Western medical students' experiences on clinical electives in sub-Saharan Africa

Ben Kumwenda* (Corresponding Author), David Royan, Paige Ringsell, Jon Dowell

*Corresponding author for this work

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

14 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Context: Electives commonly represent a valued, enjoyed and formative part of medical training. However, there is little empirical evidence about students' preparedness, practices and perceptions of medical electives in resource-poor settings. Exploring what students do, why and under what circumstances is therefore worthwhile.

Objectives: This study aimed to evaluate students' views on the processes, outcomes and impacts of medical electives in three low-income countries.

Methods: A qualitative study using purposeful sampling and semi-structured interviews was conducted. Participants were 29 Western students on medical electives at seven host sites in sub-Saharan Africa. A framework approach was used to analyse 872minutes of audio-recorded data.

Results: Students were highly positive about their experiences and seemed aware of their clinical limitations. Pre-departure training offered by some institutions was beneficial, but the content was perceived to be of little clinical relevance. Language barriers were the main challenges faced by students, even in places where English was the second language. Students who stayed longer, were nearer qualification or were based in rural units (rather than teaching centres) contributed more to patient care. Supervision was considered adequate but this appeared to be judged in a local context. Deliberate inappropriate practice was not encountered, but on occasion misunderstanding arose over the student's status.

Conclusions: Students who undertake electives in resource-poor countries appear to have clearly thought out and positive intentions, but current systems cause concern with reference to student activities and staff time, and require improvement. Instead of focusing on education benefits alone, students (and their sending institutions) need to consider other approaches through which host communities can more clearly benefit. Effective pre-departure preparation should become a requirement.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)593-603
Number of pages11
JournalMedical Education
Volume48
Issue number6
Early online date8 May 2014
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Jun 2014

Cite this

Western medical students' experiences on clinical electives in sub-Saharan Africa. / Kumwenda, Ben (Corresponding Author); Royan, David; Ringsell, Paige; Dowell, Jon.

In: Medical Education, Vol. 48, No. 6, 06.2014, p. 593-603.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Kumwenda, B, Royan, D, Ringsell, P & Dowell, J 2014, 'Western medical students' experiences on clinical electives in sub-Saharan Africa', Medical Education, vol. 48, no. 6, pp. 593-603. https://doi.org/10.1111/medu.12477
Kumwenda, Ben ; Royan, David ; Ringsell, Paige ; Dowell, Jon. / Western medical students' experiences on clinical electives in sub-Saharan Africa. In: Medical Education. 2014 ; Vol. 48, No. 6. pp. 593-603.
@article{afbde1fa1ce949548ca4bab9614f3d94,
title = "Western medical students' experiences on clinical electives in sub-Saharan Africa",
abstract = "Context: Electives commonly represent a valued, enjoyed and formative part of medical training. However, there is little empirical evidence about students' preparedness, practices and perceptions of medical electives in resource-poor settings. Exploring what students do, why and under what circumstances is therefore worthwhile.Objectives: This study aimed to evaluate students' views on the processes, outcomes and impacts of medical electives in three low-income countries.Methods: A qualitative study using purposeful sampling and semi-structured interviews was conducted. Participants were 29 Western students on medical electives at seven host sites in sub-Saharan Africa. A framework approach was used to analyse 872minutes of audio-recorded data.Results: Students were highly positive about their experiences and seemed aware of their clinical limitations. Pre-departure training offered by some institutions was beneficial, but the content was perceived to be of little clinical relevance. Language barriers were the main challenges faced by students, even in places where English was the second language. Students who stayed longer, were nearer qualification or were based in rural units (rather than teaching centres) contributed more to patient care. Supervision was considered adequate but this appeared to be judged in a local context. Deliberate inappropriate practice was not encountered, but on occasion misunderstanding arose over the student's status.Conclusions: Students who undertake electives in resource-poor countries appear to have clearly thought out and positive intentions, but current systems cause concern with reference to student activities and staff time, and require improvement. Instead of focusing on education benefits alone, students (and their sending institutions) need to consider other approaches through which host communities can more clearly benefit. Effective pre-departure preparation should become a requirement.",
author = "Ben Kumwenda and David Royan and Paige Ringsell and Jon Dowell",
note = "Acknowledgements we would like to thank Dr Neil Merrylees, and primary contacts at study sites (whose anonymity is guaranteed) for their support of this study. Funding this study was funded by NHS Education for Scotland.",
year = "2014",
month = "6",
doi = "10.1111/medu.12477",
language = "English",
volume = "48",
pages = "593--603",
journal = "Medical Education",
issn = "0308-0110",
publisher = "WILEY-BLACKWELL",
number = "6",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Western medical students' experiences on clinical electives in sub-Saharan Africa

AU - Kumwenda, Ben

AU - Royan, David

AU - Ringsell, Paige

AU - Dowell, Jon

N1 - Acknowledgements we would like to thank Dr Neil Merrylees, and primary contacts at study sites (whose anonymity is guaranteed) for their support of this study. Funding this study was funded by NHS Education for Scotland.

PY - 2014/6

Y1 - 2014/6

N2 - Context: Electives commonly represent a valued, enjoyed and formative part of medical training. However, there is little empirical evidence about students' preparedness, practices and perceptions of medical electives in resource-poor settings. Exploring what students do, why and under what circumstances is therefore worthwhile.Objectives: This study aimed to evaluate students' views on the processes, outcomes and impacts of medical electives in three low-income countries.Methods: A qualitative study using purposeful sampling and semi-structured interviews was conducted. Participants were 29 Western students on medical electives at seven host sites in sub-Saharan Africa. A framework approach was used to analyse 872minutes of audio-recorded data.Results: Students were highly positive about their experiences and seemed aware of their clinical limitations. Pre-departure training offered by some institutions was beneficial, but the content was perceived to be of little clinical relevance. Language barriers were the main challenges faced by students, even in places where English was the second language. Students who stayed longer, were nearer qualification or were based in rural units (rather than teaching centres) contributed more to patient care. Supervision was considered adequate but this appeared to be judged in a local context. Deliberate inappropriate practice was not encountered, but on occasion misunderstanding arose over the student's status.Conclusions: Students who undertake electives in resource-poor countries appear to have clearly thought out and positive intentions, but current systems cause concern with reference to student activities and staff time, and require improvement. Instead of focusing on education benefits alone, students (and their sending institutions) need to consider other approaches through which host communities can more clearly benefit. Effective pre-departure preparation should become a requirement.

AB - Context: Electives commonly represent a valued, enjoyed and formative part of medical training. However, there is little empirical evidence about students' preparedness, practices and perceptions of medical electives in resource-poor settings. Exploring what students do, why and under what circumstances is therefore worthwhile.Objectives: This study aimed to evaluate students' views on the processes, outcomes and impacts of medical electives in three low-income countries.Methods: A qualitative study using purposeful sampling and semi-structured interviews was conducted. Participants were 29 Western students on medical electives at seven host sites in sub-Saharan Africa. A framework approach was used to analyse 872minutes of audio-recorded data.Results: Students were highly positive about their experiences and seemed aware of their clinical limitations. Pre-departure training offered by some institutions was beneficial, but the content was perceived to be of little clinical relevance. Language barriers were the main challenges faced by students, even in places where English was the second language. Students who stayed longer, were nearer qualification or were based in rural units (rather than teaching centres) contributed more to patient care. Supervision was considered adequate but this appeared to be judged in a local context. Deliberate inappropriate practice was not encountered, but on occasion misunderstanding arose over the student's status.Conclusions: Students who undertake electives in resource-poor countries appear to have clearly thought out and positive intentions, but current systems cause concern with reference to student activities and staff time, and require improvement. Instead of focusing on education benefits alone, students (and their sending institutions) need to consider other approaches through which host communities can more clearly benefit. Effective pre-departure preparation should become a requirement.

U2 - 10.1111/medu.12477

DO - 10.1111/medu.12477

M3 - Article

VL - 48

SP - 593

EP - 603

JO - Medical Education

JF - Medical Education

SN - 0308-0110

IS - 6

ER -