2005) and define two evidence-gathering properties that are satisfied by the same measures of coherence and constitute further ways in which coherence is confirmation conducive. At least one of these properties vindicates important applications of the notion of coherence in everyday life and in science.

AB - Recent works in epistemology show that the claim that coherence is truth conducive – in the sense that, given suitable ceteris paribus conditions, more coherent sets of statements are always more probable – is dubious and possibly false. From this, it does not follows that coherence is a useless notion in epistemology and philosophy of science. Dietrich and Moretti (Philosophy of science 72(3): 403–424, 2005) have proposed a formal of account of how coherence is confirmation conducive—that is, of how the coherence of a set of statements facilitates the confirmation of such statements. This account is grounded in two confirmation transmission properties that are satisfied by some of the measures of coherence recently proposed in the literature. These properties explicate everyday and scientific uses of coherence. In his paper, I review the main findings of Dietrich and Moretti (2005) and define two evidence-gathering properties that are satisfied by the same measures of coherence and constitute further ways in which coherence is confirmation conducive. At least one of these properties vindicates important applications of the notion of coherence in everyday life and in science.

KW - coherence

KW - coherence measures

KW - coherentism

KW - confirmation

KW - confirmation transmission

KW - Dietrich

KW - Fitelson

KW - Moretti

KW - Olsson

KW - total evidence

U2 - 10.1007/s11229-006-9057-5

DO - 10.1007/s11229-006-9057-5

M3 - Article

VL - 157

SP - 309

EP - 319

JO - Synthese

JF - Synthese

SN - 0039-7857

IS - 3

ER -